Ridiculous & excessive substitutions
#41
(01-04-2025, 05:34 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 05:14 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Anybody thinking the substitutions cost us 2 points today is delusional.

It was down to poor defending in one situation.

Whether 5 substitutes being an option is good for the game is open to debate, increasingly I think not.

It’s not the amount of subs but the type of subs. We change forwards because they are tired but desert the defenders.
I would argue that fatigue played more than a small part in Heggem’s reaction for Allen’s goal. Defenders get tired too! With Barts and Taylor on the bench we had better options than Swift. 
It was obvious that they were pushing for the equaliser so nothing wrong with strengthening the defence for the last 10. It just doesn’t seem to be the done thing any more.

You might be right but could easily say bringing on a defender for the last few minutes is a risk where they have to adjust to the speed of the game immediately and can't afford a mistake whilst doing so. I do think in today's case though barts might have been a good idea
Reply
#42
(01-04-2025, 05:42 PM)TartanRug Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 05:34 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 05:14 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Anybody thinking the substitutions cost us 2 points today is delusional.

It was down to poor defending in one situation.

Whether 5 substitutes being an option is good for the game is open to debate, increasingly I think not.

It’s not the amount of subs but the type of subs. We change forwards because they are tired but desert the defenders.
I would argue that fatigue played more than a small part in Heggem’s reaction for Allen’s goal. Defenders get tired too! With Barts and Taylor on the bench we had better options than Swift. 
It was obvious that they were pushing for the equaliser so nothing wrong with strengthening the defence for the last 10. It just doesn’t seem to be the done thing any more.

You might be right but could easily say bringing on a defender for the last few minutes is a risk where they have to adjust to the speed of the game immediately and can't afford a mistake whilst doing so. I do think in today's case though barts might have been a good idea
Yeah, hindsight is a wonderful thing isn’t it? Imagine if Taylor had come on and conceded that goal, would have been carnage!  Smile 
Stand by my thoughts though that, in general, subs should be reactive to what’s happening rather than dictated by pre-ordained plans, that only seem to consider the wellbeing of forwards!
Reply
#43
(01-04-2025, 05:14 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Anybody thinking the substitutions cost us 2 points today is delusional.

It was down to poor defending in one situation.

Whether 5 substitutes being an option is good for the game is open to debate, increasingly I think not.

Stats don’t support that (possession & chances) …conversely for someone to suggest substitutions (both positively and negatively) didn’t profoundly affect the game is truly delusional 

Swift introduction and where he played was bizarre 

Then to take both forwards off (with at least 15 mins of play remaining) was only ever going to make us much less likely to keep the ball in their final third & more unlikely to score & kill the game

The two who went off have got 18 goals this season …two who came on have scored 0 ?
Reply
#44
I cannot comment on the match as I’ve been out all day, but I would love to know how many of you championship coaches we have posting on here, because reading some of your posts make me think some of you should be at Man City you know that much.
I will ask this do any of you know why the subs were made, no you don’t, do you know who was injured or totally knackered after the run of games again no you don’t. The subs were made by coach’s,ex players and in all know more about the health and well being of the players. So they did what they thought was right. But next time I’m sure they will check on here to see who they should substitute because we all know better don’t we.
Reply
#45
(01-04-2025, 06:19 PM)Baggeridgebaggy Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 05:14 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Anybody thinking the substitutions cost us 2 points today is delusional.

It was down to poor defending in one situation.

Whether 5 substitutes being an option is good for the game is open to debate, increasingly I think not.

Stats don’t support that (possession & chances) …conversely for someone to suggest substitutions (both positively and negatively) didn’t profoundly affect the game is truly delusional 

Swift introduction and where he played was bizarre 

Then to take both forwards off (with at least 15 mins of play remaining) was only ever going to make us much less likely to keep the ball in their final third & more unlikely to score & kill the game

The two who went off have got 18 goals this season …two who came on have scored 0 ?
But they were knackered. Maja is ten times better than Cole in every area, sure, but he could hardly move. When you are defending a lead you need someone up there chasing and harrying and he couldn’t do that.

I thought Swift would play ten and KG wide and i think that would have given us better shape.
Reply
#46
(01-04-2025, 06:19 PM)wba13 Wrote: I cannot comment on the match as I’ve been out all day, but I would love to know how many of you championship coaches we have posting on here, because reading some of your posts make me think some of you should be at Man City you know that much.
I will ask this do any of you know why the subs were made, no you don’t, do you know who was injured or totally knackered after the run of games again no you don’t. The subs were made by coach’s,ex players and in all know more about the health and well being of the players. So they did what they thought was right. But next time I’m sure they will check on here to see who they should substitute because we all know better don’t we.

Not sure how qualified you are to criticise others when you’ve not even watched the game, assuming you had something important to do 

And maybe you might contemplate that football or fans interest & involvement (and even this message board) is nothing without an opinion or two, but should i apologise to you for having one?
Reply
#47
(01-04-2025, 06:19 PM)wba13 Wrote: I cannot comment on the match as I’ve been out all day, but I would love to know how many of you championship coaches we have posting on here, because reading some of your posts make me think some of you should be at Man City you know that much.
I will ask this do any of you know why the subs were made, no you don’t, do you know who was injured or totally knackered after the run of games again no you don’t. The subs were made by coach’s,ex players and in all know more about the health and well being of the players. So they did what they thought was right. But next time I’m sure they will check on here to see who they should substitute because we all know better don’t we.

To take that line of thinking to its logical conclusion means we may as well close this discussion forum.
Reply
#48
But all your discussions are that Brunty and co were wrong when none of us know the circumstances behind those subs, this discussion is had most weeks and most weeks we have no idea of what is going on out on the pitch, health wise.
I will leave this discussion to you lot.
Reply
#49
(01-04-2025, 06:51 PM)wba13 Wrote: But all your discussions are that Brunty and co were wrong when none of us know the circumstances behind those subs, this discussion is had most weeks and most weeks we have no idea of what is going on out on the pitch, health wise.
I will leave this discussion to you lot.

You can’t tell me that defenders are healthier than midfielders and forwards though mate and that’s the discussion.
Furlong and Heggem have played virtually every minute, never come off. Maja, Fellows, Johnstone rarely play 90.
Today’s subs, as with most week’s, were predominantly tactical and that is subjective therefore open to debate.
Reply
#50
(01-04-2025, 06:51 PM)wba13 Wrote: But all your discussions are that Brunty and co were wrong when none of us know the circumstances behind those subs, this discussion is had most weeks and most weeks we have no idea of what is going on out on the pitch, health wise.
I will leave this discussion to you lot.

The 5 that came off were not the problem. It was the timing and replacements that left alot to be desired. 

I am not sure why you are unwilling to consider the analyst, loan manager and youth GK coach may have got it wrong?
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: