Keeper scenario!?
#41
(02-12-2025, 10:54 PM)MrBater Wrote: Just wait for the meltdown when JG turns out to be no / not much better.

Reminds me of the debate when Sam Johnston was getting some stick... There were some on here saying that the reserve keeper was better, and should be given a go...
They were on the Button with that one!
Reply
#42
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.
Reply
#43
Last game Wildsmith was poor, and I hope Griffiths gets in next game, but lets be honest there's a lot of our fans that were desperate for his first mistake so they could jump on it.
Reply
#44
(02-14-2025, 09:55 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.
No one trying to make faults for Wildsmith but even though he had a decent match v Wednesday he pushed out the initial cross, straight to Pattersonand into danger. Also he was at fault with both goals against Blackburn.

(02-14-2025, 09:55 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.
No one trying to make a point but facts are facts. Wildsmith had a decent match v Wednesday but 
he pushed out the initial cross, straight to Patterson and into danger. Also he was at fault with both goals against Blackburnand wasn’t very convincing v Bournemouth. So in three of his first 4 matches for Albion he has not convinced me he can be our No1.He could still prove me wrong, but we have a 21year old who has had a terrific season and is highly regarded who should now be given the chance to show us his ability,so bring in Josh Griffiths.
Reply
#45
(02-14-2025, 11:00 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(02-14-2025, 09:55 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.
No one trying to make faults for Wildsmith but even though he had a decent match v Wednesday he pushed out the initial cross, straight to Pattersonand into danger. Also he was at fault with both goals against Blackburn.

(02-14-2025, 09:55 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.
No one trying to make a point but facts are facts. Wildsmith had a decent match v Wednesday but 
he pushed out the initial cross, straight to Patterson and into danger. Also he was at fault with both goals against Blackburnand wasn’t very convincing v Bournemouth. So in three of his first 4 matches for Albion he has not convinced me he can be our No1.He could still prove me wrong, but we have a 21year old who has had a terrific season and is highly regarded who should now be given the chance to show us his ability,so bring in Josh Griffiths.

I was talking about rewriting history about Griffiths, not Wildsmith.
Reply
#46
Josh Griffiths isn't 21, he's 23.
Reply
#47
(02-14-2025, 09:55 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.

Nah. Just the one determined to labour a point. Big Grin
Reply
#48
(02-14-2025, 09:55 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 08:22 PM)Josh1873 Wrote: Griffiths wasn't dodgy when he had is run when Palmer was out injured. He did absolutely fine.

Our fan base has their knives out for any GK that doesn't perform like prime Gordon Banks! It's worse than the fullback situation.

Spot on Josh.

People love to rewrite history to try and make a point sometimes. He did ok in his 1st team appearances, nothing calamitous, nothing outstanding. Yet some folks are saying he was poor or shakey at best.

Yep, but if I remember right he did look a bit nervous making his debut due to Palmers injury when he was just 21!!  

Apparently that's enough for some to put him in the bin.
Reply
#49
The biggest things to my mind are his lack of height, and he seems to have zero presence. I sit right at the front, behind the goals, and Palmer was constantly shouting and directing the defence. Wildsmith did non of this. The second goal against Blackburn, Palmer would have taken that cross easily. Griffiths has the stature of Palmer, and hopefully will be much more vocal. Hopefully Mowbray puts him in tomorrow. Another slip by Wildsmith and the boo boys will be all over him.
Reply
#50
(02-14-2025, 11:19 AM)GunsOfNavarone Wrote: Josh Griffiths isn't 21, he's 23.

When you reach my age you always take a couple of years off. Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: