Growth
(01-30-2025, 05:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: https://inews.co.uk/opinion/kwasi-kwarte...25-3509499

Fucking hell, Kwarteng's right but shame it took over two years to realise the fucking obvious. I was screaming this in 2022 that it's not high taxes constraining growth but infrastructure and demographics, and spending was far too embedded to easily cut due to all the fat being trimmed during austerity (and often making things worse: see primary and social care spending cuts resulting in hospital care spending ballooning to compensate).

The sooner the right get over Thatcher and realise that we don't have the birth rate, EEC boon and oil revenues to subsidise supply side reform anymore the better.

Jesus Christ, even the I is behind a paywall now.
Reply
(01-30-2025, 05:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-30-2025, 05:01 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: https://inews.co.uk/opinion/kwasi-kwarte...25-3509499

Fucking hell, Kwarteng's right but shame it took over two years to realise the fucking obvious. I was screaming this in 2022 that it's not high taxes constraining growth but infrastructure and demographics, and spending was far too embedded to easily cut due to all the fat being trimmed during austerity (and often making things worse: see primary and social care spending cuts resulting in hospital care spending ballooning to compensate).

The sooner the right get over Thatcher and realise that we don't have the birth rate, EEC boon and oil revenues to subsidise supply side reform anymore the better.

Jesus Christ, even the I is behind a paywall now.

Working for me
Reply
Defo behind paywall
Reply
Seeing as it's not behind a paywall for me (no idea why) here you go:

January 30, 2025 4:08 pm (Updated 5:13 pm)
Article thumbnail image
The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right (Photo: Bettmann)
share
Share
bookmark
Save
2025 is a big year for Margaret Thatcher fans.

It would not only be her centenary year, it marks the 50th anniversary of her election to the leadership of the Conservative Party. No former prime minister still permeates popular culture and politics as much as the Iron Lady.

Channel 4 is currently broadcasting Brian and Maggie, a dramatisation of the infamous 1989 interview between journalist Brian Walden and Thatcher starring Steve Coogan and Harriet Walter. And Sir Keir Starmer praised the former PM’s approach to regulation and even plans to emulate it, writing in The Times this week: “In the 1980s, the Thatcher government deregulated finance capital… This is our equivalent.”

It may come as no surprise that I consider myself an admirer of Thatcher. I met her only once, in the summer of 2010.

As a young, newly elected MP, I confess I was excited to meet her. She certainly had an aura and charisma, but it was obvious to all that her powers had faded.

She was tired and a little frail. I remember her being immaculately dressed, in a bright crimson, satin dress. She was presented to the new Tory MPs like royalty. She muttered a few words to each in turn, and we were shuffled on.

When she was elected as leader of the Conservative Party in February 1975, aged 49, she seemed young and dynamic. It was a significant moment, and many of the Tory grandees were surprised, even shocked, at that result.

Pictured: Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher.
Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher (Photo: Matt Frost)
Of course, we all know that she led the Conservatives to victory in the general election in 1979, and then consolidated Tory rule through the 1980s. She was controversial, dominant, assertive and also divisive. The entire British population, it seemed, had sharply contrasting views about her.

Fifty years on, however, it is time to put her legacy firmly in the past. She was a product of radically different times.

Her mindset was formed by her parents’ Methodism and her experience growing up in a flat over the family shop in Grantham in the 1930s. That culture stressed thrift, personal responsibility and a strong moral, religious sense of right and wrong. Her upbringing gave her tone an almost preachy quality, shaped by the firm certainties of religion and the stern rigour of theology.

To her opponents, those moral certainties sounded too much like dogmatism. To her supporters, her iron-clad convictions gave comfort and certainty. She was definitely a leader.

People like me can admire Mrs Thatcher and her achievements, while maintaining some critical distance. Like every politician in history, she had many faults.

Sometimes she seemed somewhat detached and lacking in empathy. Too often, her charismatic style was that of the pulpit and not really adapted to the arena of Parliament.

The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right, especially after losses like the Conservatives suffered at the general election. What is less comprehensible though is the desire to mimic her, still less to try to be like her.

Read Next
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she’s ‘a new Thatcher cut off in her prime’
square
LIZ TRUSS
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she's 'a new Thatcher cut off in her prime'
Read More
The circumstances which gave rise to Thatcher as a political phenomenon couldn’t have been more different to today. Her time was an era when religion played a bigger role at the centre of politics than it does now. It was a Britain which had recently experienced the trauma of the Second World War and the loss of an empire.

