Ridiculous & excessive substitutions
#31
(01-04-2025, 03:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Hindsight is a wonderful thing. As soon as we went 1-0 up we invited pressure onto us. If we'd brought on another centreback then the criticism would have been "well now we're going even more defensive, that's going to invite more pressure", and that's probably correct. The subs are not why we lost.

They were a massive part of the reason. 

We had a decent spell of controlled possession either side of the break. Between 35 and 60 mins we had 11 of our 18 shots. But apart from that it was a poor performance.

After the subs on 66 mins we only had 32% possession.
And we were just as sloppy with it as we had been all game but we didn't have the legs to get on the end of the wayward out balls that we did with MJ, Grant, and Maja up the field.

What subs on 66 minutes? We scored on 66 minutes and only made one sub. Swift for Johnstone. Maja and Grant stayed on until 81 minutes.
Reply
#32
(01-04-2025, 03:46 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 03:39 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-04-2025, 03:24 PM)Sliced Wrote: Hindsight is a wonderful thing. As soon as we went 1-0 up we invited pressure onto us. If we'd brought on another centreback then the criticism would have been "well now we're going even more defensive, that's going to invite more pressure", and that's probably correct. The subs are not why we lost.

They were a massive part of the reason. 

We had a decent spell of controlled possession either side of the break. Between 35 and 60 mins we had 11 of our 18 shots. But apart from that it was a poor performance.

After the subs on 66 mins we only had 32% possession.
And we were just as sloppy with it as we had been all game but we didn't have the legs to get on the end of the wayward out balls that we did with MJ, Grant, and Maja up the field.

What subs on 66 minutes? We scored on 66 minutes and only made one sub. Swift for Johnstone. Maja and Grant stayed on until 81 minutes.

Apologies 68 mins the swift sub. The 2 last subs were far too late considering the lack of possession retention, as I alluded to above I think the subs were both wrong and poorly timed. 

But to be fair we do have an analyst, loan manager and youth team goalie coach on the bench at the moment doing their best.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#33
I really don't think we completely changed our way of playing because Swift came on is the point. We went a goal down and did as we have done time and time again this season, we sat back. Maja was completely out on his feet after 81 mins so i understand why he was taken off, and Diangana for Grant isn't super controversial either. Grady won a couple of fouls high up the pitch for us in the last ten minutes.

We should've really been out of sight by then.

I just think it's a bit harsh bemoaning the subs when Mowatt and Fellows coming on gave us the impetus to take the lead in the first place.
Reply
#34
(01-04-2025, 03:54 PM)Sliced Wrote: I really don't think we completely changed our way of playing because Swift came on is the point. We went a goal down and did as we have done time and time again this season, we sat back. Maja was completely out on his feet after 81 mins so i understand why he was taken off, and Diangana for Grant isn't super controversial either. Grady won a couple of fouls high up the pitch for us in the last ten minutes.

We should've really been out of sight by then.

I just think it's a bit harsh bemoaning the subs when Mowatt and Fellows coming on gave us the impetus to take the lead in the first place.

The Mowatt and Fellows subs were fine. 

But the game management when we got ahead was poor. As I say, leaving the front 2 on till 81 when we had lost our share of possession as we stopped picking the loose, frantic passes up, was the wrong choice. 

Putting Swift in the left was wrong, even though I could see why they wanted him on the pitch. Not adding Bart's/Taylor to the defensive line was the wrong choice.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#35
Maja and KG were absolutely knackered. Maja, in particular, could hardly move. Had they not been taken off there would have been moans in here as well…
Reply
#36
When I started going up in 1964 there were no subs then went up to one for an injury and and we had a nucleus of about 15 players who played most of the games ,and the pitches were bloody awful.i don’t get it that they can’t play 90 minutes nowadays
Reply
#37
(01-04-2025, 04:31 PM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Maja and KG were absolutely knackered. Maja, in particular, could hardly move. Had they not been taken off there would have been moans in here as well…

Pretty much how I see it. 

Although, I do think there is an unwritten rule in football that you have to use all subs, regardless of game situation. 

It kills the game as a spectacle for a neutral. 

I completely understand subs around this time of year with a loaded schedule, but even when you have one game a week you see 5 subs made at bizarre times, just for the sake of it. It frustrates me.
Reply
#38
Anybody thinking the substitutions cost us 2 points today is delusional.

It was down to poor defending in one situation.

Whether 5 substitutes being an option is good for the game is open to debate, increasingly I think not.
Reply
#39
(01-04-2025, 04:34 PM)Mickyfudge Wrote: When I started going up in 1964 there were no subs then went up to one for an injury and and we had a nucleus of about 15 players who played most of the games ,and the pitches were bloody awful.i don’t get it that they can’t play 90 minutes nowadays

Computer people sports science people say nooooooo. Which would be justifiable if we weren't getting the number of injuries we still do.

Games gone.
Reply
#40
(01-04-2025, 05:14 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Anybody thinking the substitutions cost us 2 points today is delusional.

It was down to poor defending in one situation.

Whether 5 substitutes being an option is good for the game is open to debate, increasingly I think not.

It’s not the amount of subs but the type of subs. We change forwards because they are tired but desert the defenders.
I would argue that fatigue played more than a small part in Heggem’s reaction for Allen’s goal. Defenders get tired too! With Barts and Taylor on the bench we had better options than Swift. 
It was obvious that they were pushing for the equaliser so nothing wrong with strengthening the defence for the last 10. It just doesn’t seem to be the done thing any more.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)