"I am not going to tell you where to pass..."
#71
(02-23-2025, 01:32 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:50 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:47 PM)Jerry Wrote: Going back to the OP initial comments regarding defined build up versus a more freedom approach I read a piece on the BBC web site -Why Guardiola's tactics stopped working amid rise of rapid football- which I think is relevant to the discussion (please do not focus on Man City but on the change to football styles). To sum it up CC was akin to  Man City controlled build up pattern of play where TM is trying to be more rapid football. You have to move with the times.

I think that's more to do with tactical approach. As I have said many times I didn't much care for CCs tactical approach. But it was bloody well implemented. 

Everything ToMo says is grand. He wants to us play hurtful, risky passes through the lines. He wants us to flood the box, he wants us to sustain attacks by counter pressing in their half if it's on. Now I just want to see that implemented in a controlled repeatable fashion.  Wink

Sightly confused by this one. How is a "risky pass" "implemented in a controlled repeatable fashion"?
 
The "controlled fashion" isn't the player playing the low percentage pass. It's the movements and patterns around the player in possession. How we move teams around and create space. 

Yesterday we definitely commited lots of players forwards. But by and large it seemed random and a bit chaotic in the final third. You need to create chaos in their box, but keep control of your possession and shape on the build up to try and get overloads and find space for your best players to utilise their skills. 

How many times do MJ and Fellows get the ball and they are double/tripled up on but we still don't seem to have players over anywhere?
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#72
(02-23-2025, 01:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 01:32 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:50 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:47 PM)Jerry Wrote: Going back to the OP initial comments regarding defined build up versus a more freedom approach I read a piece on the BBC web site -Why Guardiola's tactics stopped working amid rise of rapid football- which I think is relevant to the discussion (please do not focus on Man City but on the change to football styles). To sum it up CC was akin to  Man City controlled build up pattern of play where TM is trying to be more rapid football. You have to move with the times.

I think that's more to do with tactical approach. As I have said many times I didn't much care for CCs tactical approach. But it was bloody well implemented. 

Everything ToMo says is grand. He wants to us play hurtful, risky passes through the lines. He wants us to flood the box, he wants us to sustain attacks by counter pressing in their half if it's on. Now I just want to see that implemented in a controlled repeatable fashion.  Wink

Sightly confused by this one. How is a "risky pass" "implemented in a controlled repeatable fashion"?
 
The "controlled fashion" isn't the player playing the low percentage pass. It's the movements and patterns around the player in possession. How we move teams around and create space. 

Yesterday we definitely commited lots of players forwards. But by and large it seemed random and a bit chaotic in the final third. You need to create chaos in their box, but keep control of your possession and shape on the build up to try and get overloads and find space for your best players to utilise their skills. 

How many times do MJ and Fellows get the ball and they are double/tripled up on but we still don't seem to have players over anywhere?

I disagree, I felt if anything we had loads more options up front, which maybe the players aren't used to so they maybe made the wrong choice with the final balls.

I wouldn't call it chaotic at all. I've said all along I felt we were in total control, you can't have total control and it being chaotic.

Interestingly the highest passing stat I've found from yesterday was CCs Valencia, 92% passing accuracy. Didn't help them much though.
Reply
#73
(02-23-2025, 01:40 PM)MrBater Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 01:38 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 01:32 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:50 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:47 PM)Jerry Wrote: Going back to the OP initial comments regarding defined build up versus a more freedom approach I read a piece on the BBC web site -Why Guardiola's tactics stopped working amid rise of rapid football- which I think is relevant to the discussion (please do not focus on Man City but on the change to football styles). To sum it up CC was akin to  Man City controlled build up pattern of play where TM is trying to be more rapid football. You have to move with the times.

I think that's more to do with tactical approach. As I have said many times I didn't much care for CCs tactical approach. But it was bloody well implemented. 

Everything ToMo says is grand. He wants to us play hurtful, risky passes through the lines. He wants us to flood the box, he wants us to sustain attacks by counter pressing in their half if it's on. Now I just want to see that implemented in a controlled repeatable fashion.  Wink

Sightly confused by this one. How is a "risky pass" "implemented in a controlled repeatable fashion"?
 
The "controlled fashion" isn't the player playing the low percentage pass. It's the movements and patterns around the player in possession. How we move teams around and create space. 

Yesterday we definitely commited lots of players forwards. But by and large it seemed random and a bit chaotic in the final third. You need to create chaos in their box, but keep control of your possession and shape on the build up to try and get overloads and find space for your best players to utilise their skills. 

How many times do MJ and Fellows get the ball and they are double/tripled up on but we still don't seem to have players over anywhere?

I disagree, I felt if anything we had loads more options up front, which maybe the players aren't used to so they maybe made the wrong choice with the final balls.

I wouldn't call it chaotic at all. I've said all along I felt we were in total control, you can't have total control and it being chaotic.

Of course you can. We had full control over the game. Just not over our attacking play. 

You're right we had lots of bodies in the final third, as I said above. But Mowatt, Price, Molumby and Fellows are not dainty, tight spaces, types. That's why I think he got the team wrong yesterday. Either a focal point 9 to hit earlier with Armstrong off him, or another 10 to help us work opportunities in tight areas was needed.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#74
Plenty of comments during CC’s poor run that Mowatt needed to up his game. Maybe this comment is a sign that he’s falling back in love with football? Who knows, but I definitely read it as a positive.
Some players will be anxious at not having rigid, strict coaching, others will relish a bit of freedom. I imagine Mowbray will look to bring in players who fit the latter. Price and Armstrong certainly appear to.
Reply
#75
Our xG ended up at 2.72, against Pompey it was 2.9, so yesterday was almost as good as that for attacking play.

As far as I can tell these are our two highest xGs of the season... Both with TM in charge, so maybe he's trying to get things repeatable, or more than you're giving him credit for?

I still disagree, in that control and chaos are at odds.
Reply
#76
(02-23-2025, 12:31 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:24 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 09:05 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Mowatt quote from his post match presser when talking about the changes ToMo has made...

"I am not going to tell you where to pass the ball... You're all professional footballers"

I think this sums up our lack of cutting edge, spite and ruthlessness in front of goal. Relying on individuals to all make the right choices and sync up is a failed, outdated tactic. 

I am all for a more offensive approach, but attacking play has to be drilled and rehearsed as much as the defensive side.

Fuck me, it’s not FIFA 25 Josh.

We will continue to score more goals because of this.

Do you think Slot tells Salah where to pass.

Terrible example. 

Liverpool have the most repeatable, controlled, patterns of play of any team in the prem. The way they create over loads time and time again using well drilled approach play creates the space for the forward players to use their talent and skills. 

Oh and Salah in particular, another bad example. He pretty much does 3 things. And does them over and over again. And it works.

Oh, and I am not josh...

Apart from that though...

No it’s not, I’m sorry. They create overloads but the passing is not formulaic it’s done by having varied runners giving options to pass to. It also leads them open which is why they concede a fair few.

My lads at uni of Liverpool and has seen them a fair bit this year. They are a high press counter attacking team but not repetitive unless you mean winning.

As for Salah yep he does 3 things, score goals, assist goals and also lose the ball a fair bit.

Yes, I know you are not Josh the OP was obvious.
Reply
#77
(02-23-2025, 02:49 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:31 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:24 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 09:05 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Mowatt quote from his post match presser when talking about the changes ToMo has made...

"I am not going to tell you where to pass the ball... You're all professional footballers"

I think this sums up our lack of cutting edge, spite and ruthlessness in front of goal. Relying on individuals to all make the right choices and sync up is a failed, outdated tactic. 

I am all for a more offensive approach, but attacking play has to be drilled and rehearsed as much as the defensive side.

Fuck me, it’s not FIFA 25 Josh.

We will continue to score more goals because of this.

Do you think Slot tells Salah where to pass.

Terrible example. 

Liverpool have the most repeatable, controlled, patterns of play of any team in the prem. The way they create over loads time and time again using well drilled approach play creates the space for the forward players to use their talent and skills. 

Oh and Salah in particular, another bad example. He pretty much does 3 things. And does them over and over again. And it works.

Oh, and I am not josh...

Apart from that though...

No it’s not, I’m sorry. They create overloads but the passing is not formulaic it’s done by having varied runners giving options to pass to. It also leads them open which is why they concede a fair few.

My lads at uni of Liverpool and has seen them a fair bit this year. They are a high press counter attacking team but not repetitive unless you mean winning.

As for Salah yep he does 3 things, score goals, assist goals and also lose the ball a fair bit.

Yes, I know you are not Josh the OP was obvious.

Repeatable - Formulaic are two different things.

Salahs goals, assists and losing the ball are the result of the repetitive actions he does. Most of which are hurtful and low percentage but is what helps with his output.

He holds the width, plays 1-2s off the line breaking CM who is usually ahead of play and gets shots off. 

He drops in then spins in behind for a ball over the top from Trent or Gravenberch.

And he runs hard into the back post when Robertson or the left winger gets it. 

It's so repeatable and clear when you watch Liverpool. It's what makes them so good. Yes there's room for individual brilliance. But it's from within a really well oiled frame work.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#78
This method is no different to what Brian clough used to tell his players. Each player knew there jobs and responsibilities then he used to say go out there and play! It shouldn’t be rocket science
Reply
#79
You have to give players some freedom within a system, it’s a justifiable criticism of CC that his system was incredibly restrictive and made many games dull and formulaic. I must admit to scratching my head at fans who were regularly criticising Pulis but giving CC praise for creating very little in ‘entertainment’ or goals in a much poorer league.

Still he’s gone now and TM will be judged on results and as long as we are in the Playoffs then he’s done his job. If not then it’s again justifiable to question him and the decision to hire him.
Reply
#80
(02-23-2025, 03:13 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 02:49 PM)Jack Halford Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:31 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:27 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 12:24 PM)Jack Halford Wrote: Fuck me, it’s not FIFA 25 Josh.

We will continue to score more goals because of this.

Do you think Slot tells Salah where to pass.

Terrible example. 

Liverpool have the most repeatable, controlled, patterns of play of any team in the prem. The way they create over loads time and time again using well drilled approach play creates the space for the forward players to use their talent and skills. 

Oh and Salah in particular, another bad example. He pretty much does 3 things. And does them over and over again. And it works.

Oh, and I am not josh...

Apart from that though...

No it’s not, I’m sorry. They create overloads but the passing is not formulaic it’s done by having varied runners giving options to pass to. It also leads them open which is why they concede a fair few.

My lads at uni of Liverpool and has seen them a fair bit this year. They are a high press counter attacking team but not repetitive unless you mean winning.

As for Salah yep he does 3 things, score goals, assist goals and also lose the ball a fair bit.

Yes, I know you are not Josh the OP was obvious.

Repeatable - Formulaic are two different things.

Salahs goals, assists and losing the ball are the result of the repetitive actions he does. Most of which are hurtful and low percentage but is what helps with his output.

He holds the width, plays 1-2s off the line breaking CM who is usually ahead of play and gets shots off. 

He drops in then spins in behind for a ball over the top from Trent or Gravenberch.

And he runs hard into the back post when Robertson or the left winger gets it. 

It's so repeatable and clear when you watch Liverpool. It's what makes them so good. Yes there's room for individual brilliance. But it's from within a really well oiled frame work.

It is, you’re right but there are also options. No one knows what Nunez is going to do!!

It will take time for TM to drill what he wants into the players and comments from Mowatt to me are positive.

I liked how we were hard to beat under Carlos yet the football was often sterile. I’d much rather watch adventurous attacking football. The cycle of football has changed again from Peps slow controlled football.

I think TM deserves time to get his style across. 

We were lucky to get Carlos but he’s gone and we need let the owners continue to evolve the squad over the next few windows. Price and Bany seem excellent additions.

Enjoy the ride, it’s been a lot lot worse.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)