Maja
(01-02-2025, 11:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: People forget that these owners are not the ones from before Feb 24. ??‍♂️

We still have the same level of external debt, and whilst they have eased the cashflow concerns of the Lai era, they have yet to invest any significant funds into the club.
Reply
So the 1m plus for the training ground was from the tooth fairy?

And as for debt, you suspect they won’t find ways of improving cash flow. I can’t understand this.,They are unlikely to be static .
Reply
(01-02-2025, 11:57 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 11:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: People forget that these owners are not the ones from before Feb 24. ??‍♂️

We still have the same level of external debt, and whilst they have eased the cashflow concerns of the Lai era, they have yet to invest any significant funds into the club.

Has Shilen slipped your Mrs one?
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
(01-02-2025, 10:12 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:00 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:29 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:27 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Well losing him and replacing with a young loan player or player from overseas with potential (we don’t exactly have patient fans, see Diakite for proof) seems a pointless risk when we can sell in the Summer. Whilst we have a chance then we should try and keep the squad together. We can reassess in the summer with a new head coach and far better environment to buy and sell players.
I agree with you here Derek. We need to keep the core of the 1st 11 together as much as we can and improve it if possible. Just by getting rid of Dobbin and McNair we have opened up two opportunities to bring in better options and that alone could be the difference, the margins of 5th-10th are so small.
If we can also offload some fringe players, that will be an added bonus and maybe allow us to further enhance our first 11 options.

How does that help our finances?
Dunno, I'm one of the minority on here who isn't a finance expert, so everything is just an opinion.
Which is why I state "as much as we can", "If possible" and "maybe". I'll leave the actual decisions to the actual experts employed by the club.

If anyone at the club had listened to the financial experts on here over the last two years we would have been well on our way to Division One playing the kids with a few 35yr old journeymen.

No -you’re wrongly conflating the current position with what we would have had to do to avoid administration if Patel hadn’t bought the club earlier this year.   Fortunately that particular risk went away when the sale went through.  That’s a chalk and cheese situation with where we are now.
Reply
(01-02-2025, 12:07 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: So the 1m plus for the training ground was from the tooth fairy?

And as for debt, you suspect they won’t find ways of improving cash flow. I can’t understand this.,They are unlikely to be static .

Small beer. They won't even pay to clean the Brummie. Read the latest Albion Assembly minutes.

Both Villa & Blues had all their debt repaid as part of the structure of the takeover. Villa are in Champions League, Blues are signing £12M players, rebult their broken ground and committing to a massive infrastructure project. And we can't afford to clean and paint our stands.
Reply
(01-02-2025, 10:43 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:33 AM)FFS Sake Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:30 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:55 AM)FFS Sake Wrote: To clarify / correct a few things mentioned on this thread.

Since Patel took over, it's no longer money in the bank we have a problem with, as he is pumping money in to the bank account and is allowed to.

Where the problem lies is our losses.

The accounts for the financial year to 30 June 2024  (23/24) will be made public on or before 31st March 2025. It's envisaged that these accounts will show our largest loss of around £22m.

It's been reported that we've reduced the salary bill by 30% this season
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art...g3qwxxy6ro

Players' salaries for 23/24 totalled £46m.  So we've saved circa £14m in salaries in 24/25 and therefore, loses will be reduced by this amount. We also sold some players this season and their transfer fees will also help the PSR for 24/25.

From this season onwards, the 3 year total of allowable losses has increased from £39m to £41.5m, so we have a little more wiggle room.



Sell Maja for £10m..........

Some people have posted on this thread we wont be able to spend this money (if we sell him) and that we will have to use the loan market.  This isn't true.

If we sell Maja for £10m in Jan and buy another striker for £10m in Jan on the same wages and on a 4 year contract, the effect for PSR will be as follows

24/25 +£7.5m  (+£10m profit on Maja, -£2.5m amortisation of new player's £10m transfer fee)
25/26 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
26/27 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
27/28 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)


26/27 onwards doesn't really matter, as the large loss for 23/24 (envisaged £22m) will no longer be included in the 3 year rolling average figures for PSR

The above is why we were able to sign Mikey and why we gave him a 4 year contract, as we can spread the cost of his transfer fee over 4 years in the accounts.


Happy to help Big Grin

Happy New Year to you all.

The only thing you are forgetting is that we are tens of millions in debt, which is unsustainable. Whilst I agree with your maths on FFP, we do need to reduce the debt, the interest payments are crippling us. I suspect this will be a priority for Patel, who is limited in the amount of cash he can inject to reduce said debt.

The problem with repaying the MSD loan early is that the penal interest will increase the losses and that's the only reason I can think of, as to why the MSD loan is not being repaid early, as we would have to charge the P&L with higher interest charges as a result (with subsequent knock on effect to PSR)

Patel has taken on the Baldie loan and said he will repay this by 30th June 2025. Reason being, this is the last date for the accounts for 24/25 and the loan would have had to have been be written off (charged to the p&l) in full for the year to 24/25 and subsequently increase our losses for 24/25 if Patel didn't take this loan on.

There will be an Early Repayment Charge - possibly as much as 5%, but if the debt is repaid on 1st July 2025, the total cost in the Y/E 30/6/26 accounts will be less than one year's full interest. 

I still suspect there is some "smoke & mirrors" here, and Patel always intended to sell assets to reduce the debt - but I have no proof and could be wrong on that one.

It could be a lot higher than a 5% ERC.  MSD’s loan terms usually do.
Reply
(01-02-2025, 12:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:43 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:33 AM)FFS Sake Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:30 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:55 AM)FFS Sake Wrote: To clarify / correct a few things mentioned on this thread.

Since Patel took over, it's no longer money in the bank we have a problem with, as he is pumping money in to the bank account and is allowed to.

Where the problem lies is our losses.

The accounts for the financial year to 30 June 2024  (23/24) will be made public on or before 31st March 2025. It's envisaged that these accounts will show our largest loss of around £22m.

It's been reported that we've reduced the salary bill by 30% this season
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art...g3qwxxy6ro

Players' salaries for 23/24 totalled £46m.  So we've saved circa £14m in salaries in 24/25 and therefore, loses will be reduced by this amount. We also sold some players this season and their transfer fees will also help the PSR for 24/25.

From this season onwards, the 3 year total of allowable losses has increased from £39m to £41.5m, so we have a little more wiggle room.



Sell Maja for £10m..........

Some people have posted on this thread we wont be able to spend this money (if we sell him) and that we will have to use the loan market.  This isn't true.

If we sell Maja for £10m in Jan and buy another striker for £10m in Jan on the same wages and on a 4 year contract, the effect for PSR will be as follows

24/25 +£7.5m  (+£10m profit on Maja, -£2.5m amortisation of new player's £10m transfer fee)
25/26 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
26/27 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
27/28 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)


26/27 onwards doesn't really matter, as the large loss for 23/24 (envisaged £22m) will no longer be included in the 3 year rolling average figures for PSR

The above is why we were able to sign Mikey and why we gave him a 4 year contract, as we can spread the cost of his transfer fee over 4 years in the accounts.


Happy to help Big Grin

Happy New Year to you all.

The only thing you are forgetting is that we are tens of millions in debt, which is unsustainable. Whilst I agree with your maths on FFP, we do need to reduce the debt, the interest payments are crippling us. I suspect this will be a priority for Patel, who is limited in the amount of cash he can inject to reduce said debt.

The problem with repaying the MSD loan early is that the penal interest will increase the losses and that's the only reason I can think of, as to why the MSD loan is not being repaid early, as we would have to charge the P&L with higher interest charges as a result (with subsequent knock on effect to PSR)

Patel has taken on the Baldie loan and said he will repay this by 30th June 2025. Reason being, this is the last date for the accounts for 24/25 and the loan would have had to have been be written off (charged to the p&l) in full for the year to 24/25 and subsequently increase our losses for 24/25 if Patel didn't take this loan on.

There will be an Early Repayment Charge - possibly as much as 5%, but if the debt is repaid on 1st July 2025, the total cost in the Y/E 30/6/26 accounts will be less than one year's full interest. 

I still suspect there is some "smoke & mirrors" here, and Patel always intended to sell assets to reduce the debt - but I have no proof and could be wrong on that one.

It could be a lot higher than a 5% ERC.  MSD’s loan terms usually do.

I've never seen an ERC above 5% - you may well have. Even if it was 10% the argument holds good. 

I fear this is being used as an excuse.
Reply
(01-02-2025, 10:45 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:30 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:55 AM)FFS Sake Wrote: To clarify / correct a few things mentioned on this thread.

Since Patel took over, it's no longer money in the bank we have a problem with, as he is pumping money in to the bank account and is allowed to.

Where the problem lies is our losses.

The accounts for the financial year to 30 June 2024  (23/24) will be made public on or before 31st March 2025. It's envisaged that these accounts will show our largest loss of around £22m.

It's been reported that we've reduced the salary bill by 30% this season
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art...g3qwxxy6ro

Players' salaries for 23/24 totalled £46m.  So we've saved circa £14m in salaries in 24/25 and therefore, loses will be reduced by this amount. We also sold some players this season and their transfer fees will also help the PSR for 24/25.

From this season onwards, the 3 year total of allowable losses has increased from £39m to £41.5m, so we have a little more wiggle room.



Sell Maja for £10m..........

Some people have posted on this thread we wont be able to spend this money (if we sell him) and that we will have to use the loan market.  This isn't true.

If we sell Maja for £10m in Jan and buy another striker for £10m in Jan on the same wages and on a 4 year contract, the effect for PSR will be as follows

24/25 +£7.5m  (+£10m profit on Maja, -£2.5m amortisation of new player's £10m transfer fee)
25/26 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
26/27 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
27/28 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)


26/27 onwards doesn't really matter, as the large loss for 23/24 (envisaged £22m) will no longer be included in the 3 year rolling average figures for PSR

The above is why we were able to sign Mikey and why we gave him a 4 year contract, as we can spread the cost of his transfer fee over 4 years in the accounts.


Happy to help Big Grin

Happy New Year to you all.

The only thing you are forgetting is that we are tens of millions in debt, which is unsustainable. Whilst I agree with your maths on FFP, we do need to reduce the debt, the interest payments are crippling us. I suspect this will be a priority for Patel, who is limited in the amount of cash he can inject to reduce said debt.

What are you on about? Debt, as you know, is a balance sheet item. He could clear the lot tomorrow, if he wanted to. Where he’s limited by the rules is on the amount of equity he’s allowed to inject to offset losses.

That’s broadly correct.  He could put in equity to repay the MSD loan, although that would trigger a penal early repayment charge, which would only serve to increase the losses.  Regardless of how much equity is put in, the maximum amount that can be offset against at losses is I believe £5m per annum and/or £15m in any one 3-year period.

(01-02-2025, 11:57 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 11:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: People forget that these owners are not the ones from before Feb 24. ??‍♂️

We still have the same level of external debt, and whilst they have eased the cashflow concerns of the Lai era, they have yet to invest any significant funds into the club.

What about the £5m loan owed by Holdings which Patel has already settled?  Is that not significant?

(01-02-2025, 12:28 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 12:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:43 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:33 AM)FFS Sake Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:30 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: The only thing you are forgetting is that we are tens of millions in debt, which is unsustainable. Whilst I agree with your maths on FFP, we do need to reduce the debt, the interest payments are crippling us. I suspect this will be a priority for Patel, who is limited in the amount of cash he can inject to reduce said debt.

The problem with repaying the MSD loan early is that the penal interest will increase the losses and that's the only reason I can think of, as to why the MSD loan is not being repaid early, as we would have to charge the P&L with higher interest charges as a result (with subsequent knock on effect to PSR)

Patel has taken on the Baldie loan and said he will repay this by 30th June 2025. Reason being, this is the last date for the accounts for 24/25 and the loan would have had to have been be written off (charged to the p&l) in full for the year to 24/25 and subsequently increase our losses for 24/25 if Patel didn't take this loan on.

There will be an Early Repayment Charge - possibly as much as 5%, but if the debt is repaid on 1st July 2025, the total cost in the Y/E 30/6/26 accounts will be less than one year's full interest. 

I still suspect there is some "smoke & mirrors" here, and Patel always intended to sell assets to reduce the debt - but I have no proof and could be wrong on that one.

It could be a lot higher than a 5% ERC.  MSD’s loan terms usually do.

I've never seen an ERC above 5% - you may well have. Even if it was 10% the argument holds good. 

I fear this is being used as an excuse.
 
I have - many times including on MSD loans to football clubs.  It’s hardly “an excuse”.  Repaying (say) a £25m loan and stupidly suffering a (say) 10% ERC can add £2.5m to this year’s losses.  It would be insane to do that.
Reply
(01-02-2025, 12:35 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:45 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:30 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:55 AM)FFS Sake Wrote: To clarify / correct a few things mentioned on this thread.

Since Patel took over, it's no longer money in the bank we have a problem with, as he is pumping money in to the bank account and is allowed to.

Where the problem lies is our losses.

The accounts for the financial year to 30 June 2024  (23/24) will be made public on or before 31st March 2025. It's envisaged that these accounts will show our largest loss of around £22m.

It's been reported that we've reduced the salary bill by 30% this season
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/art...g3qwxxy6ro

Players' salaries for 23/24 totalled £46m.  So we've saved circa £14m in salaries in 24/25 and therefore, loses will be reduced by this amount. We also sold some players this season and their transfer fees will also help the PSR for 24/25.

From this season onwards, the 3 year total of allowable losses has increased from £39m to £41.5m, so we have a little more wiggle room.



Sell Maja for £10m..........

Some people have posted on this thread we wont be able to spend this money (if we sell him) and that we will have to use the loan market.  This isn't true.

If we sell Maja for £10m in Jan and buy another striker for £10m in Jan on the same wages and on a 4 year contract, the effect for PSR will be as follows

24/25 +£7.5m  (+£10m profit on Maja, -£2.5m amortisation of new player's £10m transfer fee)
25/26 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
26/27 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)
27/28 -£2.5m (amortisation of new player's transfer fee)


26/27 onwards doesn't really matter, as the large loss for 23/24 (envisaged £22m) will no longer be included in the 3 year rolling average figures for PSR

The above is why we were able to sign Mikey and why we gave him a 4 year contract, as we can spread the cost of his transfer fee over 4 years in the accounts.


Happy to help Big Grin

Happy New Year to you all.

The only thing you are forgetting is that we are tens of millions in debt, which is unsustainable. Whilst I agree with your maths on FFP, we do need to reduce the debt, the interest payments are crippling us. I suspect this will be a priority for Patel, who is limited in the amount of cash he can inject to reduce said debt.

What are you on about? Debt, as you know, is a balance sheet item. He could clear the lot tomorrow, if he wanted to. Where he’s limited by the rules is on the amount of equity he’s allowed to inject to offset losses.

That’s broadly correct.  He could put in equity to repay the MSD loan, although that would trigger a penal early repayment charge, which would only serve to increase the losses.  Regardless of how much equity is put in, the maximum amount that can be offset against at losses is I believe £5m per annum and/or £15m in any one 3-year period.

(01-02-2025, 11:57 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 11:50 AM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: People forget that these owners are not the ones from before Feb 24. ??‍♂️

We still have the same level of external debt, and whilst they have eased the cashflow concerns of the Lai era, they have yet to invest any significant funds into the club.

What about the £5m loan owed by Holdings which Patel has already settled?  Is that not significant?

(01-02-2025, 12:28 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 12:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:43 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:33 AM)FFS Sake Wrote: The problem with repaying the MSD loan early is that the penal interest will increase the losses and that's the only reason I can think of, as to why the MSD loan is not being repaid early, as we would have to charge the P&L with higher interest charges as a result (with subsequent knock on effect to PSR)

Patel has taken on the Baldie loan and said he will repay this by 30th June 2025. Reason being, this is the last date for the accounts for 24/25 and the loan would have had to have been be written off (charged to the p&l) in full for the year to 24/25 and subsequently increase our losses for 24/25 if Patel didn't take this loan on.

There will be an Early Repayment Charge - possibly as much as 5%, but if the debt is repaid on 1st July 2025, the total cost in the Y/E 30/6/26 accounts will be less than one year's full interest. 

I still suspect there is some "smoke & mirrors" here, and Patel always intended to sell assets to reduce the debt - but I have no proof and could be wrong on that one.

It could be a lot higher than a 5% ERC.  MSD’s loan terms usually do.

I've never seen an ERC above 5% - you may well have. Even if it was 10% the argument holds good. 

I fear this is being used as an excuse.
 
I have - many times including on MSD loans to football clubs.  It’s hardly “an excuse”.  Repaying (say) a £25m loan and stupidly suffering a (say) 10% ERC can add £2.5m to this year’s losses.  It would be insane to do that.

It wouldn't be a £2.5M loss if the loan was repaid at the correct time in the accounting period (i.e. day 1 of the accounting year). What is stupidity is paying the best part of £7.5M in interest over the remaining term of the loan, to avoid a £2.5M ERC charge - unless you don't want to put the £25M in.
Reply
(01-02-2025, 12:24 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 12:07 PM)ColliersWoodBaggie Wrote: So the 1m plus for the training ground was from the tooth fairy?

And as for debt, you suspect they won’t find ways of improving cash flow. I can’t understand this.,They are unlikely to be static .

Small beer. They won't even pay to clean the Brummie. Read the latest Albion Assembly minutes.

Both Villa & Blues had all their debt repaid as part of the structure of the takeover. Villa are in Champions League, Blues are signing £12M players, rebult their broken ground and committing to a massive infrastructure project. And we can't afford to clean and paint our stands.

Go and support Villa. You sound like one of them.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)