It looks like for the most part we're not going to agree on the war's origins, so for the sake of argument let's accept a popular view on here (the West has no responsibility in any way for this war, neither does Ukraine, it is entirely Russia's fault, it is motivated by Russian expansionism, Putin is the incarnation of Hitler, to suggest otherwise is treason or the work of a Russian agent, I know this because all my information on the subject comes from British TV, radio, and newspapers).
https://x.com/LionelMedia/status/1896192766184657274
Now what? What exactly does victory look like?
Are you trying to regain Khruschev's 1950s borders and take Crimea back? Or just Stalin's 1930s borders?
What with? Ukraine has already probably taken close to a million killed and seriously wounded. They will have to drop their conscription age to 18 to continue a war of attrition with a country with five times the population, who haven't mobilised yet.
If you did more of the same, what exactly are you expecting? Russia has enough, or their population does and overthrow the leadership? A possibility in an authoritarian country, but it doesn't seem likely - the only serious insurrection was due to the war not being pursued aggressively enough.
If Ukraine did start winning Russia go the next step up the escalation ladder. I suspect if Crimea was threatened they would use nuclear weapons. If they are forced to mobilise the conscripts you get one chance at that, so they probably keep rolling west to Germany if that happens.
The only realistic chance of beating them in a conventional war would be open deployment of NATO infantry, which under present conditions would clock the high hundreds killed in action every day. That's what we list in twenty years of Afghanistan. Would also require a wartime economy and austerity in Europe, with no cheap energy sources.
The reality is Ukraine never stood a chance, has been reliant on NATO from the start, and every time they have turned down an offer the next one has been worse (25 year lease on Sevastopol to loss of Crimea to loss of rebel territory to loss of Russian speaking territory to whatever they eventually end up with).
What I would do in their position is acknowledge they have been exploited as a NATO pawn, admit defeat (like they did a week in in Istanbul) and open immediate discussions for terms before things get worse. I would then set about prosecuting the corrupt politicians who set them up.
The reality is this war is a proxy one, using NATO army surplus and Ukrainian bodies to do our dirty work. For us it's already been a partial success as the intention was never for Ukraine to 'win' but for Russia to be weakened. Didn't end up in its collapse, but always next time. If you don't believe me ask Lyndsey Graham.
https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2023/06...v-j01.html
Anyway, got to go, my shift at the Russian embassy starts now.