Well Done Labour
#61
I’m not sure I agree with that Proth. I’d say that the changes in society have exacerbated the number and nature of those conditions. They are now occurring more broadly, in more depth and sustained for longer. That isn’t to say life was always tough and that this generation has it worse - it doesn’t. It’s just different and as you’ve said yourself, the impact of covid and school closures (amongst other things) has been marked
Reply
#62
(03-10-2025, 08:29 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(03-09-2025, 10:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Sorry easy mix those two Vile people up.

Arf. True dat

(03-09-2025, 10:11 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Why do you think so many people are claiming sickness benefit?

Because they can?

Because there's been a massive rise in the diagnosis of all sorts of shit which used to be classed as "life"?

I have sympathy with this argument but where Labour if reports are to be believed true are going with penalising people with severe illness and disability by freezing PIP and other potential benefits I think would be a disgrace for a party that is supposed to look after the most vulnerable. It costs a lot more to look after or be a person with disability than it does the average person and to potentially do this is the lowest of the low.
Reply
#63
If you read the whole thing they are also going to increase support (financially and practically) for those that need and want to get back into work and also adopt a similar approach to Germany so that those recently made redundant get a higher rate than those long term unemployed.

I think all those things are reasonable.
Reply
#64
(03-10-2025, 10:59 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: If you read the whole thing they are also going to increase support (financially and practically) for those that need and want to get back into work and also adopt a similar approach to Germany so that those recently made redundant get a higher rate than those long term unemployed.

I think all those things are reasonable.

That means absolutely nothing to those that cannot no matter what stick or carrot is used work. Again if what’s been leaked is true they are cutting in real terms money from the most vulnerable, severely disabled or ill people and their carers. If it happens it’s unjustifiable and not at all reasonable.
Reply
#65
As said before Derek, the problem is that IDS and accompanying morons created a system that makes that distinction nigh on impossible without a total rethink and around 7 million re assessments. Unfortunately, you have to start somewhere.
Reply
#66
(03-10-2025, 11:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: As said before Derek, the problem is that IDS and accompanying morons created a system that makes that distinction nigh on impossible without a total rethink and around 7 million re assessments. Unfortunately, you have to start somewhere.

Really? They can conveniently change numerous aspects of the process but can’t separate those with severe illness and disability from others? That is nonsense and an excuse for an unjustifiable potential policy. If they don’t separate them from the rest that is an excuse to defend the indefensible, they already have individual categories within a universal system it’s a load of cobblers that it’s too difficult.
Reply
#67
Derek. There is 7 million PIP claimants. How do you propose you work that out in a few weeks? Come on fella. Your intentions and morals are sound but some kind of basis in the real world would make the whole debate a bit more possible to take seriously
Reply
#68
(03-10-2025, 01:43 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Derek. There is 7 million PIP claimants. How do you propose you work that out in a few weeks? Come on fella. Your intentions and morals are sound but some kind of basis in the real world would make the whole debate a bit more possible to take seriously

They are separated into 2 groups, the drill down goes no further than that. There is a marker for terminal illness. But it's all built in.

Edit sorry meant to quote Dekka.
Reply
#69
(03-10-2025, 01:43 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Derek. There is 7 million PIP claimants. How do you propose you work that out in a few weeks? Come on fella. Your intentions and morals are sound but some kind of basis in the real world would make the whole debate a bit more possible to take seriously

They have all the information they need to separate the severely disabled and sick from others. People are assessed ti determine what level of support they need. You’re excusing a potential appalling potential policy because the government are too inept, trying to rush through a flawed and morally bankrupt cuts to the most vulnerable or simply ambivalent to the plight that would plunge people into debt.
Reply
#70
(03-10-2025, 02:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-10-2025, 01:43 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Derek. There is 7 million PIP claimants. How do you propose you work that out in a few weeks? Come on fella. Your intentions and morals are sound but some kind of basis in the real world would make the whole debate a bit more possible to take seriously

They are separated into 2 groups, the drill down goes no further than that. There is a marker for terminal illness. But it's all built in.

Edit sorry meant to quote Dekka.
I know. Unfortunately it’s not designed for the type of quick data Derek wants but doesn’t currently exist. 

Derek - honestly the gulf between your simplistic ideas of a solution and the reality of the task is a Grand Canyon.

(03-10-2025, 02:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(03-10-2025, 01:43 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Derek. There is 7 million PIP claimants. How do you propose you work that out in a few weeks? Come on fella. Your intentions and morals are sound but some kind of basis in the real world would make the whole debate a bit more possible to take seriously

They are separated into 2 groups, the drill down goes no further than that. There is a marker for terminal illness. But it's all built in.

Edit sorry meant to quote Dekka.
I know. Unfortunately it’s not designed for the type of quick data Derek wants but doesn’t currently exist. 

Derek - honestly the gulf between your simplistic ideas of a solution and the reality of the task is a Grand Canyon.

(03-10-2025, 02:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(03-10-2025, 01:43 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Derek. There is 7 million PIP claimants. How do you propose you work that out in a few weeks? Come on fella. Your intentions and morals are sound but some kind of basis in the real world would make the whole debate a bit more possible to take seriously

They have all the information they need to separate the severely disabled and sick from others. People are assessed ti determine what level of support they need. You’re excusing a potential appalling potential policy because the government are too inept, trying to rush through a flawed and morally bankrupt cuts to the most vulnerable or simply ambivalent to the plight that would plunge people into debt.
You live in a wonderfully divorced world from the actual reality fella
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 3 Guest(s)