Budget nonsense
(01-09-2025, 11:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?

That’s not the smoking gun you think it is, when Labour were asking for an even more incontinent spunking of cash / longer lockdowns etc.
Reply
Clueless Sir Jon Cunliffe on R4 this morning - career civil servant and former Deputy Governor (financial stability) for the BoE.

Agreeing with the truth that "Rachel Reeves will either have to raise taxes, cut spending or break her own fiscal rules", he was then asked what she can do to increase growth - the only answer he could come up with was to build some more houses. The utter poverty of aspiration and innovation amongst the economic elite.

Separately Rachel Reeves is asking Cabinet colleagues to come up with ideas for growth. I cannot wait for the inspired gamechangers from the ex-lawyers, social workers, charity leaders and never-had-a-proper-job-outside-politics wonks.

Liz Truss was right about one thing. We do need a paradigm shift in thinking, and the BoE and Civil Service are clearly incapable of it.
Reply
(01-10-2025, 06:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 11:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?

That’s not the smoking gun you think it is, when Labour were asking for an even more incontinent spunking of cash / longer lockdowns etc.

And once again, the simplistic view of it was lockdown or it was the GFC is peddled out. The focus of the simple views always appears to be those that fit your narrative whilst ignoring the real issues. In 2010 following the GFC we set off on a journey of reducing the state structure, or at least not maintaining it, with cuts to government spending in the name of austerity. This small state view chipped away at the foundations of society through removing policing, stretching the health services to breaking point year after year under the guise of 'improving productivity', taking away the youth services, stripping local government of funding and playing 'which cup is the ball in' with social care, and many other defunding of the state ideas based on a flawed ideology. 

When this didn't go to plan the focus then went onto the 'others', the reason for the failures in society was because of all of those nasty foreigners coming over here and taking our services without paying in bullshit that was peddled and the distraction became Brexit, another failed tilt at windmills that undermined our foundations even further.

Then came Covid, a situation that we were completely unprepared for because of the ravaging of our services which was made worse by incompetents at the wheel suggesting we 'just get on with it; and create herd immunity. And when that didn't work we needed harder lockdowns because we'd fucked up the initial reaction. Labour weren't calling for longer lockdowns because of ideology, they were calling for it because of the initial actions that left no options.

Todays issues aren't because Reeves raised NI rates for businesses, they are because an ideology has failed the country and there are still people that can't recognise the reasons we are where we are and still blame anything but the real problems. The absolute brass balls of those on here that can complain about a tax rise after standing by and watching us reach the highest tax burden ever under the Tories is astounding. Reeves had virtually no levers to pull because of the position she inherited.
Reply
(01-10-2025, 06:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 11:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?

That’s not the smoking gun you think it is, when Labour were asking for an even more incontinent spunking of cash / longer lockdowns etc.

Who was IN CHARGE of the money printing?
Reply
(01-10-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-10-2025, 06:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 11:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?

That’s not the smoking gun you think it is, when Labour were asking for an even more incontinent spunking of cash / longer lockdowns etc.

And once again, the simplistic view of it was lockdown or it was the GFC is peddled out. The focus of the simple views always appears to be those that fit your narrative whilst ignoring the real issues. In 2010 following the GFC we set off on a journey of reducing the state structure, or at least not maintaining it, with cuts to government spending in the name of austerity. This small state view chipped away at the foundations of society through removing policing, stretching the health services to breaking point year after year under the guise of 'improving productivity', taking away the youth services, stripping local government of funding and playing 'which cup is the ball in' with social care, and many other defunding of the state ideas based on a flawed ideology. 

When this didn't go to plan the focus then went onto the 'others', the reason for the failures in society was because of all of those nasty foreigners coming over here and taking our services without paying in bullshit that was peddled and the distraction became Brexit, another failed tilt at windmills that undermined our foundations even further.

Then came Covid, a situation that we were completely unprepared for because of the ravaging of our services which was made worse by incompetents at the wheel suggesting we 'just get on with it; and create herd immunity. And when that didn't work we needed harder lockdowns because we'd fucked up the initial reaction. Labour weren't calling for longer lockdowns because of ideology, they were calling for it because of the initial actions that left no options.

Todays issues aren't because Reeves raised NI rates for businesses, they are because an ideology has failed the country and there are still people that can't recognise the reasons we are where we are and still blame anything but the real problems. The absolute brass balls of those on here that can complain about a tax rise after standing by and watching us reach the highest tax burden ever under the Tories is astounding. Reeves had virtually no levers to pull because of the position she inherited.

Quality only missing out the disaster of Brexit
Reply
Who was in charge of that?
Reply
(01-10-2025, 09:40 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Who was IN CHARGE of the money printing?

The BoE & the bond market, essentially. Without them you can't borrow.
Reply
Excellent. Can’t blame Rachel for anything based on that logic.

Glad that’s cleared up.
Reply
(01-10-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-10-2025, 06:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 11:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?

That’s not the smoking gun you think it is, when Labour were asking for an even more incontinent spunking of cash / longer lockdowns etc.

And once again, the simplistic view of it was lockdown or it was the GFC is peddled out. The focus of the simple views always appears to be those that fit your narrative whilst ignoring the real issues. In 2010 following the GFC we set off on a journey of reducing the state structure, or at least not maintaining it, with cuts to government spending in the name of austerity. This small state view chipped away at the foundations of society through removing policing, stretching the health services to breaking point year after year under the guise of 'improving productivity', taking away the youth services, stripping local government of funding and playing 'which cup is the ball in' with social care, and many other defunding of the state ideas based on a flawed ideology. 

When this didn't go to plan the focus then went onto the 'others', the reason for the failures in society was because of all of those nasty foreigners coming over here and taking our services without paying in bullshit that was peddled and the distraction became Brexit, another failed tilt at windmills that undermined our foundations even further.

Then came Covid, a situation that we were completely unprepared for because of the ravaging of our services which was made worse by incompetents at the wheel suggesting we 'just get on with it; and create herd immunity. And when that didn't work we needed harder lockdowns because we'd fucked up the initial reaction. Labour weren't calling for longer lockdowns because of ideology, they were calling for it because of the initial actions that left no options.

Todays issues aren't because Reeves raised NI rates for businesses, they are because an ideology has failed the country and there are still people that can't recognise the reasons we are where we are and still blame anything but the real problems. The absolute brass balls of those on here that can complain about a tax rise after standing by and watching us reach the highest tax burden ever under the Tories is astounding. Reeves had virtually no levers to pull because of the position she inherited.

You've absolutely hit on the real issue. The real issue is that the GFC and botched response to it provided an absolutely golden opportunity to have an honest conversation about the role of the state and public sector reform. As it is the Tories, partly because they were hamstrung by the Lib Dems took the easier route of chipping away at spending. 

Let's not pretend anything else was on offer at the 2010 election either shall we? It wasn't.

I don't recognise your narrative on health services at all. The only time they have ever consistently improved productivity since 1997 was during the coalition years when the NHS was still receiving huge increases year on year. 

The real issue is that we can't afford the public services we have, let alone the public services people might want. The nation faces a choice - either ever more taxation creating a doom loop which will require ever more taxation to maintain services (that's what's happened since 2015), or a serious conversation about what the state does and whet individuals, families and businesses should do for themselves.

Allied to radical liberalising of our economy I'd suggest the announcement tomorrow that the Triple Lock will end in March. State Pensions will only rise in line with CPI inflation in future. Higher Rate relief on Pension Contributions should go - with the proviso that pensions go back outside the IHT envelope. Private provision of healthcare ought to be incentivised through the tax system rather than penalised - and an insurance market should be created for social care, with the alternative being the seizure of some or all of individuals largely unearned housing wealth upon death for those with assets and safety net for those without.

You'll note I complained consistently about the Tories essentially aping the big state-big tax-big borrowing narrative of the Labour Party - particularly after Osborne left office (and he was bad enough). I also called Hunt's foolish bear traps on NI out for what they were.

This is real issue Ponty - very few politicians will be honest with you. We've returned to the same godawful state we were in when we entered the 1970s - but this time without the promise of North Sea Oil.

Unless you're going to tell me the "Real Issue" is something different (when it isn't)

(01-10-2025, 11:50 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Excellent. Can’t blame Rachel for anything based on that logic.

Glad that’s cleared up.

Domestic and global policy by governments creates the bond market. There's plenty to blame Reeves, Hunt, Javid, Osborne & Brown about - amongst others.

Their recklessness has brought us here.
Reply
(01-10-2025, 12:06 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-10-2025, 08:46 AM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-10-2025, 06:30 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 11:25 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?

That’s not the smoking gun you think it is, when Labour were asking for an even more incontinent spunking of cash / longer lockdowns etc.

And once again, the simplistic view of it was lockdown or it was the GFC is peddled out. The focus of the simple views always appears to be those that fit your narrative whilst ignoring the real issues. In 2010 following the GFC we set off on a journey of reducing the state structure, or at least not maintaining it, with cuts to government spending in the name of austerity. This small state view chipped away at the foundations of society through removing policing, stretching the health services to breaking point year after year under the guise of 'improving productivity', taking away the youth services, stripping local government of funding and playing 'which cup is the ball in' with social care, and many other defunding of the state ideas based on a flawed ideology. 

When this didn't go to plan the focus then went onto the 'others', the reason for the failures in society was because of all of those nasty foreigners coming over here and taking our services without paying in bullshit that was peddled and the distraction became Brexit, another failed tilt at windmills that undermined our foundations even further.

Then came Covid, a situation that we were completely unprepared for because of the ravaging of our services which was made worse by incompetents at the wheel suggesting we 'just get on with it; and create herd immunity. And when that didn't work we needed harder lockdowns because we'd fucked up the initial reaction. Labour weren't calling for longer lockdowns because of ideology, they were calling for it because of the initial actions that left no options.

Todays issues aren't because Reeves raised NI rates for businesses, they are because an ideology has failed the country and there are still people that can't recognise the reasons we are where we are and still blame anything but the real problems. The absolute brass balls of those on here that can complain about a tax rise after standing by and watching us reach the highest tax burden ever under the Tories is astounding. Reeves had virtually no levers to pull because of the position she inherited.

You've absolutely hit on the real issue. The real issue is that the GFC and botched response to it provided an absolutely golden opportunity to have an honest conversation about the role of the state and public sector reform. As it is the Tories, partly because they were hamstrung by the Lib Dems took the easier route of chipping away at spending. 

Let's not pretend anything else was on offer at the 2010 election either shall we? It wasn't.

I don't recognise your narrative on health services at all. The only time they have ever consistently improved productivity since 1997 was during the coalition years when the NHS was still receiving huge increases year on year. 

The real issue is that we can't afford the public services we have, let alone the public services people might want. The nation faces a choice - either ever more taxation creating a doom loop which will require ever more taxation to maintain services (that's what's happened since 2015), or a serious conversation about what the state does and whet individuals, families and businesses should do for themselves.

Allied to radical liberalising of our economy I'd suggest the announcement tomorrow that the Triple Lock will end in March. State Pensions will only rise in line with CPI inflation in future. Higher Rate relief on Pension Contributions should go - with the proviso that pensions go back outside the IHT envelope. Private provision of healthcare ought to be incentivised through the tax system rather than penalised - and an insurance market should be created for social care, with the alternative being the seizure of some or all of individuals largely unearned housing wealth upon death for those with assets and safety net for those without.

You'll note I complained consistently about the Tories essentially aping the big state-big tax-big borrowing narrative of the Labour Party - particularly after Osborne left office (and he was bad enough). I also called Hunt's foolish bear traps on NI out for what they were.

This is real issue Ponty - very few politicians will be honest with you. We've returned to the same godawful state we were in when we entered the 1970s - but this time without the promise of North Sea Oil.

Unless you're going to tell me the "Real Issue" is something different (when it isn't)

(01-10-2025, 11:50 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Excellent. Can’t blame Rachel for anything based on that logic.

Glad that’s cleared up.

Domestic and global policy by governments creates the bond market. There's plenty to blame Reeves, Hunt, Javid, Osborne & Brown about - amongst others.

Their recklessness has brought us here.

Go on then sell the small state, low regulation dream… bullet points will do. Tell us what you’re cutting and how those services will be replaced. Be honest.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)