Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(03-05-2025, 09:43 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (03-05-2025, 09:37 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: In an address to the French people tonight Macron basically said, we cannot rely on America, we won’t abandon Ukraine, we’re going to have to fight Russia, we need to double defence expenditure and European nations need to work together on defence. Great stuff hopefully Europe will now start to get its act together.
It has to be paid for, and cuts, tax increases or whatever won't wash with citizens in European countries. It'll drive even more to vote for far-right butters who are happy for Ukraine to be overrun.
Meanwhile the Trump cult is starting to lean on judges who rule against him in cases. There's talk that said judges will stop receiving federal protection, leaving them open to physical attack by rabid MAGA loons. Democracy in the US is dying before our eyes.
Dying? It's already took a shit and died.
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
(03-05-2025, 09:37 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: In an address to the French people tonight Macron basically said, we cannot rely on America, we won’t abandon Ukraine, we’re going to have to fight Russia, we need to double defence expenditure and European nations need to work together on defence. Great stuff hopefully Europe will now start to get its act together.
Interesting as well that Macron reminded everyone in his speech that France had a nuclear deterrent, which can protect Europe, another reason why we don’t have to rely on America. First time I think any European leader has rattled the nuclear sabre.
Unfortunately, at the moment, both France and the UK's nuclear deterrent relies on US Technology and authorisation. If they switch it off, our deterrent goes....
I suspect the UK and France are working on that behind the scenes.
Posts: 4,751
Threads: 374
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(03-05-2025, 09:59 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: (03-05-2025, 09:37 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: In an address to the French people tonight Macron basically said, we cannot rely on America, we won’t abandon Ukraine, we’re going to have to fight Russia, we need to double defence expenditure and European nations need to work together on defence. Great stuff hopefully Europe will now start to get its act together.
Interesting as well that Macron reminded everyone in his speech that France had a nuclear deterrent, which can protect Europe, another reason why we don’t have to rely on America. First time I think any European leader has rattled the nuclear sabre.
Unfortunately, at the moment, both France and the UK's nuclear deterrent relies on US Technology and authorisation. If they switch it off, our deterrent goes....
I suspect the UK and France are working on that behind the scenes.
I fucking hope so. Otherwise we are relying on these deranged Trumpets.
Posts: 7,481
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
It’s impossible to work out how all this will play out. What’s for sure is the world and Europe is entering an incredibly dangerous period in the coming weeks and months
Posts: 1,712
Threads: 20
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
18
03-05-2025, 11:00 PM
(This post was last modified: 03-05-2025, 11:03 PM by fuzzbox.)
Slovakia and Hungary are going to stymie the EC, it'll be 'interesting' to see how the rest of Europe deals with this. Maybe a two-tier Europe will become necessary? Ironically, something that moderate brexiteers wanted...
(I was always and still am, remain. But there were some logical reasons to vote brexit)
Posts: 7,729
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
Intelligence sharing now paused. This will play out how Trump wants by the looks of things, UK and Europe doesn't have anything like the military intelligence capability of the US. I imagine there will be a ceasefire within days, minerals deal signed, borders redrawn as per the territory now held. No reparations aside from what has been frozen in assets, gained from sanctions.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(03-05-2025, 11:37 PM)Jacko Wrote: Intelligence sharing now paused. This will play out how Trump wants by the looks of things, UK and Europe doesn't have anything like the military intelligence capability of the US. I imagine there will be a ceasefire within days, minerals deal signed, borders redrawn as per the territory now held. No reparations aside from what has been frozen in assets, gained from sanctions.
Wrong, totally wrong.
In fact, UK is generally considered amongst the top of Western countries at intelligence gathering, we are exceptionally good at it with very few leaks and double agents compared to the US that has had an issue with such problems for years due to the size of their agencies being unmanageable. Quite often in Afghanistan, it was our intelligence used over the US equivalent. We know we will never have the strength in numbers the US or most countries we'll ever need to fight have over us, but we will be aware of what they're doing to make the most of what we do have, which is a strong reliance on our special forces due to the cutting down of our general military. The US may know more overall, we tend to be better at focussing, and if it's a very specific subject, we're arguably better.
We hold two cards over the US, and we play them well. Our intelligence gathering and analysis, as well as our special forces, are orders of magnitude better than theirs. It is not much, but we play them well.
What Trump has done is order us not to share any intelligence with Ukraine, that is going to be the big point now, do we follow what the US say, or do we deliver on our promise to support Ukraine, that will be the turning point for the 'special relationship'.
Posts: 7,729
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
03-06-2025, 12:15 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2025, 12:22 AM by Jacko.)
(03-06-2025, 12:04 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (03-05-2025, 11:37 PM)Jacko Wrote: Intelligence sharing now paused. This will play out how Trump wants by the looks of things, UK and Europe doesn't have anything like the military intelligence capability of the US. I imagine there will be a ceasefire within days, minerals deal signed, borders redrawn as per the territory now held. No reparations aside from what has been frozen in assets, gained from sanctions.
Wrong, totally wrong.
In fact, UK is generally considered amongst the top of Western countries at intelligence gathering, we are exceptionally good at it with very few leaks and double agents compared to the US that has had an issue with such problems for years due to the size of their agencies being unmanageable. Quite often in Afghanistan, it was our intelligence used over the US equivalent. We know we will never have the strength in numbers the US or most countries we'll ever need to fight have over us, but we will be aware of what they're doing to make the most of what we do have, which is a strong reliance on our special forces due to the cutting down of our general military. The US may know more overall, we tend to be better at focussing, and if it's a very specific subject, we're arguably better.
We hold two cards over the US, and we play them well. Our intelligence gathering and analysis, as well as our special forces, are orders of magnitude better than theirs. It is not much, but we play them well.
What Trump has done is order us not to share any intelligence with Ukraine, that is going to be the big point now, do we follow what the US say, or do we deliver on our promise to support Ukraine, that will be the turning point for the 'special relationship'.
Not the same type of intelligence. He's not giving them the satellite imagery, troop movements, communications intercepts, etc. This is a bigger blow than pausing the cash and weapons. He's leaving them blind.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(03-06-2025, 12:15 AM)Jacko Wrote: (03-06-2025, 12:04 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (03-05-2025, 11:37 PM)Jacko Wrote: Intelligence sharing now paused. This will play out how Trump wants by the looks of things, UK and Europe doesn't have anything like the military intelligence capability of the US. I imagine there will be a ceasefire within days, minerals deal signed, borders redrawn as per the territory now held. No reparations aside from what has been frozen in assets, gained from sanctions.
Wrong, totally wrong.
In fact, UK is generally considered amongst the top of Western countries at intelligence gathering, we are exceptionally good at it with very few leaks and double agents compared to the US that has had an issue with such problems for years due to the size of their agencies being unmanageable. Quite often in Afghanistan, it was our intelligence used over the US equivalent. We know we will never have the strength in numbers the US or most countries we'll ever need to fight have over us, but we will be aware of what they're doing to make the most of what we do have, which is a strong reliance on our special forces due to the cutting down of our general military. The US may know more overall, we tend to be better at focussing, and if it's a very specific subject, we're arguably better.
We hold two cards over the US, and we play them well. Our intelligence gathering and analysis, as well as our special forces, are orders of magnitude better than theirs. It is not much, but we play them well.
What Trump has done is order us not to share any intelligence with Ukraine, that is going to be the big point now, do we follow what the US say, or do we deliver on our promise to support Ukraine, that will be the turning point for the 'special relationship'.
Not the same type of intelligence. He's not giving them the satellite imagery, troop movements, communications intercepts, etc. This is a bigger blow than pausing the cash and weapons. He's leaving them blind.
We can do that too, it's whether we do or not now since he has ordered us not to, I would like to think we are strong enough to ignore orders from a foreign orange cheeto wanting to lick Putins arse after he's had a strong curry.
Posts: 7,729
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
03-06-2025, 12:29 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-06-2025, 02:04 AM by Jacko.)
(03-06-2025, 12:23 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (03-06-2025, 12:15 AM)Jacko Wrote: (03-06-2025, 12:04 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (03-05-2025, 11:37 PM)Jacko Wrote: Intelligence sharing now paused. This will play out how Trump wants by the looks of things, UK and Europe doesn't have anything like the military intelligence capability of the US. I imagine there will be a ceasefire within days, minerals deal signed, borders redrawn as per the territory now held. No reparations aside from what has been frozen in assets, gained from sanctions.
Wrong, totally wrong.
In fact, UK is generally considered amongst the top of Western countries at intelligence gathering, we are exceptionally good at it with very few leaks and double agents compared to the US that has had an issue with such problems for years due to the size of their agencies being unmanageable. Quite often in Afghanistan, it was our intelligence used over the US equivalent. We know we will never have the strength in numbers the US or most countries we'll ever need to fight have over us, but we will be aware of what they're doing to make the most of what we do have, which is a strong reliance on our special forces due to the cutting down of our general military. The US may know more overall, we tend to be better at focussing, and if it's a very specific subject, we're arguably better.
We hold two cards over the US, and we play them well. Our intelligence gathering and analysis, as well as our special forces, are orders of magnitude better than theirs. It is not much, but we play them well.
What Trump has done is order us not to share any intelligence with Ukraine, that is going to be the big point now, do we follow what the US say, or do we deliver on our promise to support Ukraine, that will be the turning point for the 'special relationship'.
Not the same type of intelligence. He's not giving them the satellite imagery, troop movements, communications intercepts, etc. This is a bigger blow than pausing the cash and weapons. He's leaving them blind.
We can do that too, it's whether we do or not now since he has ordered us not to, I would like to think we are strong enough to ignore orders from a foreign orange cheeto wanting to lick Putins arse after he's had a strong curry.
Can Europe fill the gaps?
If the freeze remains in place, Ukraine’s other Western allies will be left scrambling to fill another US hole. Given that, for the moment, they are forbidden from passing on to the Ukrainians US intelligence to which they have access, the task will be harder still.
Britain and its European allies have already been sharing intelligence with Ukraine and supporting its forces on the battlefield. RAF RC-135V Rivet Joint reconnaissance aircraft and French surveillance planes operate in the Black Sea and both countries would be able to offer some intelligence.
But it would not be of the same quantity, quality or timeliness as the Americans – with far less “live” information likely to be made available.
The access to speedy, real-time US intelligence has been one of the most important aspects of Ukraine’s survival in its three-year campaign to defend its territory from Russian aggression. Without it, Ukraine’s soldiers and civilians will be facing a far more perilous future.
Telegraph.
We just haven't got the quality or quantity of technology in the exosphere. Whether we refuse to share US intelligence we have access to is a different story, I'd imagine we would given we could lose said access.
|