01-21-2025, 11:56 AM
(01-21-2025, 11:28 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote:(01-21-2025, 10:49 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: This 'give the kids a gew' narrative frustrates me a little.
Fellows and Palmer aren't first XI regulars now because they were given an opportunity due to a policy of bringing through youth players. They're in the team because they're the best options we have. They're there because they're good enough.
There's a reason that Clearly, for example, isn't in the squad regularly. Because he's not good enough.
It's all well and good towing the line of 'play more kids, Tom. They cor be any wuss'. Well, they can and unfortunately, in many cases, they are. It's not football manager! Ultimately those academy lads with the talent and quality will force their way into the team. Whether we have a policy of playing more youth players, or not.
The criticism is that a lot of the younger players we have released were good enough. We deemed Field, Azaz, TI and, Wilson to be not good enough and brought in players who were no better, older and with little resale value. Recent examples Button, Rogic, Kelly, M'Villa and probably Cole.
Let's go through the litany of names.
Field - this has been done to death on here. There were times he could have played more, but he always seemed to be getting injured at the worst of times.
Azaz - Poached by Villa for more money.
Tim Iroegbunam - Poached by Villa for more money
Kane Wilson - Has spent years working his way up from League Two, so was definitely not at the level required.
I'll even throw in:
Morgan Rogers - sold to pay for Bilic + team. Money well spent as we achieved promotion that season and Bilic brought in one of the most talented players to grace the Hawthorns for quite some time.
Josh is right. If the kids are good enough, they make the first team.


