Maja
#71
Would be reluctant to sell Maja, player of the season for us, still underrated by some on here. And I don't think this is a flash in the pan season...last season masks his career trajectory, he is a player who is improving..

On principle I wouldn't want Barry. May well have been our screw up, but his advisers took full advantage, and we have been royally screwd by the Villa, Barry returning on loan would be a reminder of that.

On the Dibbin/Irebognum move, Everton covered their tracks well, Irebognum started in their first 11, and then he was injured. Could be Dyche rated wanted him.
Reply
#72
Who are we going to replace him with? Until we can answer that it would be folly to sell him with everything still to play for.
Reply
#73
(01-02-2025, 08:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Who are we going to replace him with? Until we can answer that it would be folly to sell him with everything still to play for.

We would replace him with £10 million in the bank. You selective memory has totally forgotten our financial situation.
Reply
#74
(01-02-2025, 08:46 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 08:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Who are we going to replace him with? Until we can answer that it would be folly to sell him with everything still to play for.

We would replace him with £10 million in the bank. You selective memory has totally forgotten our financial situation.

Forgive me from not taking football finance lessons from those who would have sold every decent player we had before the takeover in some ludicrous fire sale that would have solved nothing and left the playing squad in a relegation battle. 

Whilst we have a chance of promotion selling key players should be met with caution unless we can replace them. If we did go up the financial stability would be made far easier than trying to wheel and deal for the next two, three, four, five years in the Championship.
Reply
#75
And there is the question: Do we think Josh Maja is likely to be the difference between us getting promoted or not, this season?
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#76
(01-02-2025, 09:10 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: And there is the question:  Do we think Josh Maja is likely to be the difference between us getting promoted or not, this season?

Well losing him and replacing with a young loan player or player from overseas with potential (we don’t exactly have patient fans, see Diakite for proof) seems a pointless risk when we can sell in the Summer. Whilst we have a chance then we should try and keep the squad together. We can reassess in the summer with a new head coach and far better environment to buy and sell players.
Reply
#77
(01-02-2025, 08:55 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 08:46 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 08:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Who are we going to replace him with? Until we can answer that it would be folly to sell him with everything still to play for.

We would replace him with £10 million in the bank. You selective memory has totally forgotten our financial situation.

Forgive me from not taking football finance lessons from those who would have sold every decent player we had before the takeover in some ludicrous fire sale that would have solved nothing and left the playing squad in a relegation battle. 

Whilst we have a chance of promotion selling key players should be met with caution unless we can replace them. If we did go up the financial stability would be made far easier than trying to wheel and deal for the next two, three, four, five years in the Championship.

Actually I suspect we’d spend £2m on a proven loan for half a season and bank £8m.  That’s the way it’s likely to be for the next 2 years while we get our finances straight.  That’s the alternative to the fire sale which would have HAD to happen if Lai had not sold when he did. 

Remarkably there are still several in denial about our finances.  Getting promoted is far less important than the financial survival of the club and the avoidance of points penalties. Yes it almost certainly means staying in the Championship for one of two seasons. 

What are our chances of going up this season ?  Well it looks like at least 3, possibly 4, clubs will get north of 90-95 points and two of those will end up in the playoffs. We certainly won’t be going up automatically. 

We’ll be fighting it out with about 5-6 clubs for the last 2 playoff places. Probably odds of around 2/1 or 3/1 to make the playoffs.  We’ve then got to win a two legged playoff against one of those 90-95 point teams finishing 3rd/4th, and then win a final.  Odds of around 20-25/1 I’d suggest. 

With those odds it would be foolish not to take the bird in the hand of cash for one or even two players (Maja and Fellows, could even be Heggem) to deal with the debt between now and the summer and the new owner can then start injecting funds to drive us forward with no risk of points deductions.  Just my opinion that the sooner we can reach that stage, the better, rather than gradually doing it over 2-3 seasons. 

For what it’s worth if we were one of the 4 clubs looking like getting 90-95 points I’d be stalling on any sales until after the playoffs because the odds would be significantly better.
Reply
#78
(01-02-2025, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:10 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: And there is the question:  Do we think Josh Maja is likely to be the difference between us getting promoted or not, this season?

Well losing him and replacing with a young loan player or player from overseas with potential (we don’t exactly have patient fans, see Diakite for proof) seems a pointless risk when we can sell in the Summer. Whilst we have a chance then we should try and keep the squad together. We can reassess in the summer with a new head coach and far better environment to buy and sell players.
I agree with you here Derek. We need to keep the core of the 1st 11 together as much as we can and improve it if possible. Just by getting rid of Dobbin and McNair we have opened up two opportunities to bring in better options and that alone could be the difference, the margins of 5th-10th are so small.
If we can also offload some fringe players, that will be an added bonus and maybe allow us to further enhance our first 11 options.
Reply
#79
(01-02-2025, 09:27 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:20 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 09:10 AM)CarlosCorbewrong Wrote: And there is the question:  Do we think Josh Maja is likely to be the difference between us getting promoted or not, this season?

Well losing him and replacing with a young loan player or player from overseas with potential (we don’t exactly have patient fans, see Diakite for proof) seems a pointless risk when we can sell in the Summer. Whilst we have a chance then we should try and keep the squad together. We can reassess in the summer with a new head coach and far better environment to buy and sell players.
I agree with you here Derek. We need to keep the core of the 1st 11 together as much as we can and improve it if possible. Just by getting rid of Dobbin and McNair we have opened up two opportunities to bring in better options and that alone could be the difference, the margins of 5th-10th are so small.
If we can also offload some fringe players, that will be an added bonus and maybe allow us to further enhance our first 11 options.

How does that help our finances?
Reply
#80
(01-02-2025, 09:25 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 08:55 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 08:46 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-02-2025, 08:37 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Who are we going to replace him with? Until we can answer that it would be folly to sell him with everything still to play for.

We would replace him with £10 million in the bank. You selective memory has totally forgotten our financial situation.

Forgive me from not taking football finance lessons from those who would have sold every decent player we had before the takeover in some ludicrous fire sale that would have solved nothing and left the playing squad in a relegation battle. 

Whilst we have a chance of promotion selling key players should be met with caution unless we can replace them. If we did go up the financial stability would be made far easier than trying to wheel and deal for the next two, three, four, five years in the Championship.

Actually I suspect we’d spend £2m on a proven loan for half a season and bank £8m.  That’s the way it’s likely to be for the next 2 years while we get our finances straight.  That’s the alternative to the fire sale which would have HAD to happen if Lai had not sold when he did. 

Remarkably there are still several in denial about our finances.  Getting promoted is far less important than the financial survival of the club and the avoidance of points penalties. Yes it almost certainly means staying in the Championship for one of two seasons. 

What are our chances of going up this season ?  Well it looks like at least 3, possibly 4, clubs will get north of 90-95 points and two of those will end up in the playoffs. We certainly won’t be going up automatically. 

We’ll be fighting it out with about 5-6 clubs for the last 2 playoff places. Probably odds of around 2/1 or 3/1 to make the playoffs.  We’ve then got to win a two legged playoff against one of those 90-95 point teams finishing 3rd/4th, and then win a final.  Odds of around 20-25/1 I’d suggest. 

With those odds it would be foolish not to take the bird in the hand of cash for one or even two players (Maja and Fellows, could even be Heggem) to deal with the debt between now and the summer and the new owner can then start injecting funds to drive us forward with no risk of points deductions.  Just my opinion that the sooner we can reach that stage, the better, rather than gradually doing it over 2-3 seasons. 

For what it’s worth if we were one of the 4 clubs looking like getting 90-95 points I’d be stalling on any sales until after the playoffs because the odds would be significantly better.

Completely get that, Prag, and it would probably sort us out in one fell swoop (or at least for this season) but I think it would kill our chances completely unless we are extremely fortunate and find someone on loan who can score and link up with other players, especially as it's essential for our other attacking players in Fellows, Johnston and Grant. Ideally we'd look to offload a couple of the higher earners who might command some kind of fee but even if you got rid of Wallace, Diangana and Swift you'd still be short, I suppose. And three are harder to get rid of /replace than one.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: