Snorethons
#21
I probably shouldn't give the argument the time of day, but I'll entertain it:

I can't say that I notice more women attending games now than 10/15 years back. It still seems mainly male dominated, and if I had to have a very rough go at the split I'd say it's 80% male 20% female. I could be completely way out, but that's the feel I get.

I've sat next to some right hooligan women (meant light-heartedly) who have given as good as any male in terms of singing.

It's a bizarre argument to make.

I just feel it's a societal problem. I bet if you put a poll on the 23 other teams forums and asked if they thought their atmosphere was better now, than say 10 years ago, I reckons all 23 would bot quite heavily 'no'.

Football is boring, I believe that's the massive elephant in the soulless stadia.
Reply
#22
(02-14-2025, 06:48 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote: I went mob handed with my family Weds night. 
First visit for a while - although i go away more for geographical reasons.

It was pretty much like a pre season friendly - players calls clearly heard, overhearing conversations behind me about the cultivation techniques of Bonsai Trees. You're in trouble when Blackburn outsing the Smethwick before a goal is scored.

I was sitting immediately next to a couple of Dutch lads (mid 50s) on a football tourism trip. They had been over here earlier in the season, did the North West. Midlands this time, and they went to Derby the night before, and had tickets for Villa. Bloody hell, i was embarrassed, and spent some considerable time almost apologising. I hope they didn't cherry pick us for our "atmosphere" - they even commented on it.

Cold, expensive, shit night factor magnified by finding a flat tyre on the car where we were parked. Post 2am back at The Welsh Riviera. It's getting less and less enjoyable.....

Jeez you have my sympathy mate, it was a bitterly cold miserable night but if I’d got back to a flat tyre on top of that I’d have probably jumped off the M5 bridge
Being brutally honest 
Reply
#23
(02-14-2025, 07:40 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 06:48 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote: I went mob handed with my family Weds night. 
First visit for a while - although i go away more for geographical reasons.

It was pretty much like a pre season friendly - players calls clearly heard, overhearing conversations behind me about the cultivation techniques of Bonsai Trees. You're in trouble when Blackburn outsing the Smethwick before a goal is scored.

I was sitting immediately next to a couple of Dutch lads (mid 50s) on a football tourism trip. They had been over here earlier in the season, did the North West. Midlands this time, and they went to Derby the night before, and had tickets for Villa. Bloody hell, i was embarrassed, and spent some considerable time almost apologising. I hope they didn't cherry pick us for our "atmosphere" - they even commented on it.

Cold, expensive, shit night factor magnified by finding a flat tyre on the car where we were parked. Post 2am back at The Welsh Riviera. It's getting less and less enjoyable.....

Jeez you have my sympathy mate, it was a bitterly cold miserable night but if I’d got back to a flat tyre on top of that I’d have probably jumped off the M5 bridge

Agreed. More sympathies LB. Walking across the M5 island I was probably the least enthusiastic I've ever been going to a game. Hope your curry was good.
Reply
#24
(02-14-2025, 07:52 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 07:40 PM)Beachboysbaggie Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 06:48 PM)Llandudno Baggie Wrote: I went mob handed with my family Weds night. 
First visit for a while - although i go away more for geographical reasons.

It was pretty much like a pre season friendly - players calls clearly heard, overhearing conversations behind me about the cultivation techniques of Bonsai Trees. You're in trouble when Blackburn outsing the Smethwick before a goal is scored.

I was sitting immediately next to a couple of Dutch lads (mid 50s) on a football tourism trip. They had been over here earlier in the season, did the North West. Midlands this time, and they went to Derby the night before, and had tickets for Villa. Bloody hell, i was embarrassed, and spent some considerable time almost apologising. I hope they didn't cherry pick us for our "atmosphere" - they even commented on it.

Cold, expensive, shit night factor magnified by finding a flat tyre on the car where we were parked. Post 2am back at The Welsh Riviera. It's getting less and less enjoyable.....

Jeez you have my sympathy mate, it was a bitterly cold miserable night but if I’d got back to a flat tyre on top of that I’d have probably jumped off the M5 bridge

Agreed. More sympathies LB. Walking across the M5 island I was probably the least enthusiastic I've ever been going to a game. Hope your curry was good.


An embarrassing night on and off the pitch, but absolutely nothing happened in that first half criminal given the wingers we have and a top class striker like Armstrong on the pitch.  Around me all I heard was understandable whinging and moaning. Of the people there Wednesday only real hard core supporters would return.
Reply
#25
I love the amnesia of many of our fans, I’ve been to numerous atmosphere free games in the 1990s.

I have to say that I find it quite difficult to get excited by watching us create barely any chances as we pass the ball sideways and backwards for huge chunks of games under both CC and now TM. As Josh said this is more about the chess like modern game more than individual managers.

In conclusion it’s a regular navel gazing topic when things are a bit shit.
Reply
#26
(02-14-2025, 03:02 PM)Laughing Gravy Wrote: What, if anything, do people think can be done to improve the atmosphere at The Hawthorns which has been generally pretty poor this season.Genuine question as I don't see playing at home gives us the advantage that it potentially should. 

I know some people will glibly just say playing better is the answer but surely, to a greater extent, supporters should be trying to lift the players, not the other way round. 

I don't know what the solution is but when in a crowd of 20k+ you can actually hear the players, it's not great.

 i know what you mean i just think most fans are just bored with modern day  possetion football
the only time they get excited is in the 2 transfer windows 
the days of me feeling proud of our fan base has long gone 
we  used to be a special fan  base that exceeded our attendance with the volume of our our support we had
but sadly not any more
still love my team  though
Reply
#27
(02-14-2025, 04:28 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I going to say it as it looks like no one else will, to many women going
Don’t help the atmosphere see lots of young lads taking their girl friends
To the game when I was young went with my mates I know it’s not pc
But it don’t help the atmosphere in my opinion.

You missed the impact that immigrants have had what with them not knowing the words to the songs, and FFS why they had to put boiler man in a rainbow outfit I don’t know, it’s just going to encourage them.



















Can you take the whoosh before you hit the ban button Midge
Reply
#28
At the end of the day fans will get off their seat...ooh and aah..sing etc..when summat happens. Like a shot at goal..
Lets be honest , watching this hardly gets ya going.
However , I also think football has become a bit of a bore generally. Everything seems predictable to me now..years ago , didnt seem to know what was gonna happen next. Many play the same way and cancel each other out...
And , as someone else has said..seats. Its never been the same since the terraces went.
Reply
#29
On a cold Wednesday watching our lot pass repeatedly straight to Blackburn players the most I shouted all night was ‘oh just fuck off’
Reply
#30
(02-14-2025, 10:22 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 04:28 PM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote: I going to say it as it looks like no one else will, to many women going
Don’t help the atmosphere see lots of young lads taking their girl friends
To the game when I was young went with my mates I know it’s not pc
But it don’t help the atmosphere in my opinion.

You missed the impact that immigrants have had what with them not knowing the words to the songs, and FFS why they had to put boiler man in a rainbow outfit I don’t know, it’s just going to encourage them.



















Can you take the whoosh before you hit the ban button Midge

Yup, last time I went there was a black guy sat near me and it meant none of us could monkey chant like we did in the old days ffs. 

I think there’s a lot of decent points on this thread, but ultimately I think there’s just a weariness around the club. We know that promotion will just see us hammered every week in the PL as we again  bank the money to try and keep us financially secure for another decade. For all the talk of ambition, what’s the end goal, we might have one season in Europe, but that is so, so, so far off it’s hardly worth getting excited by. This squad has also continually bottled any pressure games, and the lack of comeback wins, late goals, and our proclivity to play out draws means that the team needs to start giving the fans some reason to believe again. We should have been on cloud nine after the Wednesday winner, people on here were making out it was some kind of monumental turning point that would kickstart our promotion bid, only for this team to follow it up with a gutless and inept display where we were bullied off the pitch by a side without a manager and with a limited but hardworking group. When the players start to give the fans a reason to be hopeful the atmosphere will come, right now it’s just the expectation of an anticlimax.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)