Wildsmith
#1
Is he really better than Griffiths? Im not sure.
Reply
#2
He's not. But he's not as bad as is being made out. Definite Space Goating going on.

[Image: 87dc68aa029e0199e16864811e001ba10d241f1d.jpg]
Reply
#3
Imagine my surprise that Josh is wrong again...

At fault for 3 goals in 180 minutes of football, made one excellent save. Don't recall him catching any crosses, and his kicking on Saturday was particularly bad.

Coupled with the fact we've got one of the best young keepers in the country kicking his heels on the bench. This is just Button/Palmer revisited.
Reply
#4
Way out of his depth.

Absolutely has to be moved to the bench- at best
Reply
#5
(02-13-2025, 10:41 AM)Jacko Wrote: Imagine my surprise that Josh is wrong again...

At fault for 3 goals in 180 minutes of football, made one excellent save. Don't recall him catching any crosses, and his kicking on Saturday was particularly bad.

Coupled with the fact we've got one of the best young keepers in the country kicking his heels on the bench. This is just Button/Palmer revisited.

The only goal I will even entertain as him being at fault for is the Blackburn 1st goal. But it was still an excellent strike. 

I'm really not sure what he could have done any better for Wednesday's goal, and Blackburn's second - that's just poor defending on our part. 

I've also agreed Griffiths is the better GK and it's who I'd play as no.1.
Reply
#6
Wednesday's goal - not palm the ball into the middle of the box after getting a good hand on it.

Blackburn second - commit to collecting the ball instead of end up in no-man's land
Reply
#7
The second last night was parks keeping - absolutely dire
Reply
#8
(02-13-2025, 10:49 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Wednesday's goal - not palm the ball into the middle of the box after getting a good hand on it.

Blackburn second - commit to collecting the ball instead of end up in no-man's land

I think you're being extremely harsh. The Wednesday save was a good save initially, I'm not sure he had time to think about where to palm it. I'd blame the defenders for being flat footed and not reacting. 

Blackburn second - hesitation initially, but got back OK, and could do nothing with the finish. 

But he's not Palmer or Griffiths so people are looking for any excuse to criticise. I get it.
Reply
#9
(02-13-2025, 10:47 AM)Josh1873 Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 10:41 AM)Jacko Wrote: Imagine my surprise that Josh is wrong again...

At fault for 3 goals in 180 minutes of football, made one excellent save. Don't recall him catching any crosses, and his kicking on Saturday was particularly bad.

Coupled with the fact we've got one of the best young keepers in the country kicking his heels on the bench. This is just Button/Palmer revisited.

The only goal I will even entertain as him being at fault for is the Blackburn 1st goal. But it was still an excellent strike. 

I'm really not sure what he could have done any better for Wednesday's goal, and Blackburn's second - that's just poor defending on our part. 

I've also agreed Griffiths is the better GK and it's who I'd play as no.1.
It was well within his reach to come and collect but he bottled it. The fact that he started coming, put the rest of the defence into a false sense of security, but yes they should have kept going none the less.
For balance, I thought he was decent on Saturday so no spacegoating on my part. Nice picture by the way.
Reply
#10
(02-13-2025, 10:49 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Wednesday's goal - not palm the ball into the middle of the box after getting a good hand on it.

Blackburn second - commit to collecting the ball instead of end up in no-man's land

Watching the highlights the non commitment was my initial thought, but after a couple of views there was no way he'd have got to the ball, and if he'd kept going then Weimann would have just squared it even easier, and the striker would have had a simpler tap in, either option sees them score I think.

The punch against Weds, I did feel he should have done better with it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)