Looking back on last night's match
#1
in the cold light of morning - and without the knee-jerk reactions after a disappointing result

Both goals happened because Boro players had time to get shots off from distance. Maybe Palmer should have stopped the first. I thought Mowatt in particular was off the pace for most of the match, not closing down quickly enough when Boro came forward. Diakite would have been more effective.

All this talk about the defence - the CBs were under pressure because we didn't have enough energy to control the midfield. Holgate was better than Heggem (again) apart from that one Bartley-esque lapse leading to the second goal. Furlong was poor defensively again and Styles does his best but isn't a full back. Too many crosses coming in. Where's Frabotta?

There were times when AJ was crying out for a cross into the box. Time and again Furlong in particular went backwards when there were Albion players in good scoring positions. Is this a carryover from CC's approach?

I was amazed that Mowatt stayed on and Molumby was subbed off. Wallace and Swift as the first two subs was crushingly predictable but wrong. This is the usual "senior player" hierarchy when a new coach takes over. Mogga needs to learn very quickly that his most experienced players haven't been delivering.

Grady - this is going to divide opinion. He is classy and sometimes a threat, but does much of his trickery deliver anything? How often does he lose possession in dangerous areas? Does he provide the "defending from the front" that we get with Maja and Grant paired up front? I don't think we can afford to play more than two of Fellows, Johnston and Diangana - indeed if we had a reliable goal scorer it might be any two from Fellows, Grant, Johnston and Diangana. I'd rather see Diakite as the extra man instead of a "10" and have Mowatt and Molumby getting forward more.

Cole - another one that will divide opinion. I don't know why he was playing wide left, but he looked OK to me. I've read critique of his "first touch". I thought he did well to receive the ball and lay it off several times. Why not try him centrally? We certainly haven't seen enough of him to write him off.

It's too early to tell whether this is an average squad that's over-achieved or a good squad that has been limited by its lack of a goal-scorer. Unlike some on this bored, I just don't know.
Reply
#2
Good summary. I thought Devante Cole was fine when he came on and agree that Holgate outperformed Heggem again. Unfortunately some posters have decided how players are going to play before kickoff. I think overall we have a strong squad but one gaping hole up front if Maja is injured.
Reply
#3
Two very sensible posts in succession, blimey.  
I didn't think Holgate was that bad either, came closer to scoring than any of the other fuckers.
Reply
#4
I like Mowatt but this happens a lot with him. He starts the season like a house on fire before injury niggles kick in and he never really regains his form.
Reply
#5
(01-22-2025, 11:33 AM)Dumbo Wrote: I like Mowatt but this happens a lot with him. He starts the season like a house on fire before injury niggles kick in and he never really regains his form.

Agree, and the drop in quality between fit Mowatt and unfit Mowatt is massive. He's the only player we have that can carry the ball and distribute with quality passes. Molumby pushes forward but his passing isn't as good, Diakite is too defensive and Swift isn't strong enough to play that role.
Reply
#6
The lack of control to our game yesterday was the most worrying thing. It's been the case for much of the last 3/4 games.

We need to get back to a repeatable, controlled approach, what ever that may be. We need to see patterns of play more often rather than "get the ball to MJ/Grady/Fellows and hope they do something".

I agree that Holgate was largely okay fwiw, but his huge lapses in concentration both in possession and out make him unreliable. Heggem, by and large didn't play well, but he didn't cause us any issues in terms of errors so I can forgive it, he is at least predictable and reliable.

I have bleated on about it for god knows how long, but our lack of running power really does kill us when we try and open up. We have so many players who 'buzz around'; Molumby, Mowatt, MJ, Grady, Styles etc, but not many who cover the ground, over long distances both offensively and defensively. Hopefully Price can do this centrally which will help but we need to keep working on the balance and profile of the player in the team.

Lots of work for ToMo to do, I really hope he can work his magic cause I want him to succeed and would love to see us do what we did under Clarke after Roy.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#7
(01-22-2025, 11:27 AM)Sliced Wrote: Good summary. I thought Devante Cole was fine when he came on and agree that Holgate outperformed Heggem again. Unfortunately some posters have decided how players are going to play before kickoff. I think overall we have a strong squad but one gaping hole up front if Maja is injured.

The criticism of Holgate really baffles me. He has the occasional error in him but has largely been as steady as any of our other defenders this season. He just seems to have emerged as a fall for certain sections of the crowd though.
Reply
#8
(01-22-2025, 11:49 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: The lack of control to our game yesterday was the most worrying thing. It's been the case for much of the last 3/4 games.

We need to get back to a repeatable, controlled approach, what ever that may be. We need to see patterns of play more often rather than "get the ball to MJ/Grady/Fellows and hope they do something".

I agree that Holgate was largely okay fwiw, but his huge lapses in concentration both in possession and out make him unreliable. Heggem, by and large didn't play well, but he didn't cause us any issues in terms of errors so I can forgive it, he is at least predictable and reliable.

I have bleated on about it for god knows how long, but our lack of running power really does kill us when we try and open up. We have so many players who 'buzz around'; Molumby, Mowatt, MJ, Grady, Styles etc, but not many who cover the ground, over long distances both offensively and defensively. Hopefully Price can do this centrally which will help but we need to keep working on the balance and profile of the player in the team.

Lots of work for ToMo to do, I really hope he can work his magic cause I want him to succeed and would love to see us do what we did under Clarke after Roy.

Agree with this completely. The transitions from Boro, especially first half were a lot more "orchestrated", we tend to wait until someone moves by which point the defence is in place; they were already on the move. It's been an issue for some time. It's also the case we delay that pass when someone is in a decent position to receive and then it all breaks down.

(01-22-2025, 11:19 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: in the cold light of morning - and without the knee-jerk reactions after a disappointing result

Both goals happened because Boro players had time to get shots off from distance. Maybe Palmer should have stopped the first. I thought Mowatt in particular was off the pace for most of the match, not closing down quickly enough when Boro came forward. Diakite would have been more effective.

All this talk about the defence - the CBs were under pressure because we didn't have enough energy to control the midfield. Holgate was better than Heggem (again) apart from that one Bartley-esque lapse leading to the second goal. Furlong was poor defensively again and Styles does his best but isn't a full back. Too many crosses coming in. Where's Frabotta?

There were times when AJ was crying out for a cross into the box. Time and again Furlong in particular went backwards when there were Albion players in good scoring positions. Is this a carryover from CC's approach?

I was amazed that Mowatt stayed on and Molumby was subbed off. Wallace and Swift as the first two subs was crushingly predictable but wrong. This is the usual "senior player" hierarchy when a new coach takes over. Mogga needs to learn very quickly that his most experienced players haven't been delivering.

Grady - this is going to divide opinion. He is classy and sometimes a threat, but does much of his trickery deliver anything? How often does he lose possession in dangerous areas? Does he provide the "defending from the front" that we get with Maja and Grant paired up front? I don't think we can afford to play more than two of Fellows, Johnston and Diangana - indeed if we had a reliable goal scorer it might be any two from Fellows, Grant, Johnston and Diangana. I'd rather see Diakite as the extra man instead of a "10" and have Mowatt and Molumby getting forward more.

Cole - another one that will divide opinion. I don't know why he was playing wide left, but he looked OK to me. I've read critique of his "first touch". I thought he did well to receive the ball and lay it off several times. Why not try him centrally? We certainly haven't seen enough of him to write him off.

It's too early to tell whether this is an average squad that's over-achieved or a good squad that has been limited by its lack of a goal-scorer. Unlike some on this bored, I just don't know.

That's one of the most offensive things I've ever read on here.
Reply
#9
Mowatt put in the best individual display by any Albion player this season against Bristol City. His form tailed off somewhat after that gaff against Luton away, but he quickly got back on it. He is an important player for us imo.

Mowbray needs to be mindful of how much we expose central midfield when we get caught high up the pitch on the counter. Alex puts in a lot of leg work, to do that he needs to be firing on all cylinders.
Reply
#10
(01-22-2025, 11:58 AM)Man from delmonte Wrote:
(01-22-2025, 11:27 AM)Sliced Wrote: Good summary. I thought Devante Cole was fine when he came on and agree that Holgate outperformed Heggem again. Unfortunately some posters have decided how players are going to play before kickoff. I think overall we have a strong squad but one gaping hole up front if Maja is injured.

The criticism of Holgate really baffles me. He has the occasional error in him but has largely been as steady as any of our other defenders this season. He just seems to have emerged as a fall for certain sections of the crowd though.

Yep. Bizarre. Put in a couple of good blocks early doors yesterday that could have put us further behind and despite not being a natural leader, he was making an effort to organise an otherwise silent defence. We love a good CD scapegoat at the Albion. Bizarrely, I've seen Holgate described as a League One defender and Heggem described as PL quality. The fact is neither of them are anywhere near good enough to have a lasting positive impact in a decent Prem team, but all of our defenders are mid to higher Championship level.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: