Squad for next season
#21
(01-22-2025, 11:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 09:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 08:30 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 07:59 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think this season is our best opportunity to go up. Whoever comes down from the Prem will most likely be very strong.

That has a familiar ring to it.

Not with me, I’ve been consistent that last season was the strongest Champ for years and that this season would likely be a weaker one. I stand by that. Unless there are fire sales for the teams coming down then they will be stronger than the teams currently in the top 4.

Surprised anyone is disagreeing with this. Leicester were streets ahead of everyone else last season, with Ipswich, Southampton and Leeds not far behind them.

Leeds should get promoted this season, but the other three are coming back to the Championship, with parachute payments and reasonable owners who will ensure they don't have to flog the family silver, so they will be even stronger than previously.

Whereas this season, the relegated teams were Burnley, Sheff Utd and Luton who are average to poor.

Let's hope the Dingles drop then as I think they are the one side who might go into freefall. Fosun have given up and the inbred natives ain't happy. A relegation could see them implode. Here's hoping....
Reply
#22
(01-23-2025, 07:26 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 11:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 09:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 08:30 PM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 07:59 PM)Sliced Wrote: I think this season is our best opportunity to go up. Whoever comes down from the Prem will most likely be very strong.

That has a familiar ring to it.

Not with me, I’ve been consistent that last season was the strongest Champ for years and that this season would likely be a weaker one. I stand by that. Unless there are fire sales for the teams coming down then they will be stronger than the teams currently in the top 4.

Surprised anyone is disagreeing with this. Leicester were streets ahead of everyone else last season, with Ipswich, Southampton and Leeds not far behind them.

Leeds should get promoted this season, but the other three are coming back to the Championship, with parachute payments and reasonable owners who will ensure they don't have to flog the family silver, so they will be even stronger than previously.

Whereas this season, the relegated teams were Burnley, Sheff Utd and Luton who are average to poor.

Who hold 2nd and 3rd place.  And if rumours are correct, investing heavily in this window.  The free hit this year is Luton, who have created and extra spot to play for.

This is exactly the point
Reply
#23
(01-23-2025, 07:50 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 07:26 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 11:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 09:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 08:30 PM)B68Baggy Wrote: That has a familiar ring to it.

Not with me, I’ve been consistent that last season was the strongest Champ for years and that this season would likely be a weaker one. I stand by that. Unless there are fire sales for the teams coming down then they will be stronger than the teams currently in the top 4.

Surprised anyone is disagreeing with this. Leicester were streets ahead of everyone else last season, with Ipswich, Southampton and Leeds not far behind them.

Leeds should get promoted this season, but the other three are coming back to the Championship, with parachute payments and reasonable owners who will ensure they don't have to flog the family silver, so they will be even stronger than previously.

Whereas this season, the relegated teams were Burnley, Sheff Utd and Luton who are average to poor.

Who hold 2nd and 3rd place.  And if rumours are correct, investing heavily in this window.  The free hit this year is Luton, who have created and extra spot to play for.

This is exactly the point

Wouldn't say Burnley are average to poor. They may not be as free-flowing or destructive as they were under Kompany, but they're a better 'team' imo. Only 8 goals conceded in the league this season doesn't scream poor. Sheff Utd are a pretty darn decent team too.
Reply
#24
(01-23-2025, 08:07 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 07:50 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 07:26 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 11:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 09:10 PM)Sliced Wrote: Not with me, I’ve been consistent that last season was the strongest Champ for years and that this season would likely be a weaker one. I stand by that. Unless there are fire sales for the teams coming down then they will be stronger than the teams currently in the top 4.

Surprised anyone is disagreeing with this. Leicester were streets ahead of everyone else last season, with Ipswich, Southampton and Leeds not far behind them.

Leeds should get promoted this season, but the other three are coming back to the Championship, with parachute payments and reasonable owners who will ensure they don't have to flog the family silver, so they will be even stronger than previously.

Whereas this season, the relegated teams were Burnley, Sheff Utd and Luton who are average to poor.

Who hold 2nd and 3rd place.  And if rumours are correct, investing heavily in this window.  The free hit this year is Luton, who have created and extra spot to play for.

This is exactly the point

Wouldn't say Burnley are average to poor. They may not be as free-flowing or destructive as they were under Kompany, but they're a better 'team' imo. Only 8 goals conceded in the league this season doesn't scream poor. Sheff Utd are a pretty darn decent team too.

We've played both. Did they play us off the pitch? No. Whereas we lost twice to Leicester and Southampton amd they are likely to be even stronger next season.

It seems like some people have written this season off already. From what Nestor has said, the aim is still very much to finish in the playoffs.
Reply
#25
(01-23-2025, 07:50 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 07:26 AM)B68Baggy Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 11:59 PM)Squid Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 09:10 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 08:30 PM)B68Baggy Wrote: That has a familiar ring to it.

Not with me, I’ve been consistent that last season was the strongest Champ for years and that this season would likely be a weaker one. I stand by that. Unless there are fire sales for the teams coming down then they will be stronger than the teams currently in the top 4.

Surprised anyone is disagreeing with this. Leicester were streets ahead of everyone else last season, with Ipswich, Southampton and Leeds not far behind them.

Leeds should get promoted this season, but the other three are coming back to the Championship, with parachute payments and reasonable owners who will ensure they don't have to flog the family silver, so they will be even stronger than previously.

Whereas this season, the relegated teams were Burnley, Sheff Utd and Luton who are average to poor.

Who hold 2nd and 3rd place.  And if rumours are correct, investing heavily in this window.  The free hit this year is Luton, who have created and extra spot to play for.

This is exactly the point

What are you judging them average to poor on? By eye or PPG?  Genuinely question? Just doesn't feel massively different to most recent years. One stand out team, two or three reasonably stocked parachute teams and everyone else scrapping for one /two places.

Add to that SU have just added a 20 goal champ striker.
Reply
#26
I wouldn't describe them as average to poor in general but I think they weaker than the teams that went up last year.

Last year Leeds failed to go up, they weakened significantly in the summer losing Summerville, who was arguably the best player in the Championship last season, Sinisterra who would get into any champ team easily, Archie Gray who's now a regular at Spurs and Rutter who has been great for Brighton, and despite losing their best players they are top this season.

At this point last season they were 14 points off top of the league with a stronger squad.

Sheffield United's attack last season:
Archer played 30 games: Gone
McBurnie played 23 games: Gone
Osula played 24 games: Gone
Brereton Diaz played 14 games: Gone until about a week ago when he returned on loan

Lost Auston Trusty who was their first choice centre back.
They lost their first 4 attacking choices. Currently second in the league.

Burnley lost half their starting 11, and these are by far the strongest teams in the league, along with Sunderland who finished 16th and lost Jack Clarke.

If you would rather talk about chance of getting promoted than overall strength of the league then that's fine. It was more difficult for a team in our position to get promoted last year than this year, firstly because the points totals for the teams at the top last year were very high, but secondly because the best teams this year are weaker.

(01-23-2025, 09:10 AM)Squid Wrote: We've played both. Did they play us off the pitch? No. Whereas we lost twice to Leicester and Southampton amd they are likely to be even stronger next season.

It seems like some people have written this season off already. From what Nestor has said, the aim is still very much to finish in the playoffs.

Completely agree on both points. I don't get it at all. Playing Leicester and Southampton last year it felt like we were major underdogs. The majority of the Leicester and Saints bench would have gotten into our first team, and Leeds before all their sales. There's no teams I feel that about this season.

I've seen posts saying already that the season is a write off. We're around the playoffs.
Reply
#27
(01-23-2025, 09:49 AM)Sliced Wrote: I wouldn't describe them as average to poor in general but I think they weaker than the teams that went up last year.

Last year Leeds failed to go up, they weakened significantly in the summer losing Summerville, who was arguably the best player in the Championship last season, Sinisterra who would get into any champ team easily, Archie Gray who's now a regular at Spurs and Rutter who has been great for Brighton, and despite losing their best players they are top this season.

At this point last season they were 14 points off top of the league with a stronger squad.

Sheffield United's attack last season:
Archer played 30 games: Gone
McBurnie played 23 games: Gone
Osula played 24 games: Gone
Brereton Diaz played 14 games: Gone until about a week ago when he returned on loan

Lost Auston Trusty who was their first choice centre back.
They lost their first 4 attacking choices. Currently second in the league.

Burnley lost half their starting 11, and these are by far the strongest teams in the league, along with Sunderland who finished 16th and lost Jack Clarke.

If you would rather talk about chance of getting promoted than overall strength of the league then that's fine. It was more difficult for a team in our position to get promoted last year than this year, firstly because the points totals for the teams at the top last year were very high, but secondly because the best teams this year are weaker.

(01-23-2025, 09:10 AM)Squid Wrote: We've played both. Did they play us off the pitch? No. Whereas we lost twice to Leicester and Southampton amd they are likely to be even stronger next season.

It seems like some people have written this season off already. From what Nestor has said, the aim is still very much to finish in the playoffs.

Completely agree on both points. I don't get it at all. Playing Leicester and Southampton last year it felt like we were major underdogs. The majority of the Leicester and Saints bench would have gotten into our first team, and Leeds before all their sales. There's no teams I feel that about this season.

I've seen posts saying already that the season is a write off. We're around the playoffs.

I agree with every word of that. I've generally not been blown away by any of the opposition teams at the Hawthorns this season.

As for writing this season off, I think part of that is fans wanting to give Mowbray time, which ok, but also a big chunk of our fanbase seems to think we are far worse/other teams are much better than the reality.
Reply
#28
(01-23-2025, 10:38 AM)Squid Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 09:49 AM)Sliced Wrote: I wouldn't describe them as average to poor in general but I think they weaker than the teams that went up last year.

Last year Leeds failed to go up, they weakened significantly in the summer losing Summerville, who was arguably the best player in the Championship last season, Sinisterra who would get into any champ team easily, Archie Gray who's now a regular at Spurs and Rutter who has been great for Brighton, and despite losing their best players they are top this season.

At this point last season they were 14 points off top of the league with a stronger squad.

Sheffield United's attack last season:
Archer played 30 games: Gone
McBurnie played 23 games: Gone
Osula played 24 games: Gone
Brereton Diaz played 14 games: Gone until about a week ago when he returned on loan

Lost Auston Trusty who was their first choice centre back.
They lost their first 4 attacking choices. Currently second in the league.

Burnley lost half their starting 11, and these are by far the strongest teams in the league, along with Sunderland who finished 16th and lost Jack Clarke.

If you would rather talk about chance of getting promoted than overall strength of the league then that's fine. It was more difficult for a team in our position to get promoted last year than this year, firstly because the points totals for the teams at the top last year were very high, but secondly because the best teams this year are weaker.

(01-23-2025, 09:10 AM)Squid Wrote: We've played both. Did they play us off the pitch? No. Whereas we lost twice to Leicester and Southampton amd they are likely to be even stronger next season.

It seems like some people have written this season off already. From what Nestor has said, the aim is still very much to finish in the playoffs.

Completely agree on both points. I don't get it at all. Playing Leicester and Southampton last year it felt like we were major underdogs. The majority of the Leicester and Saints bench would have gotten into our first team, and Leeds before all their sales. There's no teams I feel that about this season.

I've seen posts saying already that the season is a write off. We're around the playoffs.

I agree with every word of that. I've generally not been blown away by any of the opposition teams at the Hawthorns this season.

As for writing this season off, I think part of that is fans wanting to give Mowbray time, which ok, but also a big chunk of our fanbase seems to think we are far worse/other teams are much better than the reality.

It would be a failure if we don’t make the playoffs and an excuse.
Reply
#29
(01-23-2025, 11:27 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 10:38 AM)Squid Wrote:
(01-23-2025, 09:49 AM)Sliced Wrote: I wouldn't describe them as average to poor in general but I think they weaker than the teams that went up last year.

Last year Leeds failed to go up, they weakened significantly in the summer losing Summerville, who was arguably the best player in the Championship last season, Sinisterra who would get into any champ team easily, Archie Gray who's now a regular at Spurs and Rutter who has been great for Brighton, and despite losing their best players they are top this season.

At this point last season they were 14 points off top of the league with a stronger squad.

Sheffield United's attack last season:
Archer played 30 games: Gone
McBurnie played 23 games: Gone
Osula played 24 games: Gone
Brereton Diaz played 14 games: Gone until about a week ago when he returned on loan

Lost Auston Trusty who was their first choice centre back.
They lost their first 4 attacking choices. Currently second in the league.

Burnley lost half their starting 11, and these are by far the strongest teams in the league, along with Sunderland who finished 16th and lost Jack Clarke.

If you would rather talk about chance of getting promoted than overall strength of the league then that's fine. It was more difficult for a team in our position to get promoted last year than this year, firstly because the points totals for the teams at the top last year were very high, but secondly because the best teams this year are weaker.

(01-23-2025, 09:10 AM)Squid Wrote: We've played both. Did they play us off the pitch? No. Whereas we lost twice to Leicester and Southampton amd they are likely to be even stronger next season.

It seems like some people have written this season off already. From what Nestor has said, the aim is still very much to finish in the playoffs.

Completely agree on both points. I don't get it at all. Playing Leicester and Southampton last year it felt like we were major underdogs. The majority of the Leicester and Saints bench would have gotten into our first team, and Leeds before all their sales. There's no teams I feel that about this season.

I've seen posts saying already that the season is a write off. We're around the playoffs.

I agree with every word of that. I've generally not been blown away by any of the opposition teams at the Hawthorns this season.

As for writing this season off, I think part of that is fans wanting to give Mowbray time, which ok, but also a big chunk of our fanbase seems to think we are far worse/other teams are much better than the reality.

It would be a failure if we don’t make the playoffs and an excuse.

On that we agree. WM reported that the aim was to finish fourth. Maja's injury and the managerial change may have impacted, but I see no reason to finish outside of the playoffs.
Reply
#30
We are between 5th and 7th at the minute in a direct battle with Boro and Blackburn. Boro are better than us when we play them, but not necessarily when they play others, if that makes sense? Blackburn, similar to us, had one great run and have now levelled off. If those 2 finish above us we can't really complain.

The trouble is, we are getting reigned in by the likes of Watford, QPR (ffs), Wednesday and even Bristol City and, if we finish below any of them it will be a real disappointment.

The squad in February will be key, never mind next season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)