Aussie Diakite
#71
Bringing it back to Aussie. Some things that probably should be taken into account

Although 24 he only has one full season of first team football behind him (last year). So is relatively inexperienced.

He has mainly played in Austria. Admittedly the top division but I can make an educated presumption that the pace and style of play is very different to the chump.

TVS Hartberg, where he spent the last two seasons and played the bulk of his games, is a multi-purpose sports stadium and has a capacity of 4,635. Slightly different to running out at the Shrine with a full house (and Hillsborough in all fairness) so no suprise if the nerves were jangling and adrenalin rushing about.

Finally, and this is stating the obvious, he wasn't rough around the edges with some flaws he wouldn't be here on a free. In that way he reminds me (and others) of Mulumbu, who had all the stability and composure of a new born dear on his debut and was loudly declared as utter shit by many around me.

Not saying people shouldn't call things out as they see them. That's football and it's emotional. But always good to step back and apply some context after the event.
Reply
#72
(01-02-2025, 11:16 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 11:12 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 10:47 AM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:32 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

The same fans then act all hurt and defensive when they are pulled up on them writing off a kid who has barely played.

oops

(09-28-2024, 12:27 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The two central midfielders have been abysmal, slow, lack of movement and pretty darn lazy frankly. Even when they have touched the ball they have lost possession.

Talk of more sophisticated scouting this season may be wide of the mark… yes I appreciate it’s early days before people get all defensive.


(09-28-2024, 12:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: If I hear anyone even suggest replacing either Mowatt or Molumby with either of these two again I'll be amazed.

Genuinely up there as one of the worst performances by a midfield pairing I've ever seen.

It's time for some posters to get off their high horses

It was. And as said, certainly neither were able to push above Mowatt or Molumby on that showing.

Didn't say they were shit, or hopeless and that they'll never be good enough here, just no one will be asking for them after that awful performance. 

Criticising a performance is fine, it's when people say a player will always be shit after one game is when I just don't listen.

I didn't call them shit either. In fact I don't think anyone said they will 'always be shit'.

Ten minutes into their first game you were ripping both the midfielders constantly. It's post after post about how 'awful' and 'abysmal' they are. Don't try and pretend that this is any different to what others are posting 3 months later saying it's too early.

The hypocrisy, especially from DH, is just hilarious. How about posters just letting people have an opinion on something in the future rather than acting all high and mighty when they've done the exact same think that they are turning their nose up about.

People did, saying rubbish signing etc, that's what I'm commenting about, quite happy to call out awful performances, I do.

All I'm saying, and was saying is that yes a 24 year old who is new to the country and league, he's barely played, mistakes are inevitable and we can hope he'll improve with game time.

It seems it is helping now he's playing, good.
Reply
#73
(01-02-2025, 11:51 AM)B68Baggy Wrote: Bringing it back to Aussie.  Some things that probably should be taken into account

Although 24 he only has one full season of first team football behind him (last year).  So is relatively inexperienced.

He has mainly played in Austria.  Admittedly the top division but I can make an educated presumption that the pace and style of play is very different to the chump.

TVS Hartberg, where he spent the last two seasons and played the bulk of his games, is a multi-purpose sports stadium and has a capacity of 4,635.  Slightly different to running out at the Shrine with a full house (and Hillsborough in all fairness) so no suprise if the nerves were jangling and adrenalin rushing about.

Finally, and this is stating the obvious, he wasn't rough around the edges with some flaws he wouldn't be here on a free.  In that way he reminds me (and others) of Mulumbu, who had all the stability and composure of a new born dear on his debut and was loudly declared as utter shit by many around me.

Not saying people shouldn't call things out as they see them.  That's football and it's emotional.  But always good to step back and apply some context after the event.

Well said.

Perfectly right to call out a mistake made and say that a player's current form is concerning, but to write someone off after 2 or 3 games is crazy.

He has all the attributes we've been missing since Fletcher left so I really hope he continues this upward trajectory!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)