For Thatcher, the economic argument was simple. She wanted to roll back the state and foster an environment where individuals could be allowed to succeed or fail, according to their deserts, their efforts and talents.

The welfare state today, in many ways, is larger and more deeply embedded, with the NHS being accorded an ever greater part of national resources, while demand for it increases.

A simple tax-cutting agenda without thinking about spending at the same time is not possible. That was one of the lessons I learnt in the “mini-budget”, though many had made the point at the time.

So yes, modern politicians should recognise her for what she was – a remarkable politician who was very much a woman of her time. But they should be seeking to forge their own political characters, their own ideas and style. They should not simply indulge in a grotesque cosplay of an idealised Thatcher who only ever existed in their imagination.
Reply
(01-30-2025, 06:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Seeing as it's not behind a paywall for me (no idea why) here you go:

January 30, 2025 4:08 pm (Updated 5:13 pm)
Article thumbnail image
The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right (Photo: Bettmann)
share
Share
bookmark
Save
2025 is a big year for Margaret Thatcher fans.

It would not only be her centenary year, it marks the 50th anniversary of her election to the leadership of the Conservative Party. No former prime minister still permeates popular culture and politics as much as the Iron Lady.

Channel 4 is currently broadcasting Brian and Maggie, a dramatisation of the infamous 1989 interview between journalist Brian Walden and Thatcher starring Steve Coogan and Harriet Walter. And Sir Keir Starmer praised the former PM’s approach to regulation and even plans to emulate it, writing in The Times this week: “In the 1980s, the Thatcher government deregulated finance capital… This is our equivalent.”

It may come as no surprise that I consider myself an admirer of Thatcher. I met her only once, in the summer of 2010.

As a young, newly elected MP, I confess I was excited to meet her. She certainly had an aura and charisma, but it was obvious to all that her powers had faded.

She was tired and a little frail. I remember her being immaculately dressed, in a bright crimson, satin dress. She was presented to the new Tory MPs like royalty. She muttered a few words to each in turn, and we were shuffled on.

When she was elected as leader of the Conservative Party in February 1975, aged 49, she seemed young and dynamic. It was a significant moment, and many of the Tory grandees were surprised, even shocked, at that result.

Pictured: Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher.
Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher (Photo: Matt Frost)
Of course, we all know that she led the Conservatives to victory in the general election in 1979, and then consolidated Tory rule through the 1980s. She was controversial, dominant, assertive and also divisive. The entire British population, it seemed, had sharply contrasting views about her.

Fifty years on, however, it is time to put her legacy firmly in the past. She was a product of radically different times.

Her mindset was formed by her parents’ Methodism and her experience growing up in a flat over the family shop in Grantham in the 1930s. That culture stressed thrift, personal responsibility and a strong moral, religious sense of right and wrong. Her upbringing gave her tone an almost preachy quality, shaped by the firm certainties of religion and the stern rigour of theology.

To her opponents, those moral certainties sounded too much like dogmatism. To her supporters, her iron-clad convictions gave comfort and certainty. She was definitely a leader.

People like me can admire Mrs Thatcher and her achievements, while maintaining some critical distance. Like every politician in history, she had many faults.

Sometimes she seemed somewhat detached and lacking in empathy. Too often, her charismatic style was that of the pulpit and not really adapted to the arena of Parliament.

The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right, especially after losses like the Conservatives suffered at the general election. What is less comprehensible though is the desire to mimic her, still less to try to be like her.

Read Next
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she’s ‘a new Thatcher cut off in her prime’
square
LIZ TRUSS
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she's 'a new Thatcher cut off in her prime'
Read More
The circumstances which gave rise to Thatcher as a political phenomenon couldn’t have been more different to today. Her time was an era when religion played a bigger role at the centre of politics than it does now. It was a Britain which had recently experienced the trauma of the Second World War and the loss of an empire.

For Thatcher, the economic argument was simple. She wanted to roll back the state and foster an environment where individuals could be allowed to succeed or fail, according to their deserts, their efforts and talents.

The welfare state today, in many ways, is larger and more deeply embedded, with the NHS being accorded an ever greater part of national resources, while demand for it increases.

A simple tax-cutting agenda without thinking about spending at the same time is not possible. That was one of the lessons I learnt in the “mini-budget”, though many had made the point at the time.

So yes, modern politicians should recognise her for what she was – a remarkable politician who was very much a woman of her time. But they should be seeking to forge their own political characters, their own ideas and style. They should not simply indulge in a grotesque cosplay of an idealised Thatcher who only ever existed in their imagination.

There you go. That's all anyone needs.
Reply
Superficial claptrap from a political lightweight. As I said at the time - his budget was many of the right ideas at absolutely the wrong time. The guys a fool.
Reply
(01-30-2025, 08:01 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
(01-30-2025, 06:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Seeing as it's not behind a paywall for me (no idea why) here you go:

January 30, 2025 4:08 pm (Updated 5:13 pm)
Article thumbnail image
The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right (Photo: Bettmann)
share
Share
bookmark
Save
2025 is a big year for Margaret Thatcher fans.

It would not only be her centenary year, it marks the 50th anniversary of her election to the leadership of the Conservative Party. No former prime minister still permeates popular culture and politics as much as the Iron Lady.

Channel 4 is currently broadcasting Brian and Maggie, a dramatisation of the infamous 1989 interview between journalist Brian Walden and Thatcher starring Steve Coogan and Harriet Walter. And Sir Keir Starmer praised the former PM’s approach to regulation and even plans to emulate it, writing in The Times this week: “In the 1980s, the Thatcher government deregulated finance capital… This is our equivalent.”

It may come as no surprise that I consider myself an admirer of Thatcher. I met her only once, in the summer of 2010.

As a young, newly elected MP, I confess I was excited to meet her. She certainly had an aura and charisma, but it was obvious to all that her powers had faded.

She was tired and a little frail. I remember her being immaculately dressed, in a bright crimson, satin dress. She was presented to the new Tory MPs like royalty. She muttered a few words to each in turn, and we were shuffled on.

When she was elected as leader of the Conservative Party in February 1975, aged 49, she seemed young and dynamic. It was a significant moment, and many of the Tory grandees were surprised, even shocked, at that result.

Pictured: Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher.
Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher (Photo: Matt Frost)
Of course, we all know that she led the Conservatives to victory in the general election in 1979, and then consolidated Tory rule through the 1980s. She was controversial, dominant, assertive and also divisive. The entire British population, it seemed, had sharply contrasting views about her.

Fifty years on, however, it is time to put her legacy firmly in the past. She was a product of radically different times.

Her mindset was formed by her parents’ Methodism and her experience growing up in a flat over the family shop in Grantham in the 1930s. That culture stressed thrift, personal responsibility and a strong moral, religious sense of right and wrong. Her upbringing gave her tone an almost preachy quality, shaped by the firm certainties of religion and the stern rigour of theology.

To her opponents, those moral certainties sounded too much like dogmatism. To her supporters, her iron-clad convictions gave comfort and certainty. She was definitely a leader.

People like me can admire Mrs Thatcher and her achievements, while maintaining some critical distance. Like every politician in history, she had many faults.

Sometimes she seemed somewhat detached and lacking in empathy. Too often, her charismatic style was that of the pulpit and not really adapted to the arena of Parliament.

The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right, especially after losses like the Conservatives suffered at the general election. What is less comprehensible though is the desire to mimic her, still less to try to be like her.

Read Next
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she’s ‘a new Thatcher cut off in her prime’
square
LIZ TRUSS
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she's 'a new Thatcher cut off in her prime'
Read More
The circumstances which gave rise to Thatcher as a political phenomenon couldn’t have been more different to today. Her time was an era when religion played a bigger role at the centre of politics than it does now. It was a Britain which had recently experienced the trauma of the Second World War and the loss of an empire.

For Thatcher, the economic argument was simple. She wanted to roll back the state and foster an environment where individuals could be allowed to succeed or fail, according to their deserts, their efforts and talents.

The welfare state today, in many ways, is larger and more deeply embedded, with the NHS being accorded an ever greater part of national resources, while demand for it increases.

A simple tax-cutting agenda without thinking about spending at the same time is not possible. That was one of the lessons I learnt in the “mini-budget”, though many had made the point at the time.

So yes, modern politicians should recognise her for what she was – a remarkable politician who was very much a woman of her time. But they should be seeking to forge their own political characters, their own ideas and style. They should not simply indulge in a grotesque cosplay of an idealised Thatcher who only ever existed in their imagination.

There you go. That's all anyone needs.

Cosplayer world no 1 dogmatic true believer is a member of our very own bored.

We are indeed blessed.
Reply
(01-30-2025, 09:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Superficial claptrap from a political lightweight. As I said at the time - his budget was many of the right ideas at absolutely the wrong time. The guys a fool.

The budget was wrong, there were no right ideas. There was zero scope for infrastructure investment, the headline income tax cuts were pointless as they're not what is wrong with the current tax system and it wasn't funded. It is not the 1980s anymore, there is no external revenues from selling off state-owned organisations and North Sea oil revenues to cover tax reform in the 2020s.
Reply
Given that the current government is aping Truss's approach to growth in most other ways than tax cuts I expect they believe there's some merit to her approach.

I have already stated many times that borrowing to fund tax cuts is lunacy. However on a day like today - SA day - getting rid of IR35 promised much, pity Sunak was stupid enough to put the block on that.
Reply
(01-30-2025, 06:29 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Seeing as it's not behind a paywall for me (no idea why) here you go:

January 30, 2025 4:08 pm (Updated 5:13 pm)
Article thumbnail image
The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right (Photo: Bettmann)
share
Share
bookmark
Save
2025 is a big year for Margaret Thatcher fans.

It would not only be her centenary year, it marks the 50th anniversary of her election to the leadership of the Conservative Party. No former prime minister still permeates popular culture and politics as much as the Iron Lady.

Channel 4 is currently broadcasting Brian and Maggie, a dramatisation of the infamous 1989 interview between journalist Brian Walden and Thatcher starring Steve Coogan and Harriet Walter. And Sir Keir Starmer praised the former PM’s approach to regulation and even plans to emulate it, writing in The Times this week: “In the 1980s, the Thatcher government deregulated finance capital… This is our equivalent.”

It may come as no surprise that I consider myself an admirer of Thatcher. I met her only once, in the summer of 2010.

As a young, newly elected MP, I confess I was excited to meet her. She certainly had an aura and charisma, but it was obvious to all that her powers had faded.

She was tired and a little frail. I remember her being immaculately dressed, in a bright crimson, satin dress. She was presented to the new Tory MPs like royalty. She muttered a few words to each in turn, and we were shuffled on.

When she was elected as leader of the Conservative Party in February 1975, aged 49, she seemed young and dynamic. It was a significant moment, and many of the Tory grandees were surprised, even shocked, at that result.

Pictured: Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher.
Steve Coogan as Brian Walden and Harriet Walter as Margaret Thatcher (Photo: Matt Frost)
Of course, we all know that she led the Conservatives to victory in the general election in 1979, and then consolidated Tory rule through the 1980s. She was controversial, dominant, assertive and also divisive. The entire British population, it seemed, had sharply contrasting views about her.

Fifty years on, however, it is time to put her legacy firmly in the past. She was a product of radically different times.

Her mindset was formed by her parents’ Methodism and her experience growing up in a flat over the family shop in Grantham in the 1930s. That culture stressed thrift, personal responsibility and a strong moral, religious sense of right and wrong. Her upbringing gave her tone an almost preachy quality, shaped by the firm certainties of religion and the stern rigour of theology.

To her opponents, those moral certainties sounded too much like dogmatism. To her supporters, her iron-clad convictions gave comfort and certainty. She was definitely a leader.

People like me can admire Mrs Thatcher and her achievements, while maintaining some critical distance. Like every politician in history, she had many faults.

Sometimes she seemed somewhat detached and lacking in empathy. Too often, her charismatic style was that of the pulpit and not really adapted to the arena of Parliament.

The desire to revere her memory is understandable for many on the political Right, especially after losses like the Conservatives suffered at the general election. What is less comprehensible though is the desire to mimic her, still less to try to be like her.

Read Next
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she’s ‘a new Thatcher cut off in her prime’
square
LIZ TRUSS
Truss goes full Maga to show Trumpists she's 'a new Thatcher cut off in her prime'
Read More
The circumstances which gave rise to Thatcher as a political phenomenon couldn’t have been more different to today. Her time was an era when religion played a bigger role at the centre of politics than it does now. It was a Britain which had recently experienced the trauma of the Second World War and the loss of an empire.

For Thatcher, the economic argument was simple. She wanted to roll back the state and foster an environment where individuals could be allowed to succeed or fail, according to their deserts, their efforts and talents.

The welfare state today, in many ways, is larger and more deeply embedded, with the NHS being accorded an ever greater part of national resources, while demand for it increases.

A simple tax-cutting agenda without thinking about spending at the same time is not possible. That was one of the lessons I learnt in the “mini-budget”, though many had made the point at the time.

So yes, modern politicians should recognise her for what she was – a remarkable politician who was very much a woman of her time. But they should be seeking to forge their own political characters, their own ideas and style. They should not simply indulge in a grotesque cosplay of an idealised Thatcher who only ever existed in their imagination.

Fuck Thatcher hope she's rotting in hell, and no I won't be watching Brian and Maggie...
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: