Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
01-19-2025, 11:16 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-19-2025, 11:17 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(01-19-2025, 12:03 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Many fans have a fixed idea of Mowbray based on how he was 16 years ago. It's like comparing the Beatles doing She Loves You to A Day in the Life- they'd completely changed.
I don't pretend to have analysed closely what Mowbray 2025 is compared to the guy we knew years ago- I haven't followed the style of football close enough. However, I would say he is wiser and more pragmatic, with more soldiers now as part of his team.
I spoke to several fans today, with only one really enthusiastic about the appointment, with many stuck in the 2009 relegation time warp.
However, as the guy behind me said, Mowbray may be the guy to get a tune out of Grady, Swift and one or two others.
As much as I liked CC, he was a safety first manager where the team were well drilled, with little room for flair.
I'm actually more enthusiastic for his appointment after today.
Time will tell, but given the interview that was posted where he says we ‘played great football’ when we got relegated from Prem, I have some nagging doubts. We didn’t play great football we played relegation quality football and Hansen was absolutely spot on.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(01-19-2025, 11:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 12:03 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Many fans have a fixed idea of Mowbray based on how he was 16 years ago. It's like comparing the Beatles doing She Loves You to A Day in the Life- they'd completely changed.
I don't pretend to have analysed closely what Mowbray 2025 is compared to the guy we knew years ago- I haven't followed the style of football close enough. However, I would say he is wiser and more pragmatic, with more soldiers now as part of his team.
I spoke to several fans today, with only one really enthusiastic about the appointment, with many stuck in the 2009 relegation time warp.
However, as the guy behind me said, Mowbray may be the guy to get a tune out of Grady, Swift and one or two others.
As much as I liked CC, he was a safety first manager where the team were well drilled, with little room for flair.
I'm actually more enthusiastic for his appointment after today.
Time will tell, but given the interview that was posted where he says we ‘played great football’ when we got relegated from Prem, I have some nagging doubts. We didn’t play great football we played relegation quality football and Hansen was absolutely spot on.
Agree, but that was then and I don't think TM is the sort of guy to say he got it wrong. We have actually seen evidence of Mowbray's later style. Blues last year (We won a hard fought game 1-0, I think) and Blackburn previously. IIRC Blackburn were down to 10 men with a temp in goal and stifled the game with Pulis like belligerence. I think you'll like him now Derek!
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
Not sure if this deserves a separate thread, but here are some Sunderland fans views on Mowbray:
A very good manager for us, and he has every right to complain about his treatment.
I do think our board has learnt a lot of lessons since then and hopefully we won't ever be left if the state we were on sept 1st 2023. With Hemir Burstow and Rusyn as our strikers (Mayenda was already Injured).
He did a great job for us in difficult circumstances and always completed himself well.
There is a strange happy clapper revisionism that seems to think that Speakman was playing some sort of 4 dimensional chess by bringing in Beale in order for Le Bris to take over.
We shouldn't have fired Mowbray, and we shouldn't have hired Beale. We should also not have let some of our best players from the previous season go to be replaced by kids who weren't ready- and some who are unlikely to ever be.
Mowbray got a raw deal and it's a shame he never got to work with a striker like Isidor (Stewart was injured quite early).
I think we can also start talking a bit about Mowbray's legacy.
1: Whilst part of the ownerships long term vision I think Mowbray is the person who cemented our footballing philosophy- a grandiose term for how we play. Turning us into a top championship attacking side (Le Bris has added a lot to this)
2: He gave debuts to Rigg and Watson, and managed them very well. We are seeing the fruits of this now.
3: The absoloute dentition of Southampton. A fantastic game. We were imperious.
I'm absolutely delighted with Le Bris. He is a fantastic manager and I think overall an improvement on Mowbray.
But Mowbray deserves a lot of credit.
Posts: 13,262
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(01-19-2025, 11:16 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 12:03 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Many fans have a fixed idea of Mowbray based on how he was 16 years ago. It's like comparing the Beatles doing She Loves You to A Day in the Life- they'd completely changed.
I don't pretend to have analysed closely what Mowbray 2025 is compared to the guy we knew years ago- I haven't followed the style of football close enough. However, I would say he is wiser and more pragmatic, with more soldiers now as part of his team.
I spoke to several fans today, with only one really enthusiastic about the appointment, with many stuck in the 2009 relegation time warp.
However, as the guy behind me said, Mowbray may be the guy to get a tune out of Grady, Swift and one or two others.
As much as I liked CC, he was a safety first manager where the team were well drilled, with little room for flair.
I'm actually more enthusiastic for his appointment after today.
Time will tell, but given the interview that was posted where he says we ‘played great football’ when we got relegated from Prem, I have some nagging doubts. We didn’t play great football we played relegation quality football and Hansen was absolutely spot on.
I don’t necessarily think it’s an indication he hasn’t changed but I remember him saying many times that season “Yeah we lost but if we play like that we’ll be absolutely fine”. Meanwhile young me was thinking “it doesn’t look to me like we’ll be fine, we’re way out of our depth”
Posts: 17,084
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
In addition to Birdie's excellent summary, it's also worth pointing out that we finished only 4 points short of safety that season, so we weren't hopelessly cast adrift as some like to suggest.
Anyway, that was then and this is now, and Mogga doesn't approach it in the same way these days defensively as he did in his early 40s.
Posts: 8,841
Threads: 315
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
78
(01-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
This fan liked it very much indeed. From not being able to attend a match without seeing away fans celebrating a goal, it became a fairly rare sight, which I greatly appreciated.
Anyway, as for Mowbray, neither of his last two teams who visited the Hawthorns, Blues or Sunderland featured suicidal artistic defending and the Sunderland team looked very good indeed.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
01-19-2025, 06:33 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-19-2025, 06:34 PM by Tom Joad.)
(01-19-2025, 05:41 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (01-19-2025, 05:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-19-2025, 04:20 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Some just point blank refuses to accept years have passed and he's changed dramatically, to them Mowbray is the exact same manager we had back then.
He's changed a lot, there's a pragmatism to his game now, that if he had developed here he'd have kept us up that season, but he had to learn it the hard way, in lower leagues
Did have to learn it? It was obvious from the moment he arrived we played far too open and that at a higher level we would struggle as teams would take the chances Championship teams missed.
My comment above is based on his recent interview where he said Hansen used to slate us every week for not defending but he believed we played great stuff. That makes me question if he’s changed as much as others have said. Time will tell.
By a few metrics, with the stuff people complained about CC, we did play good football, we were always on 'the front foot', still a stupid phrase. We kept possession well, our passing numbers were good, what we couldn't do was score enough goals to make up for our often shambolic defending, but according to some on this board, defending is boring and it's all about attacking and scoring goals.
Mowbray's mistakes were twofold, first, not breaking the wage structure, to survive you need one or two stars earning more than the others who are key to you, as we did with Odemwingie as an example. Secondly thinking we could defend by retaining possession rather than by defensive shape and organisation and winning the ball back, it's a pretty but very naive look at football that simply doesn't work in England, it works for Barcelona etc where teams are so scared of your attack they may back off a bit, but in England we do like to tackle, and you'll always have to deal with not having the ball for significant periods, and all English teams know how to counter quickly.
We've played Mowbray several times since he left here, and his teams have defended far better, often needing our significantly better players than he had available to unlock them rather than just easily opening them, as we were guilty of under his management. While keeping his core values still intact, values similar to Corberan, different being Corberan was far more intent on a clean sheet than fans liked, Mowbray generally seems to be less so.
Oh yes we did. Just a couple on here thought it was boring. I always felt we were more likely to win than lose under CC.
|