Quickest manager we've sacked?
#41
(02-17-2025, 09:51 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 08:56 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 07:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 05:27 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I’ve read quite a few comments on here in recent months from posters saying they were really peed off at the time when we appointed Megson. It really surprised me as I remember both my Dad and I agreeing that it seemed a fairly sensible appointment. He’d done very well on a budget at Stockport and was unlucky to be at Stoke for such a short period. He was a good candidate when we were a pretty unappealing prospect for a lot of managers.

It think that says more about them than it does Megson.

(02-17-2025, 05:27 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote: I’ve read quite a few comments on here in recent months from posters saying they were really peed off at the time when we appointed Megson. It really surprised me as I remember both my Dad and I agreeing that it seemed a fairly sensible appointment. He’d done very well on a budget at Stockport and was unlucky to be at Stoke for such a short period. He was a good candidate when we were a pretty unappealing prospect for a lot of managers.

It think that says more about them than it does Megson.

I don’t think it does at all Derek. I think most of us felt the Meggo appointment was hugely underwhelming. I had already consigned myself to our certain relegation and didn’t think for a minute Megson would do anything to stop it. I was, of course, utterly delighted to be proven completely wrong but I feel like you’re re-writing history to make yourself look like some sort of paragon of fairness and insight. If you were excited by Meggo’s appointment you were one of very few, wise Baggies.
Indeed. Very little to suggest the Gary Megson that walked in would walk out Sir Gary Megson, club legend.
Glad he did though.

Precisely. Megson was underwhelming, whilst I’m happy to admit I thought Brian Little would be brilliant.
Too many people invest too much of their ego trying to make themselves look so wise on footballing matters.
Just best to treat each managerial appointment with a neutral attitude and if your opinion is negative then be humble enough to hope you are proven wrong.

Why? Football managers and players get paid a fortune for ultimately a soap opera played out on a rectangle of grass. It makes fug all difference if a fan is ‘humble’ or ‘arrogant’ in their assessment of their abilities. My reply was in response to a poster on here who said exactly the same thing to me with regards to TM because I dared not to share the same opinion as he did. I just thought I’d use to get a few bites Wink 

That said quite who some of our fans were expecting at the time always baffled me. We were losing £30k a week, the players had to bring their own food for breakfast, we were training on borrowed pitches, and the scrappy patch of grass by the old ticket office. Oh and we were fighting it out with bloody Walsall to stay up. We were a shambles on and off the pitch, who exactly of any proven stature was going to think twice about coming to us at the time? It had to be a manager with something to prove, dare I say it hungry to succeed and relatively unproven. GM was a good fit he had been doing well at Stoke until the Icelandic owners bought the club, and again at Stockport, he was eloquent and sounded intelligent unlike most managers at the time.
Reply
#42
(02-17-2025, 11:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:51 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 08:56 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 07:52 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It think that says more about them than it does Megson.


It think that says more about them than it does Megson.

I don’t think it does at all Derek. I think most of us felt the Meggo appointment was hugely underwhelming. I had already consigned myself to our certain relegation and didn’t think for a minute Megson would do anything to stop it. I was, of course, utterly delighted to be proven completely wrong but I feel like you’re re-writing history to make yourself look like some sort of paragon of fairness and insight. If you were excited by Meggo’s appointment you were one of very few, wise Baggies.
Indeed. Very little to suggest the Gary Megson that walked in would walk out Sir Gary Megson, club legend.
Glad he did though.

Precisely. Megson was underwhelming, whilst I’m happy to admit I thought Brian Little would be brilliant.
Too many people invest too much of their ego trying to make themselves look so wise on footballing matters.
Just best to treat each managerial appointment with a neutral attitude and if your opinion is negative then be humble enough to hope you are proven wrong.

Why? Football managers and players get paid a fortune for ultimately a soap opera played out on a rectangle of grass. It makes fug all difference if a fan is ‘humble’ or ‘arrogant’ in their assessment of their abilities. My reply was in response to a poster on here who said exactly the same thing to me with regards to TM because I dared not to share the same opinion as he did. I just thought I’d use to get a few bites Wink 

That said quite who some of our fans were expecting at the time always baffled me. We were losing £30k a week, the players had to bring their own food for breakfast, we were training on borrowed pitches, and the scrappy patch of grass by the old ticket office. Oh and we were fighting it out with bloody Walsall to stay up. We were a shambles on and off the pitch, who exactly of any proven stature was going to think twice about coming to us at the time? It had to be a manager with something to prove, dare I say it hungry to succeed and relatively unproven. GM was a good fit he had been doing well at Stoke until the Icelandic owners bought the club, and again at Stockport, he was eloquent and sounded intelligent unlike most managers at the time.
Not sure who we were expecting either but it wasn't Meggo, not in my corner of the world anyhow! I worked in a, predominantly, Baggies / Wolves place at the time and the Baggies were in uproar, whilst the Wolves were pissing themselves. Those chickens certainly came home to roost not long after!  Smile

As for his record prior, as always, it's subjective. From my perspective at the time, he had a mare at Norwich, did an average job at Stockport and lasted 22 games at Stoke, (ironically,the same as AFI lasted here). Coming from a Stokie family, I can definitely say that the ones I was close to did not rate him, at all, and were also pissing themselves at his appointment at B71!

Happy to be one of the many who were wrong, whatever it says about me, although, maybe it just says I can admit not being right all the time, which is not such a bad thing.  Smile
Reply
#43
(02-18-2025, 09:05 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 11:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:51 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 08:56 PM)UCEbaggie Wrote: I don’t think it does at all Derek. I think most of us felt the Meggo appointment was hugely underwhelming. I had already consigned myself to our certain relegation and didn’t think for a minute Megson would do anything to stop it. I was, of course, utterly delighted to be proven completely wrong but I feel like you’re re-writing history to make yourself look like some sort of paragon of fairness and insight. If you were excited by Meggo’s appointment you were one of very few, wise Baggies.
Indeed. Very little to suggest the Gary Megson that walked in would walk out Sir Gary Megson, club legend.
Glad he did though.

Precisely. Megson was underwhelming, whilst I’m happy to admit I thought Brian Little would be brilliant.
Too many people invest too much of their ego trying to make themselves look so wise on footballing matters.
Just best to treat each managerial appointment with a neutral attitude and if your opinion is negative then be humble enough to hope you are proven wrong.

Why? Football managers and players get paid a fortune for ultimately a soap opera played out on a rectangle of grass. It makes fug all difference if a fan is ‘humble’ or ‘arrogant’ in their assessment of their abilities. My reply was in response to a poster on here who said exactly the same thing to me with regards to TM because I dared not to share the same opinion as he did. I just thought I’d use to get a few bites Wink 

That said quite who some of our fans were expecting at the time always baffled me. We were losing £30k a week, the players had to bring their own food for breakfast, we were training on borrowed pitches, and the scrappy patch of grass by the old ticket office. Oh and we were fighting it out with bloody Walsall to stay up. We were a shambles on and off the pitch, who exactly of any proven stature was going to think twice about coming to us at the time? It had to be a manager with something to prove, dare I say it hungry to succeed and relatively unproven. GM was a good fit he had been doing well at Stoke until the Icelandic owners bought the club, and again at Stockport, he was eloquent and sounded intelligent unlike most managers at the time.
Not sure who we were expecting either but it wasn't Meggo, not in my corner of the world anyhow! I worked in a, predominantly, Baggies / Wolves place at the time and the Baggies were in uproar, whilst the Wolves were pissing themselves. Those chickens certainly came home to roost not long after!  Smile

As for his record prior, as always, it's subjective. From my perspective at the time, he had a mare at Norwich, did an average job at Stockport and lasted 22 games at Stoke, (ironically,the same as AFI lasted here). Coming from a Stokie family, I can definitely say that the ones I was close to did not rate him, at all, and were also pissing themselves at his appointment at B71!

Happy to be one of the many who were wrong, whatever it says about me, although, maybe it just says I can admit not being right all the time, which is not such a bad thing.  Smile

Bob I posted the ‘it says more’ comment in response to another poster saying that about me for not being a huge fan of TM. I was woefully wrong about Bruce and I might be wrong about TM.

With regards to Megson he joined at a time when we were in danger of going bust and a shambles, we had to take a risk on an unproven manager or a journeyman, we were in no position to go for a tried and tested manager. I was genuinely happy with his appointment and grew up in a WBA, Villa area.  You win some you lose some with assessing managers.
Reply
#44
(02-18-2025, 09:59 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-18-2025, 09:05 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 11:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:51 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-17-2025, 09:01 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Indeed. Very little to suggest the Gary Megson that walked in would walk out Sir Gary Megson, club legend.
Glad he did though.

Precisely. Megson was underwhelming, whilst I’m happy to admit I thought Brian Little would be brilliant.
Too many people invest too much of their ego trying to make themselves look so wise on footballing matters.
Just best to treat each managerial appointment with a neutral attitude and if your opinion is negative then be humble enough to hope you are proven wrong.

Why? Football managers and players get paid a fortune for ultimately a soap opera played out on a rectangle of grass. It makes fug all difference if a fan is ‘humble’ or ‘arrogant’ in their assessment of their abilities. My reply was in response to a poster on here who said exactly the same thing to me with regards to TM because I dared not to share the same opinion as he did. I just thought I’d use to get a few bites Wink 

That said quite who some of our fans were expecting at the time always baffled me. We were losing £30k a week, the players had to bring their own food for breakfast, we were training on borrowed pitches, and the scrappy patch of grass by the old ticket office. Oh and we were fighting it out with bloody Walsall to stay up. We were a shambles on and off the pitch, who exactly of any proven stature was going to think twice about coming to us at the time? It had to be a manager with something to prove, dare I say it hungry to succeed and relatively unproven. GM was a good fit he had been doing well at Stoke until the Icelandic owners bought the club, and again at Stockport, he was eloquent and sounded intelligent unlike most managers at the time.
Not sure who we were expecting either but it wasn't Meggo, not in my corner of the world anyhow! I worked in a, predominantly, Baggies / Wolves place at the time and the Baggies were in uproar, whilst the Wolves were pissing themselves. Those chickens certainly came home to roost not long after!  Smile

As for his record prior, as always, it's subjective. From my perspective at the time, he had a mare at Norwich, did an average job at Stockport and lasted 22 games at Stoke, (ironically,the same as AFI lasted here). Coming from a Stokie family, I can definitely say that the ones I was close to did not rate him, at all, and were also pissing themselves at his appointment at B71!

Happy to be one of the many who were wrong, whatever it says about me, although, maybe it just says I can admit not being right all the time, which is not such a bad thing.  Smile

Bob I posted the ‘it says more’ comment in response to another poster saying that about me for not being a huge fan of TM. I was woefully wrong about Bruce and I might be wrong about TM.

With regards to Megson he joined at a time when we were in danger of going bust and a shambles, we had to take a risk on an unproven manager or a journeyman, we were in no position to go for a tried and tested manager. I was genuinely happy with his appointment and grew up in a WBA, Villa area.  You win some you lose some with assessing managers.
Fair enough. 
I was in my 20's at the time so was not as tolerant and had slightly less common sense!  Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: