Just back, ratings.
#1
Wildo- 6 culpable for the opener, not troubled otherwise
Furgs-7 terrible defensively, great header earns us a point (the goal gets him a 7)
Heggo-6 bottled the challenge for the Leeds goal, several mistakes could of cost us
Barts-6 looked rusty, disappointing distribution 
Style-6 did a job both going forward and defensively, nothing spectacular 
Mows-6 quiet game, poor set pieces. 
Swift-7 great assist, unlucky not to score, tired towards the end 
MJ-7 caused Leeds trouble every time he got the ball
Price-7 looks better out wide than in the middle
AA- 6 huffed and puffed, should of scored 
Subs
Diang-6 didn’t improve us
Grant-7 looked dangerous, why doesn’t he start? 
Dike-6 tried hard, needs to get up to speed
Fellows-6 see Diang, not sure what’s up with him, seriously out of form.

TM-Got it right.

Marks (for clarification)
Everyone starts with a 6, assists, goals, clean sheets move you up a mark, anything detrimental moves you down a mark.
Reply
#2
You missed Molumby!

Wildsmith 5
Furlong 7
Styles 7
Bartley 8
Heggem 7
Mowatt 7
Molumby 7
Swift 7
Price 7
Mikey 7
AA 5

Subs:
Tom 5
KG 5
Diangana 7
Reply
#3
Oops!

Apologies, 1 to many beers today.

Mols gets a 7, never stopped running, great interceptions
Reply
#4
(03-01-2025, 05:07 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: You missed Molumby!

Wildsmith 5
Furlong 7
Styles 7
Bartley 8
Heggem 7
Mowatt 7
Molumby 7
Swift 7
Price 7
Mikey 7
AA 5

Subs:
Tom 5
KG 5
Diangana 7

These are much better marks but my opinion is 8 Price and 7 Bartley but most were excellent today. That’s the benchmark.
Reply
#5
(03-01-2025, 05:07 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: You missed Molumby!

Wildsmith 5
Furlong 7
Styles 7
Bartley 8
Heggem 7
Mowatt 7
Molumby 7
Swift 7
Price 7
Mikey 7
AA 5

Subs:
Tom 5
KG 5
Diangana 7

Spot on for me. The post above said Grant looked dangerous?  To my mind he added nothing. Defence did great to nullify the best attack in the league. But for us fluffing a few good chances, and Wildsmith having another brain fart, we would have won today. Mowbray definitely stamping his mark on the team now.
Reply
#6
Wildsmith 4 - at fault for the goal and kicked it straight out of play about a dozen times. Griffiths has to come in.

Furlong 7 - difficult day against 3 excellent players Soloman, Firpo and Gnonto, popped up with a great equaliser.
Bartley 7 - defence look far better organised imo and it's down to Bartley. Won plenty in the air.
Heggem 6 - Not his best day particularly in possession but some excellent interventions.
Styles 6 - struggled defensively with James but so much of our players is directed through him.

Mowatt 6.5 - controlled the midfield when we got on the ball.
Molumby 6 - a liability in possession but covered every blade of grass today.

Price 7.5 (MOTM) - Played off the right, his pressing was superb, his set pieces excellent. Would love to see what he can do next to Mowatt in the 8.
Swift 7 - played well today, obvious Mowbray likes him, he's a clever player, laid back demeanor doesn't help with the fans, should have scored.
Johnston 7 - some brilliant footwork, created a wonderful chance that Furlong couldn't convert.

Armstrong 6 - one chance he got he half hit it and Meslier smothered it, hard runner but we need to get him more involved or go back to Dike when he's ready.

Grant 6 - didn't contribute up front when he first came on, or off the left last ten mins.
Diangana 6.5 - did enough in his cameo to notch up half a point, seems to have a decent understanding with Dike.

Dike 6 - put himself about well shame we couldn't fashion him a half chance.
Fellows 5 - has to do much much better running through on goal.
Reply
#7
We’ve just drawn away at Leeds, and really could have won, I think having so many 5-6s is harsh.

Based on what I saw of the game!

Wildsmith 5 - has to take some blame for the goal and had a couple shaky moments. Griffith next week please.

Furlong 8 - great goal, nearly won it, and did his job against probably the best left side in the league.
Bartley 7.5 - leadership and experience at the back. Shows what we miss without him - we lose that game with Holgate.
Heggem 5.5- shares blame for goal with Wildsmith, Bartley helped him, he struggled today.
Styles 6 - bullied by Leeds, and his defensive weaknesses showed widen facing very good opposition.

Mowatt 7 - did a lot of defensive work, think he was involved in several blocks, and kept us ticking over when we had our better spells in possession
Molumby 7 - The game passed him by for long spells but he popped up with some crucial blocks and his running meant Tanaka couldn’t take control of the midfield like he has so regularly.

Price 8.5 - this kid looks the real deal - MOTM, and showed the defensive nouse and game intelligence he has! Looking a bargain.
Swift 6.5 - loses a point for that terrible miss. Steady throughout.
Johnston 6.5 - struggles against the very top teams… think he would find PL football a step too far.

Armstrong 6 - ran, wasn’t much on for him today. My Saints supporting friends say they’re shocked how many goals he got for them as he rarely makes a clean connection with the ball and scuffs so many!

Grant 5 - not sure he touched the ball
Grady 7 - showed some decent turnovers and lovely ball to set Fellows off
Dike 6 - Pleased to see him using his frame confidently
Fellows 5 - loses a mark for that touch. Really ought to have worked the keeper at the very least.
Reply
#8
If you go to the best team in the league and come away with a point, despite going behind, it’s hard to mark anyone down. Wasn’t a lucky point either, so 7’s all round for me with shouts to Johnston, Mowatt and Furlong. Wouldn’t even mark Wildsmith down as it’s more a misjudgment than a glaring error. I’d give Price a rounded up 9 as motm.
Reply
#9
(03-01-2025, 07:20 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: If you go to the best team in the league and come away with a point, despite going behind, it’s hard to mark anyone down. Wasn’t a lucky point either, so 7’s all round for me with shouts to Johnston, Mowatt and Furlong. Wouldn’t even mark Wildsmith down as it’s more a misjudgment than a glaring error. I’d give Price a rounded up 9 as motm.
On Wildsmith he gave the ball away by dallying on a clearance,then they scored from the next attack when he came off his line for a cross he was never getting near. If he had stayed on line the header would probably have gone done his throat. That to me is at least 3 goals he has been to blame for. Not a first choice keeper for me.
Has to be marked down for his errors.
Reply
#10
Now is the time for Mowbray to show some balls and drop Wildsmith.

We are playing a very average six out of ten Champ keeper when we have an 8 out of 10 one with the potential to be as good as Palmer sat on the bench.

Football is about playing your best players not being kind to people.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: