Mowbray
#61
I didn’t want to be disrespectful to Mowbray in my last post but it’s so easy to put sentiment over reality.He has obviously gone through a lot and nobody really knows how he will come back in terms of 100% recovery.Let’s be honest when Mowbray was with us we had really good exciting times in the Championship and also the FA Cup followed by a real naive spell in the Premier League.
I do think he changed and evolved as years went on and his record at both Blackburn and Sunderland for progressing the young players and building a good young squad is not to be sniffed at.I’ve always thought of him as a manager who improves the younger players and builds a club up for the next manager to come along.
Unfortunately Mowbray has also been a manager who is not a half way through a season appointment,he needs a full pre season.I know we won the League with him ,with a very good team but I’ve always had my doubts if he can finish the job off anymore in terms of winning promotion.His philosophy has always come across that entertainment and improving players comes before results.That is all well and good but every team needs results to get where they want to be.
Reply
#62
(01-14-2025, 09:16 AM)aj21 Wrote: I've never understood why certain Albion fans loved him so much, however if he got the job I wouldn't judge him on what he did with us. It was 16 years since he last managed us, football has changed so much during that time and he will have changed as a manager.

I think it is very difficult to judge who will be a good appointment - unless it was a dinosaur like Bruce, Sam, Pardew.

Getting us promoted deserves lots of credit, much, much more than some managers have done yet they got cult followings, whilst the achievers get doubted... It's very weird.
Reply
#63
(01-14-2025, 09:18 AM)1952 Wrote: All the managers names banded about have had some success. But, they have also failed and been sacked. Their failures out weigh their successes.
It's a lottery whether we will pick someone that's a success or failure or somewhere in between. But if we have a blueprint of what's needed and only the top management know this, we need to choose someone that matches as close as possible to it. I'm sure they are learning as they go along the pitfalls of appointing someone in England. 
One thing for sure the vocal majority will be anti whoever. 
I for one will back whoever the new man is but will criticise when they get it wrong.
Roll on an appointment.

Agree on both points. Appointing any manager is somewhat of a gamble. But we do need one, and quickly. We are treading water atm.
Reply
#64
(01-14-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:16 AM)aj21 Wrote: I've never understood why certain Albion fans loved him so much, however if he got the job I wouldn't judge him on what he did with us. It was 16 years since he last managed us, football has changed so much during that time and he will have changed as a manager. 

I think it is very difficult to judge who will be a good appointment - unless it was a dinosaur like Bruce, Sam, Pardew.

Getting us promoted deserves lots of credit, much, much more than some managers have done yet they got cult followings, whilst the achievers get doubted... It's very weird.

Robson, Mowbray = bad
Corberan, Di Matteo = good
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#65
(01-14-2025, 09:23 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:16 AM)aj21 Wrote: I've never understood why certain Albion fans loved him so much, however if he got the job I wouldn't judge him on what he did with us. It was 16 years since he last managed us, football has changed so much during that time and he will have changed as a manager. 

I think it is very difficult to judge who will be a good appointment - unless it was a dinosaur like Bruce, Sam, Pardew.

Getting us promoted deserves lots of credit, much, much more than some managers have done yet they got cult followings, whilst the achievers get doubted... It's very weird.

Robson, Mowbray = bad
Corberan, Di Matteo = good

You forgot Slav on the bad list and Val on the good...
Reply
#66
(01-14-2025, 09:23 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:23 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:16 AM)aj21 Wrote: I've never understood why certain Albion fans loved him so much, however if he got the job I wouldn't judge him on what he did with us. It was 16 years since he last managed us, football has changed so much during that time and he will have changed as a manager. 

I think it is very difficult to judge who will be a good appointment - unless it was a dinosaur like Bruce, Sam, Pardew.

Getting us promoted deserves lots of credit, much, much more than some managers have done yet they got cult followings, whilst the achievers get doubted... It's very weird.

Robson, Mowbray = bad
Corberan, Di Matteo = good

You forgot Slav on the bad list and Val on the good...

Classics of the genre.
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#67
I have rarely been able to pick who will be good and who will be bad. I was disappointed with Atkinson when we appointed him from Cambridge, I thought Ossie would be a disaster and just last August I tipped QPR for the top 3 based on their manager who is now close to getting sacked. So you should probably take this with a pinch of salt.
What I want to see is a steady improvement on and off the field. If this means taking a tried and tested manager with experience of improving clubs at this level like Mowbray or Eustace, then I am fine about it. Part of me is scared that a young, euro progressive coach might well fail due to lack of experience, or even due to lack of patience. As we are in 6th place, I basically don't want anyone that might take us backwards. I like to think that long term, Nestor/Patel will know more about this league and will make an appointment based on their business plan, for now though I'd play it safe for the short term.
Reply
#68
(01-14-2025, 08:55 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 07:59 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 07:44 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 07:34 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I’d be distinctly underwhelmed by his appointment as it would make me question the direction we were going in as a club, particularly given what has been said about the system we want to employ and the “other” candidates mentioned - he’s quite a different proposition to Hake or Wicky for example.

But, let’s look at his CV:

Hibs - their two best finishes in a decade and cup finals 
WBA - took over a mess from Barny, two Wembley appearances and a league champion. Laid foundations for our future success with a string of excellent signings 
Celtic - a complete mess 
Boro - sorted out a mess inherited from Strachan and moved them out of relegation and safely into mid table before missing the playoffs next yea
Coventry - dragged them clear of relegation and then just missed the playoffs following season despite al the chaos of SISU
Blackburn - inherited a club in freefall, but won promotion at the first attempt, made huge profit on players and improved their league position every season despite the Venkys influence 
Sunderland - took a young, newly promoted side into playoffs, harshly sacked last season and the wheels well and truly came off after he left 
Blues - took over Rooney’s mess and took 13 points from 8 games - they’d have comfortably survived had he not been taken ill 

All of this is punctuated with a huge number of young players developed and sold on for profit and at least an attempt at playing decent football. 

I’m sure Derek will come along and say about how he had a huge budget with us, and a decent budget at Blackburn but on both occasions he’s won promotion when he’s been given the tools to. There are plenty of managers (usually the ones he follows) that can’t make that claim.

Admittedly he wasn’t my first choice, far, far from it, but his record is as good as they come. Consistently improves finishing positions year on year, has an immediate impact, develops youth and attempts to play the right way.
Whilst I’m quite content with Mowbray your first paragraph is absolutely spot on. I think you mocked Stoke (rightly) when they appointed Robins for veering between different types of manager / head coach in Schumacher / Pelach / Robins. To have Mowbray and Wicky in the running suggests you don’t have a clear direction you want to go in. 

Three weeks in without a head coach and that confusion in the type we want suggests a criminal lack of planning which is all the more worrying when Carlos was linked with every job going since May.

Managerial appointments are always a bit haphazard as different options become available at different times - since CC left we’ve seen Edwards and Dyche become available who I imagine we’d have had an interest in talking to, and pending his hospital results, Mogga too so I’m not overly concerned about different candidates coming into the fold late in the process.

I do agree that to go from Wicky to Mowbray is quite some swing, but Mogga has worked with DoFs before, his teams of late have pressed, moved the ball wide quickly, and looked to dominate possession, so not a million miles off what CC has done and Wicky was reported to have done in Switzerland.

The big difference is that Mowbray is 61 and has been around the block a bit, and subsequently invites comparisons with Bruce, Fat Sam and Pardew, and that’s where the negativity is coming from. I’d also argue since we all got excited by the mere mention of Urs Fischer, it’ll be tough for anyone else to meet expectations - the man who took a second tier club into the Champions Lwague on a shoe string whilst playing attacking football is always the dream.

As you dragged me into the conversation

Managers I’ve backed:

Megson (right from the start)
RDM (harder league more impressive promotion)
Hodgson (best manager we have had for decades)
Pulis (did a good job for two season no matter what the spin) 
Bruce (fuck knows what I was thinking Wink ) 

I didn’t back Mowbray because he was naive, condescending and in the end hypocritical. If fans raised concerns about our lack of defensive acumen at football forums he would suggest they didn’t know what they were talking about. He took the high moral ground when we lost to clubs above us such as Blues, Stoke and Sunderland because we apparently played the right way. He then told players to be loyal only to move to a tin pot Scottish league where it’s harder to fail than it is to succeed with Celtic. 

We went up with a very low points total in a league where only Stoke got anywhere near what we had to spend on the squad. 

I wish him well and good health, but I would be a hypocrite to say I want him back aa our manager. That said if it happens let’s hope he does well because we are one managerial mistake away from finding ourselves getting further and further away from being competitive in this division.

I think your concerns are valid Derek, and I'm not calling for TM's return, I'm simply trying to say that he's had a far better record than many managers and deserves more credit than I think you give him for that promotion season. Yes we had a decent budget, but we completely rebuilt the squad in one summer, brought players in from all over Europe and moulded them into a side that won the league and making about £15m in profit when that was a huge amount of cash... for all this talk of it being a weaker league that year, noone else seemed to piss it!
Reply
#69
(01-14-2025, 09:19 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(01-14-2025, 09:16 AM)aj21 Wrote: I've never understood why certain Albion fans loved him so much, however if he got the job I wouldn't judge him on what he did with us. It was 16 years since he last managed us, football has changed so much during that time and he will have changed as a manager. 

I think it is very difficult to judge who will be a good appointment - unless it was a dinosaur like Bruce, Sam, Pardew.

Getting us promoted deserves lots of credit, much, much more than some managers have done yet they got cult followings, whilst the achievers get doubted... It's very weird.

Not sure that is true. Mowbray, Di Matteo, Slav, Clarke all had their good points and all had faults. Mowbray was the only one who walked out - understandably so. Di Matteo, Slav, Clarke, Moore you could say were all harshly sacked. Val, Mel, Bruce, Sam, Pardew, Irvine and Robson were all terrible.
Reply
#70
(01-14-2025, 09:47 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: I have rarely been able to pick who will be good and who will be bad. I was disappointed with Atkinson when we appointed him from Cambridge, I thought Ossie would be a disaster and just last August I tipped QPR for the top 3 based on their manager who is now close to getting sacked. So you should probably take this with a pinch of salt.
What I want to see is a steady improvement on and off the field. If this means taking a tried and tested manager with experience of improving clubs at this level like Mowbray or Eustace, then I am fine about it. Part of me is scared that a young, euro progressive coach might well fail due to lack of experience, or even due to lack of patience. As we are in 6th place, I basically don't want anyone that might take us backwards. I like to think that long term, Nestor/Patel will know more about this league and will make an appointment based on their business plan, for now though I'd play it safe for the short term.
Well said mate. We all come on and talk like experts and point to instances when we were right, but I'm the same as you in that I've got it wrong more than right and I think that applies to most if they are honest.

My hair nearly fell out when they announced Megson, I was that angry!! (and I've got a good head of hair, like the tall Bee Gee, not the little ones)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)