Trump vs Zelensky
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

So, Putin keeps Crimea in return for stopping kill more in Ukraine. What about reparations to rebuild what he's destroyed?? You said compromise on both sides, then listed major compromises for Ukraine and minor ones for Russia.

Russia could withdraw from Donbas etc... but you can sure as he'll be sure he'll keep his agents in there until they stoke enough fires for the regions to declare that they are Russian. There's so much more to this than just moving troops back out.

The UN is effectively useless at monitoring such things, Russian interference would be through the roof, as it was in US and Europe elections.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 10:44 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

So, Putin keeps Crimea in return for stopping kill more in Ukraine. What about reparations to rebuild what he's destroyed?? You said compromise on both sides, then listed major compromises for Ukraine and minor ones for Russia.

Russia could withdraw from Donbas etc... but you can sure as he'll be sure he'll keep his agents in there until they stoke enough fires for the regions to declare that they are Russian. There's so much more to this than just moving troops back out.

The UN is effectively useless at monitoring such things, Russian interference would be through the roof, as it was in US and Europe elections.

So the bloodshed continues? Because Russia won't give up Crimea or make reparations to the areas they've flattened.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 10:44 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

So, Putin keeps Crimea in return for stopping kill more in Ukraine. What about reparations to rebuild what he's destroyed?? You said compromise on both sides, then listed major compromises for Ukraine and minor ones for Russia.

Russia could withdraw from Donbas etc... but you can sure as he'll be sure he'll keep his agents in there until they stoke enough fires for the regions to declare that they are Russian. There's so much more to this than just moving troops back out.

The UN is effectively useless at monitoring such things, Russian interference would be through the roof, as it was in US and Europe elections.

and West Bromwich Albion message boards!
Reply
Ukraine should offer China 50% of the minerals in return for protection... f Trump off.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

The only actionable security guarantee for Ukraine after this is to join NATO. They already had a guarantee of security from the US for handing over the Soviet nuclear weapons they inherited with the Budapest Memorandum and how well has that worked out for them? Even prior to the US election Biden's administration was dragging their feet over aid every step of the way, including interfering with our attempts to provide military aid.

The only way handing Crimea over will work in practicality if if there's a UN-managed demilitarised corridor from the Russian border to Crimea, but the question is then who stations peacekeeping forces there? Would the Russians countenance Turkey?
Reply
(03-04-2025, 10:51 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:44 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

So, Putin keeps Crimea in return for stopping kill more in Ukraine. What about reparations to rebuild what he's destroyed?? You said compromise on both sides, then listed major compromises for Ukraine and minor ones for Russia.

Russia could withdraw from Donbas etc... but you can sure as he'll be sure he'll keep his agents in there until they stoke enough fires for the regions to declare that they are Russian. There's so much more to this than just moving troops back out.

The UN is effectively useless at monitoring such things, Russian interference would be through the roof, as it was in US and Europe elections.

So the bloodshed continues? Because Russia won't give up Crimea or make reparations to the areas they've flattened.

I said you said compromises on both sides, then listed compromises from Ukraine and not really any from Russia. That's the trouble, and is basically the way Trump is approaching it.

Russia keeps Crimea, Ukraine compromise
Russia leaves the rest and pays for the rebuilding, Russian compromise
Ukraine doesn't join NATO, Ukraine compromise

That's 2 compromises to 1, but that's better than just Ukraine compromising.

Sure they can ask for Russian non aggression deals, but they had them before and Russia ignored them, which was what Zelensky got attacked for saying in the White House. Nothing Russia signs is binding without the West / NATO being involved.

If Putin could be trusted then fine, but he can't be trusted, so if you were Ukraine would you risk it?

I'm convinced that however it plays out Russia will be pulling strings in the background to try and invite a civil war after they leave anyway. Unless NATO is involved, which is Putin's main / visible excuse for what he's done.
Reply
(03-04-2025, 11:09 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:51 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:44 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(03-04-2025, 10:19 AM)richbaggie Wrote: The only route out of this, without further bloodshed, is compromise on both sides. But I can't see appetite for that from either Putin or Zelensky.

But would Putin go for this which would then put the onus on Zelensky

Russia withdraw but keep Crimea.
Ukraine drop their wish to join Nato but receive guarantee of protection from NATO if Russia attack again.
Election held in Ukraine which is monitored closely by the UN.

So, Putin keeps Crimea in return for stopping kill more in Ukraine. What about reparations to rebuild what he's destroyed?? You said compromise on both sides, then listed major compromises for Ukraine and minor ones for Russia.

Russia could withdraw from Donbas etc... but you can sure as he'll be sure he'll keep his agents in there until they stoke enough fires for the regions to declare that they are Russian. There's so much more to this than just moving troops back out.

The UN is effectively useless at monitoring such things, Russian interference would be through the roof, as it was in US and Europe elections.

So the bloodshed continues? Because Russia won't give up Crimea or make reparations to the areas they've flattened.

I said you said compromises on both sides, then listed compromises from Ukraine and not really any from Russia. That's the trouble, and is basically the way Trump is approaching it.

Russia keeps Crimea, Ukraine compromise
Russia leaves the rest and pays for the rebuilding, Russian compromise
Ukraine doesn't join NATO, Ukraine compromise

That's 2 compromises to 1, but that's better than just Ukraine compromising.

Sure they can ask for Russian non aggression deals, but they had them before and Russia ignored them, which was what Zelensky got attacked for saying in the White House. Nothing Russia signs is binding without the West / NATO being involved.

If Putin could be trusted then fine, but he can't be trusted, so if you were Ukraine would you risk it?

I'm convinced that however it plays out Russia will be pulling strings in the background to try and invite a civil war after they leave anyway. Unless NATO is involved, which is Putin's main / visible excuse for what he's done.

In an ideal world, I wouldnt give any concessions to Putin at all. However, the one thing we know about Putin is he rarely,  if ever, compromises. To get to any deal to end the bloodshed, it's going to have to be in his favour. Returning to the situation territory wise of 3 years ago is probably going to be the only compromise he'll consider.
Reply
Not a chance!
We can suggest sensible compromise if we like.
Putin won't accept anything less than total victory, however it's couched.
The only solution is probably the status quo (Ukraine loses huge territory) and a security guarantee. Which seems to mean US support.
But even that means a measure of trust in Putin...!
Reply
Basically they need to hire The Jackal and get him to off Putin (heck Trump too)... Then they might get somewhere.

I was wondering how safe the planes that Zelensky has been globe trotting on are, seems an obvious target to me.
Reply
Crimea won't even be mentioned. The borders will be redrawn as they are now. Ukraine won't join NATO.

That's how Trump has decided the war will end. The alternative is they continue fighting, either until 4 years pass and there is a new man in the White House or until Ukraine runs out of conscripts.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: