Scotch whisky and English whisky dust-up
#1
H'mm:  https://www.thetimes.com/article/6606e3c...4bf3bdcde3

Probably a paywall, but the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) is objecting to a GI definition for English whisky that permits the worts and wash to be mashed and fermented by 3rd parties (ie brewers) and sent to the distillery for distillation and the rest.

The SWA says: "It would be very damaging for the reputation of single malt whisky from the UK, and by extension single malt Scotch whisky, if English whiskies were allowed to describe spirit as ‘Single Malt’ despite being produced in a different manner to the established process and longstanding traditions of the Scotch whisky industry."

I don't have a dog in this fight but if one thinks of "traditional" for English whisky, it has been common for worts made by third parties (brewers) to be sent under duty-suspension as feedstock to licensed/approved distillers for distillation. Actually, this started with Brain's sending beer/worts to The Welsh Whisky Company about early 1990s. In HMCE excise policy, we had to consider the application since the law is silent on it. The 1991 regs suppose that everything will be done in situ and, indeed, there isn't any consideration of anything but mashing and distilling of cereals. We took a flexible approach and permitted it. (I'm not sure that the Welsh distillation ever took place in the end).

So it is a "tradition" that perforce did not occur in Scotland.
Reply
#2
(02-20-2025, 02:53 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: H'mm:  https://www.thetimes.com/article/6606e3c...4bf3bdcde3

Probably a paywall, but the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) is objecting to a GI definition for English whisky that permits the worts and wash to be mashed and fermented by 3rd parties (ie brewers) and sent to the distillery for distillation and the rest.

The SWA says: "It would be very damaging for the reputation of single malt whisky from the UK, and by extension single malt Scotch whisky, if English whiskies were allowed to describe spirit as ‘Single Malt’ despite being produced in a different manner to the established process and longstanding traditions of the Scotch whisky industry."

I don't have a dog in this fight but if one thinks of "traditional" for English whisky, it has been common for worts made by third parties (brewers) to be sent under duty-suspension as feedstock to licensed/approved distillers for distillation. Actually, this started with Brain's sending beer/worts to The Welsh Whisky Company about early 1990s. In HMCE excise policy, we had to consider the application since the law is silent on it. The 1991 regs suppose that everything will be done in situ and, indeed, there isn't any consideration of anything but mashing and distilling of cereals. We took a flexible approach and permitted it. (I'm not sure that the Welsh distillation ever took place in the end).

So it is a "tradition" that perforce did not occur in Scotland.

Remember in the 1990`s, they used to sell `Swn- Y-Mor` Welsh whisky, also had Isle Of Man whisky.
Reply
#3
(02-20-2025, 02:58 PM)Ministry Of Silly Signings Wrote:
(02-20-2025, 02:53 PM)Hudds2 Wrote: H'mm:  https://www.thetimes.com/article/6606e3c...4bf3bdcde3

Probably a paywall, but the Scotch Whisky Association (SWA) is objecting to a GI definition for English whisky that permits the worts and wash to be mashed and fermented by 3rd parties (ie brewers) and sent to the distillery for distillation and the rest.

The SWA says: "It would be very damaging for the reputation of single malt whisky from the UK, and by extension single malt Scotch whisky, if English whiskies were allowed to describe spirit as ‘Single Malt’ despite being produced in a different manner to the established process and longstanding traditions of the Scotch whisky industry."

I don't have a dog in this fight but if one thinks of "traditional" for English whisky, it has been common for worts made by third parties (brewers) to be sent under duty-suspension as feedstock to licensed/approved distillers for distillation. Actually, this started with Brain's sending beer/worts to The Welsh Whisky Company about early 1990s. In HMCE excise policy, we had to consider the application since the law is silent on it. The 1991 regs suppose that everything will be done in situ and, indeed, there isn't any consideration of anything but mashing and distilling of cereals. We took a flexible approach and permitted it. (I'm not sure that the Welsh distillation ever took place in the end).

So it is a "tradition" that perforce did not occur in Scotland.

Remember in the 1990`s, they used to sell `Swn- Y-Mor` Welsh whisky, also had Isle Of Man whisky.
Swn Y Mor was the blend using Scotch and there may have been a single malt branded name from Tomatin.

There was also a Red Rose Lancs whisky "made" in Lancashire by reducing bulk scotch whisky with "local" water, hence turning it inot Lancashire whisky!
Reply
#4
Has the SWA got enough proof to support their case?
Reply
#5
(02-20-2025, 03:06 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Has the SWA got enough proof to support their case?

I dunno that the objection to the GI would be sustained as a matter of proof, but persuasion that the English GI - as they claim - would "devalue" the entire concept of a single malt in the UK, including the scotch whisky GI.  DEFRA will have to consider and they aren't much on techie matters - no doubt loads of lobbying and arm-twisting with them and the politicians.
Reply
#6
(02-20-2025, 03:12 PM)Hudds2 Wrote:
(02-20-2025, 03:06 PM)baggiebloke Wrote: Has the SWA got enough proof to support their case?

I dunno that the objection to the GI would be sustained as a matter of proof, but persuasion that the English GI - as they claim - would "devalue" the entire concept of a single malt in the UK, including the scotch whisky GI.  DEFRA will have to consider and they aren't much on techie matters - no doubt loads of lobbying and arm-twisting with them and the politicians.

So, if the Scotch can't persuade, enough, will they find their case on the rocks?
Reply
#7
No idea what half of this means, but I don't know anyone who says UK Whisky, it's always a specific country used. Scotch, English Whisky, Welsh Whisky etc... so I can't see what the fuss is about. Never gave much thought to a y of the processes, and only think of Scotch as the one that has lots of rules.
Reply
#8
(02-20-2025, 03:27 PM)MrBater Wrote: No idea what half of this means, but I don't know anyone who says UK Whisky, it's always a specific country used. Scotch, English Whisky, Welsh Whisky etc... so I can't see what the fuss is about. Never gave much thought to a y of the processes, and only think of Scotch as the one that has lots of rules.

Well, Welsh whisky has a GI (protected area status) which has a technical file that is drawn up by the producers and has to be followed (they are full of non-technical flowery bullshit as well), as has Irish whiskey (joint North and South).

English whisky doesn't, yet.  My own view is "what is the point at this stage?"  It's a bit of "well we want one!"

Scotch whisky GI is about brand protection for the big producers, mainly exports and for the UK government with I think about £5 billion+ in UK export earnings

By the way, there are many English producers NOT in the English Whisky Guild who are also objecting to the draft English whisky GI.
Reply
#9
I'm thinking if you cant even spell the word whiskey you probably shouldn't be the making the stuff
Reply
#10
(02-20-2025, 10:10 PM)Vinebaggie Wrote: I'm thinking if you cant even spell the word whiskey you probably shouldn't the making the stuff

This, especially if your drink looks like whiskey but actually tastes of soil. 
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)