Posts: 1,077
Threads: 70
Joined: Oct 2024
Reputation:
6
Ironically, what was required today was for someone to keep that ball and string a few passes together to just slow things down a little so that we could get some shape into the team, and players would be under less pressure to try and control a ball coming at them at 40 mph with a man on their back.
We've gone from endless pointless side-to-side passes in our own half, to get if forward at all costs as fast as possible. At times today it wasn't quite hoof ball, but it came very near it. We've gone from everyone knowing what their role is to nobody knowing what their role is. At times it was shambolic.
It was obvious that Grady has decided to do his own thing, and he did it very well. But he has a plan in his head as he goes forward but no one else knows what it is which results in the move fizzling out at the end of his run.
Grant has gone from being a key player who can change a game, to a bit-part player tasked with trying to get something from the game in the last 20 minutes. He was a candidate for player of the season before Mowbray arrived through his high work rate and sheer effort. Now he looks like a shadow of his former self and has no distinct role when he is brought on.
What on earth was Armstrong doing on the left FFS when you have MJ on the bench?
I said when Mowbray was appointed that it had a touch of the return of Johnny Giles about it, and regrettably I might be right for once.
Posts: 2,015
Threads: 71
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
1
All good points. And agreed about the return of Mowbray. It would be ideal if it works, but there’s a huge number of years between his times here.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-16-2025, 09:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-16-2025, 09:18 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust.
Giles has been out of the game for a long time when he came back and it all came apart.
Mowbray has consistently managed at this level in all the intervening years. Most recently he was guiding Blues to safety. He is also attributed by many Sunderland fans as laying the groundwork for the young exciting side they now have.
I’m not totally convinced with us appointing Mowbray, but a month in, with us being in the top 6, some of the opinions flying around are just ridiculously over the top especially when we have had to chop and change at the back and lost a very reliable goalkeeper.
With the likes of Leeds and Burnley coming up, I’m not going to be happy clapping, but I think some fans are being a bit too quick to start doing doomsday comparisons with Bruce and Giles 1985 style.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(02-16-2025, 09:08 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust.
Giles has been out of the game for a long time when he came back and it all came apart.
Mowbray has consistently managed at this level in all the intervening years. Most recently he was guiding Blues to safety. He is also attributed by many Sunderland fans as laying the groundwork for the young exciting side they now have.
I’m not totally convinced with us appointing Mowbray, but a month in, with us being in the top 6, some of the opinions flying around are just ridiculously over the top especially when we have had to chop and change at the back and lost a very reliable goalkeeper.
With the likes of Leeds and Burnley coming up, I’m not going to be happy clapping, but I think some fans are being a bit too quick to start doing doomsday comparisons with Bruce and Giles 1985 style.
Spot on. I posted similar the other day. If this was Wicky in charge or another Johnny foreigner that nobody had ever heard of they would be getting "he needs time to see the players in game situations to work out his best 11" etc etc. Because it's Mowbray he's getting "clueless" and "should be sacked" etc. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions but it looks way over the top to me.
This season is not a free hit. We do have some talent in our squad. We have bought in Armstrong, Price, Lankshear, Wildsmith to the starting 11. That's a third of a new first 11. We've lost (given away) a rock of a goal keeper who organised his defence. Bartley comes back and goes again for 3 games. There has been a lot of change.
Imo Mogga will get us in gear but it might be a bit bumpy for a few more weeks yet. Buckle in.
Posts: 7,444
Threads: 372
Joined: Sep 2024
Reputation:
33
Aye way too much flack way too soon when we are trying to transition style mid season with a set of players that have been drilled methodically for 2 seasons. Mowbray will be fine and we’ll both win and lose more games when we were doing under Drawberan.
Posts: 1,077
Threads: 70
Joined: Oct 2024
Reputation:
6
"There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust."
Putting aside the Giles comparison, I notice you've not taken me up on any of the tactical points.
Sending a group of players out to "express themselves" is straight from the first, and only page of "The Steve Bruce Book of Football Tactics" and is not a plan.
That's tactic 1.
Tactic 2 is to inexplicably play players out of position.
Tactic 3 is to tell the fans that they don't understand Tactics 1 and 2.
I gather the book was sponsored by Greggs.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-16-2025, 10:34 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-16-2025, 10:35 AM by Spandaubaggie.)
(02-16-2025, 10:24 AM)Old Fart Wrote: "There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust."
Putting aside the Giles comparison, I notice you've not taken me up on any of the tactical points.
Sending a group of players out to "express themselves" is straight from the first, and only page of "The Steve Bruce Book of Football Tactics" and is not a plan.
That's tactic 1.
Tactic 2 is to inexplicably play players out of position.
Tactic 3 is to tell the fans that they don't understand Tactics 1 and 2.
I gather the book was sponsored by Greggs.
Aside from a 2 minute Sky Sports highlights I’ve seen nothing of yesterday.
I found the line up odd, and it does seem an underwhelming performance, but it’s about results and we got a point.
Regards Armstrong, Mowbray knows him well and what makes him tick. Mowbray also has to experiment himself.
We are also integrating Price, Bany, Armstrong, Dike, Lankshear, Wildsmith all in this mix and having to keep vital players fresh.
I’m not denying that there’s not causes for concern.
Posts: 1,077
Threads: 70
Joined: Oct 2024
Reputation:
6
(02-16-2025, 10:34 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-16-2025, 10:24 AM)Old Fart Wrote: "There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust."
Putting aside the Giles comparison, I notice you've not taken me up on any of the tactical points.
Sending a group of players out to "express themselves" is straight from the first, and only page of "The Steve Bruce Book of Football Tactics" and is not a plan.
That's tactic 1.
Tactic 2 is to inexplicably play players out of position.
Tactic 3 is to tell the fans that they don't understand Tactics 1 and 2.
I gather the book was sponsored by Greggs.
Aside from a 2 minute Sky Sports highlights I’ve seen nothing of yesterday.
I found the line up odd, and it does seem an underwhelming performance, but it’s about results and we got a point.
Regards Armstrong, Mowbray knows him well and what makes him tick. Mowbray also has to experiment himself.
We are also integrating Price, Bany, Armstrong, Dike, Lankshear, Wildsmith all in this mix and having to keep vital players fresh.
I’m not denying that there’s a few causes for concern but starting a thread Sackable about a manager who has been here for a month and still has us in the top 6 is about as much an over reaction as you can get.
Where did I suggest he should be sacked?
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(02-16-2025, 10:24 AM)Old Fart Wrote: "There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust."
Putting aside the Giles comparison, I notice you've not taken me up on any of the tactical points.
Sending a group of players out to "express themselves" is straight from the first, and only page of "The Steve Bruce Book of Football Tactics" and is not a plan.
That's tactic 1.
Tactic 2 is to inexplicably play players out of position.
Tactic 3 is to tell the fans that they don't understand Tactics 1 and 2.
I gather the book was sponsored by Greggs. That med me loff!!!
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(02-16-2025, 10:35 AM)Old Fart Wrote: (02-16-2025, 10:34 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (02-16-2025, 10:24 AM)Old Fart Wrote: "There’s some huge over reactions to the form and style since Mowbray returned and this thread is right up there at the extreme end.
The comparison with the Giles return is totally unjust."
Putting aside the Giles comparison, I notice you've not taken me up on any of the tactical points.
Sending a group of players out to "express themselves" is straight from the first, and only page of "The Steve Bruce Book of Football Tactics" and is not a plan.
That's tactic 1.
Tactic 2 is to inexplicably play players out of position.
Tactic 3 is to tell the fans that they don't understand Tactics 1 and 2.
I gather the book was sponsored by Greggs.
Aside from a 2 minute Sky Sports highlights I’ve seen nothing of yesterday.
I found the line up odd, and it does seem an underwhelming performance, but it’s about results and we got a point.
Regards Armstrong, Mowbray knows him well and what makes him tick. Mowbray also has to experiment himself.
We are also integrating Price, Bany, Armstrong, Dike, Lankshear, Wildsmith all in this mix and having to keep vital players fresh.
I’m not denying that there’s a few causes for concern but starting a thread Sackable about a manager who has been here for a month and still has us in the top 6 is about as much an over reaction as you can get.
Where did I suggest he should be sacked? I re-edited but you replied to the original post in which I’d confused your thread with the one called sackable. It should make more sense now.
|