Budget nonsense
(01-09-2025, 01:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Which is fine Proth, and by the way I don’t disagree with everything you say there, but how has the Reeves budget managed to impact the US Bond market in exactly the same way? Chunks main measure for his ire is the bond market which is, and has been, lock step with the US equivalent.

Reeves Budget is based on the conceit that you can continue borrowing historically high amounts of money as interest rates return to their long run average. You can’t.

She’s not been alone in this conceit, as I have mentioned ad nauseum for much of the last 17 years.
Reply
(01-09-2025, 02:37 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 01:20 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Which is fine Proth, and by the way I don’t disagree with everything you say there, but how has the Reeves budget managed to impact the US Bond market in exactly the same way? Chunks main measure for his ire is the bond market which is, and has been, lock step with the US equivalent.

Reeves Budget is based on the conceit that you can continue borrowing historically high amounts of money as interest rates return to their long run average. You can’t.

She’s not been alone in this conceit, as I have mentioned ad nauseum for much of the last 17 years.

Perhaps Osborne should have borrowed rather than Austerity?

Hindsight is a wonderful thing!
Reply
(01-09-2025, 03:13 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Perhaps Osborne should have borrowed rather than Austerity?

Perhaps he should have got on with some actual austerity when he had the political capital to do so.
Reply
(01-09-2025, 03:46 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 03:13 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Perhaps Osborne should have borrowed rather than Austerity?

Perhaps he should have got on with some actual austerity when he had the political capital to do so.

He certainly had more options than we have now.
Reply
(01-09-2025, 12:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:57 AM)baggy1 Wrote: UK 10Y bond yields against the various Tory prime ministers over the past few years. Interesting reading - The yield whilst Johnson was in office went up 450% from 0.688 to 3.095 including a 6 month period to 6th Sept 2022 that saw an increase of 2.4 or 207%, I must have missed the outcry at that point.

Truss speaks for itself and wasn't long enough to get a measure although the trend continued, but the great saviour that was Sunak saw a climb again from 3.496 to 4.1282 - growth of 118% and a six month period to 3rd July 23 of 137%. Again the rage seems to have passed me by.

Meanwhile the increase in Starmer's 1st 6 month stands at 110% from 4.1282 to 4.555 - release the hounds indeed.

Here's what I posted a few days ago, I really don't recall your panic when the above was happening, over 200% increase in 6 months during Johnsons tenure and 450% increase overall. Sunak hitting 137% including in a 6 month period and overall just short of 118%. Whereas 4.792 today marks 116% for Starmer. Add that to the video posted by Logic above and a bit of context about dealing with the shit left behind shows we're pretty fucked but your anger at the current mob seems very misplaced, or indeed not matching the anger at the firestarters.

Your knowledge of statistics appears to be as good as your knowledge of economics. A movement from 3.496 to 4.1282 is a growth of 18% not 118% as you state above (similar for your other figures). In addition, percentage increases when talking about relatively small numbers are misleading as are quoting statistics with little context. The real question to be asked is how the changes in UK rates compare to other countries - a comparison which will reflect domestic issues rather than global economic trends.
Reply
Fair point on the growth % figure however the point is missed entirely it appears. I’ve said many times we’re fucked, my issue is blaming Labour after 6 months especially as we appear to be tied to what happens in the states.

And the more specific point is that Chunk is having a coronary because of the bonds reaching 4.5 when he was silent when there was a 4.5 times increase under Johnson and ended up on 4.1 under Sunak, without even looking at the Truss figure. The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at 4.651 and there was silence.

The damage to the bond markets was done between July and Oct 22 and we haven’t recovered. Blaming Starmer for this mess is the same as blaming the cleaning company for the puke on the carpet after the Christmas party.
Reply
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.
Reply
(01-09-2025, 09:09 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(01-09-2025, 08:26 PM)baggy1 Wrote: The movement under Starmer has been 0.67, the movement under Johnson was 2.41 and Sunak had a 6 month period that saw an increase of 1.14 leaving us at  4.651 and there was silence.

Once again you're completely ignoring the inflationary spike post-Covid / energy prices. What did you expect to happen to bond yields after we printed so much money to deal with those two issues? 

All the current yield indicates is how completely unsustainable the trajectory is. Unless you have substantial growth, which will not be forthcoming if Reeves does not change course substantially. Like I said earlier, she thought she was a very clever civil servant delivering a budget for civil servants. But completely detached from reality.

Who was in charge of the money printing?
Reply
As I said earlier, far more important than the absolute rate is the rate relative to other countries. We are now borrowing at 130 basis points above Italy....yes, Italy.
Reply
[Image: this-is-fine_custom-b7c50c845a78f5d77164...=85&f=webp]
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)