Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I don't know how many times it needs saying but Mowbray didn't have to come in and change anything. The team was functional for the most part, the addition of attacking quality should have helped but there's no need for him to rip up what was a decent blueprint. Bruce did it was Ismael's team and you can see the signs of history repeating itself.
Posts: 2,182
Threads: 163
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation:
7
I’m not calling for him to go but do we really have the time to trust the process?
From what I’ve read (and I’m happy to be corrected), failing to get promoted this year would complete the process of becoming a true midtable championship club and by that I mean we won’t have the quality of player we have now.
I’m not sure what the answer is but from where I’m sitting we’re going to need a big slice of luck to make the play offs let alone get anywhere near winning them.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
Red card for the most twatty modern day football expression ‘trust the process’.
Posts: 121
Threads: 1
Joined: Feb 2025
(02-16-2025, 04:37 AM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: It seems a lot of fans are struggling to accept what is happening to us, which is understandable because we haven't been in this position for years.
Normally a change of Manager is driven by a sacking due to poor performances, rather than what happened with CC (poached because he was doing a good job). In cases like this the new Manager gets the team playing differently, which (normally) results in a 'new manager bounce' and you see an improvement in results.
Looking at the team over the last few games, it's clear that under CC they were drilled to within an inch of their lives, with a plan of possession football overwhelming teams until you score, then sit back to defend what you have.
Most of the time it worked, and CC even had to cope with huge changes to the starting 11 with limited reinforcements available to him (remember when we lost Barts and Semi together and Styles was bought in to cover). However we longed for the shackles to be removed when we had teams on the rack and we also longed for a striker to support Maja.
CC went to Valencia (can't blame him to be honest) and due to what seemed to be a glaring oversight in our recruitment process (who knew you had to check availability of the required support staff before offering a contract) we ended up with Mowbray, who was not our first choice.
There was much optimism on his appointment, especially from those who remember his first tenure with us. However, some had reservations (the never go back scenario). Personally I would not have offered him the job. I have nothing against TM...he's universally liked by the football community and has an excellent track record. For me it was his previous illness. Cancer is a shitshow (I've been there) and some types are fuckers of the highest order. Bowel cancer especially is not one of the good ones to get (if there is such a thing). Symptoms are often overlooked/not seen until it's too late. The other thing with BC is the reoccurrence rate. It often comes back (I believe the stats are over 60%), more virulent than before. Please don't get me wrong I wish TM a long and healthy life, but I would not have appointed him for this reason.
Anyway, back to the footie....
From being organised we seem to have regressed to a team that lacks organisation, and at times a questionable formation. I watched the first 30 mins of the game yesterday and struggled to see what we were playing. We have become less assured at the back, with some of our defending more akin to Sunday league that Championship. You also have to wonder where some of TM's comments have come from (the early comments around Grant, and that he's gone from a strong contender for POTS under CC to a shadow of the player he was). Some of his tactical decisions have us scratching our heads (AA playing on the left yesterday when we had MJ on the bench, and AA one of the best number 9s in the Championship, for example).
There seems to be more negative than positive at the moment. Our fans will give him time, but unfortunately unless things start to improve the negative voices will get louder and louder.
We have a squad now that could easily secure a top six finish....we know this because we were there before TM took over, and most of the shortfalls we all saw (lack of a striker and box to box midfielder, for example) have been met in the Jan transfer window.
TM just needs to grasp the situation quicker than he's currently doing. If only we could be as organised as we were under CC, but with the freedom to keep going forward when we could and players playing in their preferred positions, with the recent additions to the squad, we would all feel happier sailing on HMS PissTheLeague than we do at the moment. Good post.i feel the same..I think we shouldn’t have given him the job though and certainly not a 2 1/2 yrs contract unless there’s a break clause at end of season. It just feels like it’s not going to work out.
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
02-16-2025, 09:41 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-16-2025, 09:45 AM by Stillclem4england.)
(02-16-2025, 08:29 AM)Sliced Wrote: Ok but there's also trusting the process Pardew style where you have a bad start and it just never picks up (this is what happens more frequently). I think there needs to be something resembling a plan even in the early games. At the moment I see the plan from Nestor and the board but not the manager. The good news is that Mowbray has a decent managerial record across his career so I'm hoping there's more to come. I am struggling to think of a manager with a poor / very average start who has gone on to be a success.
The most successful of my lifetime have had a pretty much immediate impact:
Ardiles
Meggo
Pulis
Clarke
Roy
Carlos
You could say some had a pre-season - which is fair - but a number of those took over mid season with a team that was heading down…
(02-16-2025, 08:41 AM)Sliced Wrote: (02-16-2025, 08:39 AM)mickeypearce Wrote: (02-16-2025, 08:29 AM)Sliced Wrote: Ok but there's also trusting the process Pardew style where you have a bad start and it just never picks up (this is what happens more frequently). I think there needs to be something resembling a plan even in the early games. At the moment I see the plan from Nestor and the board but not the manager. The good news is that Mowbray has a decent managerial record across his career so I'm hoping there's more to come.
The worrying thing is Slice is that Bruce also had a more than decent record and look how that turned out.
That's a good point.
I'm not panicked about it, we're somehow still top 6 so TM still in a good position to crack on. I’m less worried by the position / points total than what I see on the pitch: good players suddenly regressing to terrible players, no discernible style of play, brilliantly drilled defence playing like a Sunday league team.
As others have said on here, 80% of what we were doing was ok. You could arguably have left everything and just brought in a striker. I currently cannot see one player playing well or one area of the team looking solid.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-16-2025, 09:46 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-16-2025, 09:49 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(02-16-2025, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Red card for the most twatty modern day football expression ‘trust the process’.
No problem.
Some times managers come in and get things sorted right away, like Corberan or Hodgson. Sometimes it takes a little longer to get things on the right track.
I was underwhelmed when we appointed Mowbray, but I’m happy to see him have a fair crack of the whip.
Wednesday night was awful, but there can be games like that.
What seems to be getting overlooked is after the handful of games at the start of the season, where we were top, the form has been distinctly mid table, and that was under CC too.
Remember those weeks upon weeks where we treated to turgid goalless games v teams allegedly worse than us?
I think some fans are just way too impatient and jumping to irrational conclusions. No doubt many of them will get a kick out of Mowbray failing to say I told you so.
I just find such negativity a really shitty trait.
It doesn’t mean we can’t voice concerns, but be measured.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(02-16-2025, 09:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-16-2025, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Red card for the most twatty modern day football expression ‘trust the process’.
No problem.
Some times managers come in and get things sorted right away, Luke Corberan or Hodgson. Sometimes it takes a little longer to get things on the right track.
I was underwhelmed when we appointed Mowbray, but I’m happy to see him have a fair crack of the whip.
Wednesday night was awful, but there can be games like that.
What seems to be getting overlooked is after the handful of games at the start of the season, where we were top, the form has been distinctly mid table, and that was under CC too.
I think some fans are just way too impatient and jumping to irrational conclusions. No doubt many of them will get a kick out of Mowbray failing to say I told you so.
I just find such negativity a really shitty trait.
He will be judged on results and resources. Imo that means we should make the playoffs, he has the rest of the season to achieve this. I’m not a fan of TM and wasn’t the first time he was at the club but the balls in his 18yard box.
Posts: 7,461
Threads: 373
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Agreed Derek, he should be judged at the end of the season on whether we make the play offs. Let’s hope for a bit more patience in that. I’ve always been in the middle with Mowbray, still am, I don’t get the polarisation of views on him at all. He very clearly has some good identifiable strengths and some clear areas he could be better.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-16-2025, 09:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (02-16-2025, 09:46 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-16-2025, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Red card for the most twatty modern day football expression ‘trust the process’.
No problem.
Some times managers come in and get things sorted right away, Luke Corberan or Hodgson. Sometimes it takes a little longer to get things on the right track.
I was underwhelmed when we appointed Mowbray, but I’m happy to see him have a fair crack of the whip.
Wednesday night was awful, but there can be games like that.
What seems to be getting overlooked is after the handful of games at the start of the season, where we were top, the form has been distinctly mid table, and that was under CC too.
I think some fans are just way too impatient and jumping to irrational conclusions. No doubt many of them will get a kick out of Mowbray failing to say I told you so.
I just find such negativity a really shitty trait.
He will be judged on results and resources. Imo that means we should make the playoffs, he has the rest of the season to achieve this. I’m not a fan of TM and wasn’t the first time he was at the club but the balls in his 18yard box. Fair play to you Derek. I think you strike the balance of healthy scepticism.
I found the appointment of Mowbray odd, in the way his style bore no resemblance with Corberan’s. To adjust things dramatically in the last half of the season is a hell of a risk.
I’m concerned and underwhelmed myself, but I’m happy to see how it all unfolds.
Posts: 988
Threads: 43
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation:
0
I think his appointment was seen as the safest bet amongst the candidates that were left to choose from.
We do need to give him time but we should expect some improvements game on game as he understands the squad better.
I didn't see any improvement from Wednesday to yesterday and as others have covered, a strange attack selection. That was the worst thing for me.
If Millwall had have have better finishers we would have been dead and buried. If we had had more luck in front of goal we would have won.
Hopefully he will have learned something this week.
|