"I am not going to tell you where to pass..."
#31
(02-23-2025, 10:09 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 10:01 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think you have to give good players a certain latitude when they play.

I know some coaches want to micro manage every aspect of their teams play, but even someone like Guardiola can tell a player like De Bruyne where to pass the ball or tell Messi when to shoot or when to dribble. They know.

I agree completely. But it's what happens around then I want to see be more repeatable. 

For example, if MJ gets it in the inside left channel, like he does 20 times a game. I want to see the supporting players do the same time and time again. Whether that's Styles making a hurtful under lapping or over lapping run, a CM getting close for a 1-2. Anything really. But I want to see a game situation developing and almost know what our players are going to do. At the moment it all feels a bit random.

Sorry, but I don't know how you can say it was random. If anything it was too predictable. Get it wide, cross, get it wide, cross. There was a clear strategy yesterday whether we agree with it or not
Reply
#32
(02-23-2025, 10:11 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 10:09 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 10:01 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I think you have to give good players a certain latitude when they play.

I know some coaches want to micro manage every aspect of their teams play, but even someone like Guardiola can tell a player like De Bruyne where to pass the ball or tell Messi when to shoot or when to dribble. They know.

I agree completely. But it's what happens around then I want to see be more repeatable. 

For example, if MJ gets it in the inside left channel, like he does 20 times a game. I want to see the supporting players do the same time and time again. Whether that's Styles making a hurtful under lapping or over lapping run, a CM getting close for a 1-2. Anything really. But I want to see a game situation developing and almost know what our players are going to do. At the moment it all feels a bit random.

Sorry, but I don't know how you can say it was random. If anything it was too predictable. Get it wide, cross, get it wide, cross. There was a clear strategy yesterday whether we agree with it or not

We don't agree on crossing being the strategy  Big Grin

We always end up with loads of crosses when we don't force the agenda with our play. We get frustrated, play the safe pass, then lob it in. It's not a new issue. 

I think ToMo admitted we lacked cutting edge and didn't create enough. But with 3, 8s, 2 wingers and only one central attacking player it's always going to be hard to create good passing patterns in and around the box.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
(02-23-2025, 09:05 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Mowatt quote from his post match presser when talking about the changes ToMo has made...

"I am not going to tell you where to pass the ball... You're all professional footballers"

I think this sums up our lack of cutting edge, spite and ruthlessness in front of goal. Relying on individuals to all make the right choices and sync up is a failed, outdated tactic. 

I am all for a more offensive approach, but attacking play has to be drilled and rehearsed as much as the defensive side.

Sorry Lurk, I'm not having this. CC told them exactly where to stand and where to pass. We were more solid at the back, scored even fewer goals and got a similar reward in terms of points.

Yesterday's winning margin was narrow because Furlong missed a sitter, Ajayi had two free headers which didn't challenge the goalkeeper at all and their goalie also made a couple of fine saves to stop good efforts. The previous week, if Heggem's header had gone in instead of hitting the post we would have romped it IMO. The clinical skill of goalscoring is where we are weak - to some extent this is Carlos' legacy because free-scoring football wasn't his style or interest.

You seem to be looking for reasons to be unhappy with the situation. Your comments on the team yesterday indicate your mindset: "Let's hope he knows what he's doing. FFS", "I am genuinely at a loss. Hope he knows what he's doing".

Three points in the bag tell me that maybe he does know what he's doing.
Reply
#34
Under Corberan we had very predictable attacking patterns but that was part of the problem. We often looked to keep possession, shift the ball from one side to another and look to get Fellows one on one with his full back so that he could attack the byline. At times that felt like our only attacking option until Mikey arrived last Jan and added a threat on the left too. Once teams worked out that they couldn't let Mikey come inside and couldn't let Fellows go outside then we struggled a lot more to create. At the start of this season the Fellows/Maja combo was firing and we looked a threat again but once teams wised up to this we became less threatening again.
Mowbray even mentioned this after the Plymouth game where he said that the game plan to get it wide had failed - hence the subbing off of Mikey and Fellows.

Hopefully with time Mowbray will be able to allow the players to have a greater array of attacking options by encouraging forward runs, playing through the middle more, overloads out wide and flooding the box when we are in good positions.
Reply
#35
Well MJ has certainly taken Mowbray's instructions to heart. 

 I thought he was off to Villa Park with some of his meandering runs yesterday.  He forgot the bit about passing and kept running into three players and losing possession. 

 If he had lifted his head, and more importantly, others knew what pass was coming and where to be to receive it, we might have scored a few more goals.  That comes from coaching and repetition in training sessions. 

If we can get a settled forward line who know each other's game and where to move into space, the goals will come.  We're nowhere near that at the moment. 

But it does require some coaching input. That's what you're paid to do.
Reply
#36
(02-23-2025, 10:27 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-23-2025, 09:05 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Mowatt quote from his post match presser when talking about the changes ToMo has made...

"I am not going to tell you where to pass the ball... You're all professional footballers"

I think this sums up our lack of cutting edge, spite and ruthlessness in front of goal. Relying on individuals to all make the right choices and sync up is a failed, outdated tactic. 

I am all for a more offensive approach, but attacking play has to be drilled and rehearsed as much as the defensive side.

Sorry Lurk, I'm not having this. CC told them exactly where to stand and where to pass. We were more solid at the back, scored even fewer goals and got a similar reward in terms of points.

Yesterday's winning margin was narrow because Furlong missed a sitter, Ajayi had two free headers which didn't challenge the goalkeeper at all and their goalie also made a couple of fine saves to stop good efforts. The previous week, if Heggem's header had gone in instead of hitting the post we would have romped it IMO. The clinical skill of goalscoring is where we are weak - to some extent this is Carlos' legacy because free-scoring football wasn't his style or interest.

You seem to be looking for reasons to be unhappy with the situation. Your comments on the team yesterday indicate your mindset: "Let's hope he knows what he's doing. FFS", "I am genuinely at a loss. Hope he knows what he's doing".

Three points in the bag tell me that maybe he does know what he's doing.

Not sure why people are desperate to make it a race to the bottom? I haven't at any point compared CCs approach to ToMos, they are completely different. It's also worth noting that the way we played under CC wasn't what I like to see. It was far too controlled, risk averse and safe. 

I like vertical passing, hard running and counter pressing. But above all I like to see a team with an identity, clear structures and play with repeatable patterns, regardless of what that approach is. 

Since ToMo came back we have definitely taken the shackles off in terms of the amount of passes we make into the penalty area, the number of players we commit forward in possession, and the number of shots we take. That's great. It's a clear change of approach and I am here for it. I just want to see it looking more controlled and organised. 

Since the change of approach we have had more shots, higher total xG as a result, but we still are not creating many high quality individual goal scoring chances. That's what I want to see.

Regarding my comments pre game. I think I was right in terms of the team. 3 #8s, and an out and out winger who do not have that guile and craft in and around the box was never going to help us create high quality chances, which goes against what ToMo wants. If I see things I think dont make sense I will call it out, always have done regardless of results. 

I am desperate for ToMo to succeed. He over saw my favourite time as an Albion fan (along with Clarke) but I need to see more.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#37
Yesterday was a forgettable match, but a routine win with an ok performance.
We scored and won, but it was frustrating that we didn’t have the game comfortably wrapped up. That sometimes happens though.
Trying to use Mowatt’s words as a stick to beat Mowbray with seems a bit petty when we don’t really have much about yesterday to complain about.
It is relevant to compare with the Corberan regime and I certainly don’t think we’d have won that by 4-5 under him.
Mowbray is keeping us top 6 so far, we have more attacking intent, the football is more enjoyable, but we do seem a shade less defensively solid, although that was never tested yesterday.
TM has only been here a few weeks and he’s doing nicely enough. He’s still trying to get to know the players.
I just find there’s an element of fans eager to point out the problems when the overall situation is pretty satisfactory.
We’ve some tough games now, but if he can keep us top 6 come May he’ll have done a decent job.
Reply
#38
About right spando. Add some rainbow ribbons to that play off trophy and we’ll all be happy.
Reply
#39
(02-23-2025, 10:40 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Yesterday was a forgettable match, but a routine win with an ok performance.
We scored and won, but it was frustrating that we didn’t have the game comfortably wrapped up. That sometimes happens though.
Trying to use Mowatt’s words as a stick to beat Mowbray with seems a bit petty when we don’t really have much about yesterday to complain about.
It is relevant to compare with the Corberan regime and I certainly don’t think we’d have won that by 4-5 under him.
Mowbray is keeping us top 6 so far, we have more attacking intent, the football is more enjoyable, but we do seem a shade less defensively solid, although that was never tested yesterday.
TM has only been here a few weeks and he’s doing nicely enough. He’s still trying to get to know the players.
I just find there’s an element of fans eager to point out the problems when the overall situation is pretty satisfactory.
We’ve some tough games now, but if he can keep us top 6 come May he’ll have done a decent job.

I interpreted Mowatts words as him saying it is a positive thing...shackles off a bit and all that
Reply
#40
(02-23-2025, 09:16 AM)Sliced Wrote: In general I thought our passing was good in the build up play. The problem was we kept going wide and hitting cross after cross after cross and it wasn’t working.

I’m kind of splitting hairs though, it was a good performance and a good result

My issue yesterday was the amount of fugging short corners when it was obvious very early on it wasnt bloody working , i'm old school just get the ball in the box and let players attack the ball, it was a good tactic under Pullis( actually the only offensive tactic under Pullis)but more often than not it worked, why oh why are we so fugging shite at corners and it's set pieces in general, other than that think it was a controlled performance against a side that showed little or no real ambition.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)