Heading back - today
#21
(03-02-2025, 08:32 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Wildsmith gets the majority of the blame, I'm not denying that. But watch Bartley's movement when the cross comes in. He's no where near the attacker, whom he was touch tight to seconds earlier. He was caught switching off, lost his man, and allowed him to get the header in.

It was more a GK error, and that should lead to Griffiths coming in, I'd hope, but Bartley should be doing better in that situation.

He was responsible for the man in front of him mate. As a defender you always are.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#22
(03-02-2025, 09:46 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 08:23 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Throw all the meaningless stats around you want, you simply can't deny or argue that he was partly to blame for the Leeds goal yesterday. He regularly loses his attacker through poor positioning and reading of the game. You don't need stats to understand and see that!

He did, however, redeem himself with an excellent block late on in the second half. That's his strength - putting his body on the line with blocks, tackles and heading. He's good at the very basics, but is liable to switching off and leaving us open. But then again, most defenders at this level won't be at it for 90 mins.

Let's not pretend he's some sort of Messiah that we can't do without, eh.

Does he improve us when he plays? Not for me, no. He's average, at best.
He has good games, he has bad games. He does a job 90% of the time, and has been a decent servant for the club. Nothing more, nothing less.

Pretty much everyone I spoke to after the game spoke about how important Bartley is to us now and how much he improves us as a defensive unit when he plays. Our stats over the last couple years of how we do with him in the team to how we do without him also back this up.

It's wildly wrong to say we aren't better with him in the team.

Not to ignore any weaknesses it's his ability to organise himself and those around him that make him a shoe in as our first choice centre back currently.
Reply
#23
(03-02-2025, 09:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 08:32 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Wildsmith gets the majority of the blame, I'm not denying that. But watch Bartley's movement when the cross comes in. He's no where near the attacker, whom he was touch tight to seconds earlier. He was caught switching off, lost his man, and allowed him to get the header in.

It was more a GK error, and that should lead to Griffiths coming in, I'd hope, but Bartley should be doing better in that situation.

He was responsible for the man in front of him mate. As a defender you always are.

Not wishing to jump on the Kyle-bashing bandwagon here, but let's not reinvent history. "The man in front of him" ran round behind Bartley while Bartley was ball watching. This left Heggem with two men to mark. I've read elsewhere on here that Heggem "bottled" the challenge. Not fair, it was Bartley who lost his man and it's typical of his performances - all of our defenders have a momentary lapse in them.

Don't know what Wildsmith was doing and it's also worth pointing out that the cross came in far too easily, as they often do from our right flank. Pulis would have been fumin'.
Reply
#24
(03-02-2025, 02:20 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 09:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 08:32 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Wildsmith gets the majority of the blame, I'm not denying that. But watch Bartley's movement when the cross comes in. He's no where near the attacker, whom he was touch tight to seconds earlier. He was caught switching off, lost his man, and allowed him to get the header in.

It was more a GK error, and that should lead to Griffiths coming in, I'd hope, but Bartley should be doing better in that situation.

He was responsible for the man in front of him mate. As a defender you always are.

Not wishing to jump on the Kyle-bashing bandwagon here, but let's not reinvent history. "The man in front of him" ran round behind Bartley while Bartley was ball watching. This left Heggem with two men to mark. I've read elsewhere on here that Heggem "bottled" the challenge. Not fair, it was Bartley who lost his man and it's typical of his performances - all of our defenders have a momentary lapse in them.

Don't know what Wildsmith was doing and it's also worth pointing out that the cross came in far too easily, as they often do from our right flank. Pulis would have been fumin'.

At no point was Firpo the man in front, Dan James or Manor Solomon whichever one of them was wide left for them was playing just off Furlong's shoulder. Certainly not Heggems fault either. The whole thing was caused by the keepers poor kick and subsequent walk about. It was a good ball in from their lad as well.

EDIT - have taken the screen grabs from the match footage, Firpo starts as Furlong's man, then arguably should have been passed onto Mowatt who allows him to run and by the time either centre half should engage with him the ball is on the way and it's game over. Like I said, problem doesn't exist if the keeper wasn't so crap.
Reply
#25
(03-02-2025, 03:06 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 02:20 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 09:51 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(03-02-2025, 08:32 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Wildsmith gets the majority of the blame, I'm not denying that. But watch Bartley's movement when the cross comes in. He's no where near the attacker, whom he was touch tight to seconds earlier. He was caught switching off, lost his man, and allowed him to get the header in.

It was more a GK error, and that should lead to Griffiths coming in, I'd hope, but Bartley should be doing better in that situation.

He was responsible for the man in front of him mate. As a defender you always are.

Not wishing to jump on the Kyle-bashing bandwagon here, but let's not reinvent history. "The man in front of him" ran round behind Bartley while Bartley was ball watching. This left Heggem with two men to mark. I've read elsewhere on here that Heggem "bottled" the challenge. Not fair, it was Bartley who lost his man and it's typical of his performances - all of our defenders have a momentary lapse in them.

Don't know what Wildsmith was doing and it's also worth pointing out that the cross came in far too easily, as they often do from our right flank. Pulis would have been fumin'.

At no point was Firpo the man in front, Dan James or Manor Solomon whichever one of them was wide left for them was playing just off Furlong's shoulder. Certainly not Heggems fault either. The whole thing was caused by the keepers poor kick and subsequent walk about. It was a good ball in from their lad as well.

EDIT - have taken the screen grabs from the match footage, Firpo starts as Furlong's man, then arguably should have been passed onto Mowatt who allows him to run and by the time either centre half should engage with him the ball is on the way and it's game over. Like I said, problem doesn't exist if the keeper wasn't so crap.

Spot on pal.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#26
Wildsmith’s shakiness is a massive problem. His reluctance to come off his line except when he does but actually shouldn’t clearly concerns those in front of him.
Reply
#27
(03-02-2025, 04:00 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Wildsmith’s shakiness is a massive problem. His reluctance to come off his line except when he does but actually shouldn’t clearly concerns those in front of him.

Agree. Griffiths to start on Saturday for me, Probably the only change I would make

Asked earlier about Maja. Anyone know when he is back ? Him for Swift for the run in could secure play offs.
Reply
#28
(03-01-2025, 08:34 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Proud of us today - almost like an away at OT or Anfield.  We were really good and all the Leeds fans admitted we were easily value for a point. They won’t have many harder games than that. Bodies on the line and some attacking with intent. Got to improve decision making. Marks

Wildsmith 5 crap kick and then didn’t come for the cross for the goal. Double error and just doesn’t inspire confidence

Great write up Manc. This is my issue with Wildsmith. I don't think he organises his defence and he doesn't seem a commanding presence to me. 

I'm still baffled how in got in ahead of Griffiths. 6'6 England U21 player who we've managed well with his loans like we did with Palmer. He'd played all season for Bristol Rovers, was their player of the season, and had the best keeper stats in the division. He was match ready and should have been given the gig over Wildsmith who had been on the bench all season.

I'm not saying Wildsmith is a terrible keeper. He looks like a decent shot stopper to me but I firmly believe Griffiths is the better keeper.
Reply
#29
Wildsmith isn’t terrible but he’s firmly in the low quartile of keepers I’ve seen over the last 40 plus years. Clearly above the handful of absolute clowns
Reply
#30
Zuberhowler is possibly the worst GK I've seen.

Wildsmith is definitely a better GK than him.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: