Shit Beard
#61
(02-10-2025, 02:26 PM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote:
(02-08-2025, 06:20 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(02-08-2025, 03:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Only saw the ref flash the red card. Was it deserved?

Having watched the highlights back it was definitely deserved. Such a daft thing to do. Hopefully Holgate will be well enough to play against Blackburn.

And there’s the problem right there. The highlights. I was there in the Halfords, square on to the incident,  non of the videos/pictures show the Sheffield “Victim” running with apparent murderous intent towards Mulumby. Bartley spotted him and put himself between the pair. By the time tv picked up the incident the mad Irishman had danced off towards the Brummie. As regards the blow, from the Brummie pictures it does look like a forearm but the pictures lie. I’ve seen one video that confirms what I thought and Bartley claimed at the time, it was a push in the top of the chest that slipped up to the face. Sheff player didn’t make a meal of it to be fair. Was it stupid? Yes, was it violent conduct, no. Red or yellow? Pays yer money and takes your choice.

Jesus, talking about going over the top! Maybe the police should get involved and begin criminal proceedings against this Yorkshire thug. Someone could have been killed!
Reply
#62
I hear the Sheff Weds player was choking and Bartley threw and arm to try and dislodge what was stuck in his airway.
Reply
#63
(02-10-2025, 05:05 PM)Sliced Wrote: I hear the Sheff Weds player was choking and Bartley threw and arm to try and dislodge what was stuck in his airway.

Reverse Heimlich. Quick thinking tbf.
Reply
#64
Looks like he was doing a Musk Salute and got his angles wrong.
Reply
#65
(02-10-2025, 05:01 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(02-10-2025, 02:26 PM)Stourbridge Baggie Wrote:
(02-08-2025, 06:20 PM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(02-08-2025, 03:03 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Only saw the ref flash the red card. Was it deserved?

Having watched the highlights back it was definitely deserved. Such a daft thing to do. Hopefully Holgate will be well enough to play against Blackburn.

And there’s the problem right there. The highlights. I was there in the Halfords, square on to the incident,  non of the videos/pictures show the Sheffield “Victim” running with apparent murderous intent towards Mulumby. Bartley spotted him and put himself between the pair. By the time tv picked up the incident the mad Irishman had danced off towards the Brummie. As regards the blow, from the Brummie pictures it does look like a forearm but the pictures lie. I’ve seen one video that confirms what I thought and Bartley claimed at the time, it was a push in the top of the chest that slipped up to the face. Sheff player didn’t make a meal of it to be fair. Was it stupid? Yes, was it violent conduct, no. Red or yellow? Pays yer money and takes your choice.

Jesus, talking about going over the top! Maybe the police should get involved and begin criminal proceedings against this Yorkshire thug. Someone could have been killed!

FFS wasn’t meant to be taken literally- point was he ran from clapping the Wednesday fans into the melee and the camera’s didn’t pick it up. I apologise for causing trauma by my use of words.
Reply
#66
(02-09-2025, 08:50 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: I’m not sure what exactly from the matches I’ve seen Holgate has done wrong in the matches he’s played.

Ever obliging is Mason... Have you watched their second goal last night?  Big Grin
Reply
#67
Holgate is a frustrating player. There is a good player on there, but as an Everton friend says about him, whenever you concede a goal with him in the team, he's always missing or the one messing up, never think 'Holgate did all he could to stop that.'

I prefer him at right back than centre back but needs must, I don't think he's as awful as some make out, but he's not good either.
Reply
#68
People see what they want to see. Holgate wasn't at fault for either goal yesterday.
Reply
#69
(02-13-2025, 10:05 AM)Sliced Wrote: People see what they want to see. Holgate wasn't at fault for either goal yesterday.

For the first goal, Holgate was challenging the defender who nodded the ball across. Maybe could have done more, but the shot was spectacular and unexpected. Wildsmith should have held it.

Second goal, Holgate held back because Wildsmith was going to catch the cross. When Wildsmith hesitated there was nothing Holgate could do to close the man down. Heggem let the runner get away from him before the cross went over, but he still had time to close the scorer down. A little weak by him IMO. But "he's one of our players of the season so far" so therefore immune from criticism. Let's blame Holgate for being there and Bartley for not being there, eh? Furlong slowed to a jog and watched it all unfold as Heggem was left with two men to mark. 

Special mention for Mowatt in relation to the second goal. Careless and costly.
Reply
#70
(02-13-2025, 10:41 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(02-13-2025, 10:05 AM)Sliced Wrote: People see what they want to see. Holgate wasn't at fault for either goal yesterday.

For the first goal, Holgate was challenging the defender who nodded the ball across. Maybe could have done more, but the shot was spectacular and unexpected. Wildsmith should have held it.

Second goal, Holgate held back because Wildsmith was going to catch the cross. When Wildsmith hesitated there was nothing Holgate could do to close the man down. Heggem let the runner get away from him before the cross went over, but he still had time to close the scorer down. A little weak by him IMO. But "he's one of our players of the season so far" so therefore immune from criticism. Let's blame Holgate for being there and Bartley for not being there, eh? Furlong slowed to a jog and watched it all unfold as Heggem was left with two men to mark. 

Special mention for Mowatt in relation to the second goal. Careless and costly.

Bartley was as close to the attacker yesterday as he was closing down the Sheff Weds goal at the weekend.

Agree that Wildsmith clearly at fault for both yesterday, with a nod to Mowatt.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: