Snorethons
#31
Compare to 30/40 years ago so much is different. It's all been sanitised but taken much of the heart and soul out of it.

We have a more gentrified fan base mixed up with a very rigid safety first aspect in football.

For those old enough to recall terracing, today is a different animal altogether.

Football 1985 v 2025 like comparing a drive in a 1974 spitfire to a new four wheel drive with a sat nav.

It's so much better in many ways, but the overwhelming emptiness kills the soul.
Reply
#32
To say that seats make no difference is not strictly true. You only have to go to away games where the vast majority of people stand for the entire match and the atmosphere is generally better to see that.
Reply
#33
(02-14-2025, 10:59 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: To say that seats make no difference is not strictly true. You only have to go to away games where the vast majority of people stand for the entire match and the atmosphere is generally better to see that.

Yep, but it's because away fans are hard core. These are the fanatics.
Equally, many have been priced out of football or have other interests.
Reply
#34
(02-14-2025, 11:11 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 10:59 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: To say that seats make no difference is not strictly true. You only have to go to away games where the vast majority of people stand for the entire match and the atmosphere is generally better to see that.

Yep, but it's because away fans are hard core. These are the fanatics.
Equally, many have been priced out of football or have other interests.
Agreed - I think that this is where the safe standing argument gains some ground though. If we could designate an area of the ground for those supporters rather than them being dotted around the Brummie, Smethwick and East then I could see it being infectious around the ground, or at least provided noise to match the away end. 

Of course there are other considerations, and away fans go with family etc who may not travel away but it would be a step in the right direction.
Reply
#35
(02-15-2025, 12:11 PM)glassboybaggie Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 11:11 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 10:59 PM)baggiebuckster Wrote: To say that seats make no difference is not strictly true. You only have to go to away games where the vast majority of people stand for the entire match and the atmosphere is generally better to see that.

Yep, but it's because away fans are hard core. These are the fanatics.
Equally, many have been priced out of football or have other interests.
Agreed - I think that this is where the safe standing argument gains some ground though. If we could designate an area of the ground for those supporters rather than them being dotted around the Brummie, Smethwick and East then I could see it being infectious around the ground, or at least provided noise to match the away end. 

Of course there are other considerations, and away fans go with family etc who may not travel away but it would be a step in the right direction.

Yes, I reckon that would be a positive move.
Reply
#36
I think there is a LOT of revision on this subject and failure to appreciate why we may not be seeing such great atmospheres as we have over the last few seasons.

Firstly pre-Megson for at least a decade there were only fleeting moments where we had great atmospheres or even half decent crowds. Local derbies, the Everton cup run, promotion under Ardiles were highlights but many, many games were played out in half empty, near silent stadiums and yes people also left early. I know our middle aged, mcw forum would love to pretend the place has mostly being a hotbed of vociferous fervour but it hasn’t been.

The only consistently great atmosphere’s have been when we have been doing well or needed a win to stay up, reach the play-offs, gain promotion by battering teams each week, or punching above our financial weight in the Prem.

The atmosphere is flat currently because the team performances and club have plateaued and games don’t feel like they have much jeopardy currently. Add the identikit mind numbing game of chess that currently passes as football tactics since managers try and copy Pepball and hey-presto we have dull games, and dull atmospheres.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)