Aussie Diakite
#51
(12-29-2024, 02:52 PM)WBA Baracus Wrote: His backheel was superb, Tony Rees would have been proud.

My eyes didn't deceive me! Big Grin
Reply
#52
(12-29-2024, 05:55 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

It's possible to say "a player hasn't looked very good" when he hasn't looked very good without it turning into not wanting him to do well. I hope Diakite comes good, but one of the reasons he gets credit for the second half performance is because it wasn't anywhere near as horrendous as the first half one, not because it was a stand out performance from a central midfielder.

Same thing happened last year with Kipre. Kipre had an absolute shocker in his first game and then once he started playing well everyone was on board. It's ok to change your opinion on players without having to pretend they've looked like world beaters when they haven't. Diakite looks out of his depth to me, and his ball control I think will be a major problem. Not just based on the game today but on the other times he has player.

I'm happy to be wrong as I was about Kipre.

This absolutely 100%.

I said after Derby Diakite deserved a shot as Racic hadn't done much for us but kept picking up game time. 

His first half today was poor and that's being kind. It wasn't the mistake. That can happen to anybody. He looked like a rabbit in the headlights and the game passed him by. I don't have a problem with anybody calling his first half display shite because it was. Match threads are there for people to comment on what they have watched up to the minute they decide to post. So anyone saying he was crap was spot on.

He pulled his socks up second half and looked ok. Fair play to him for that but Zidane he fucking wasn't! He played much better second half than the first. Not difficult.

People calling out a players shite first half performance were totally justified based on the 45 minutes they had watched. I'm not quite sure why people think otherwise. If people can't do that what is the point of a match thread? You're watching a game and posting minute by minute. Say what you are seeing at that minute.

I get equally annoyed with people who don't comment and then gleefully come on at full time calling out anyone who dared make an observation. The ol' righteous captain hindsights.
Reply
#53
(12-29-2024, 09:11 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:55 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

It's possible to say "a player hasn't looked very good" when he hasn't looked very good without it turning into not wanting him to do well. I hope Diakite comes good, but one of the reasons he gets credit for the second half performance is because it wasn't anywhere near as horrendous as the first half one, not because it was a stand out performance from a central midfielder.

Same thing happened last year with Kipre. Kipre had an absolute shocker in his first game and then once he started playing well everyone was on board. It's ok to change your opinion on players without having to pretend they've looked like world beaters when they haven't. Diakite looks out of his depth to me, and his ball control I think will be a major problem. Not just based on the game today but on the other times he has player.

I'm happy to be wrong as I was about Kipre.

This absolutely 100%.

I said after Derby Diakite deserved a shot as Racic hadn't done much for us but kept picking up game time. 

His first half today was poor and that's being kind. It wasn't the mistake. That can happen to anybody. He looked like a rabbit in the headlights and the game passed him by. I don't have a problem with anybody calling his first half display shite because it was. Match threads are there for people to comment on what they have watched up to the minute they decide to post. So anyone saying he was crap was spot on.

He pulled his socks up second half and looked ok. Fair play to him for that but Zidane he fucking wasn't! He played much better second half than the first. Not difficult.

People calling out a players shite first half performance were totally justified based on the 45 minutes they had watched. I'm not quite sure why people think otherwise. If people can't do that what is the point of a match thread? You're watching a game and posting minute by minute. Say what you are seeing at that minute.

I get equally annoyed with people who don't comment and then gleefully come on at full time calling out anyone who dared make an observation. The ol' righteous captain hindsights.

Thanks Peachy, I completely agree. When did it get to the point where you're not allowed to say a player hasn't played well without being looked down upon?
Reply
#54
(12-29-2024, 09:11 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:55 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

It's possible to say "a player hasn't looked very good" when he hasn't looked very good without it turning into not wanting him to do well. I hope Diakite comes good, but one of the reasons he gets credit for the second half performance is because it wasn't anywhere near as horrendous as the first half one, not because it was a stand out performance from a central midfielder.

Same thing happened last year with Kipre. Kipre had an absolute shocker in his first game and then once he started playing well everyone was on board. It's ok to change your opinion on players without having to pretend they've looked like world beaters when they haven't. Diakite looks out of his depth to me, and his ball control I think will be a major problem. Not just based on the game today but on the other times he has player.

I'm happy to be wrong as I was about Kipre.

This absolutely 100%.

I said after Derby Diakite deserved a shot as Racic hadn't done much for us but kept picking up game time. 

His first half today was poor and that's being kind. It wasn't the mistake. That can happen to anybody. He looked like a rabbit in the headlights and the game passed him by. I don't have a problem with anybody calling his first half display shite because it was. Match threads are there for people to comment on what they have watched up to the minute they decide to post. So anyone saying he was crap was spot on.

He pulled his socks up second half and looked ok. Fair play to him for that but Zidane he fucking wasn't! He played much better second half than the first. Not difficult.

People calling out a players shite first half performance were totally justified based on the 45 minutes they had watched. I'm not quite sure why people think otherwise. If people can't do that what is the point of a match thread? You're watching a game and posting minute by minute. Say what you are seeing at that minute.

I get equally annoyed with people who don't comment and then gleefully come on at full time calling out anyone who dared make an observation. The ol' righteous captain hindsights.
Say what you see. If you see it, say it!
Reply
#55
Agree word for word Peachy
Reply
#56
(12-29-2024, 09:11 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:55 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

It's possible to say "a player hasn't looked very good" when he hasn't looked very good without it turning into not wanting him to do well. I hope Diakite comes good, but one of the reasons he gets credit for the second half performance is because it wasn't anywhere near as horrendous as the first half one, not because it was a stand out performance from a central midfielder.

Same thing happened last year with Kipre. Kipre had an absolute shocker in his first game and then once he started playing well everyone was on board. It's ok to change your opinion on players without having to pretend they've looked like world beaters when they haven't. Diakite looks out of his depth to me, and his ball control I think will be a major problem. Not just based on the game today but on the other times he has player.

I'm happy to be wrong as I was about Kipre.

This absolutely 100%.

I said after Derby Diakite deserved a shot as Racic hadn't done much for us but kept picking up game time. 

His first half today was poor and that's being kind. It wasn't the mistake. That can happen to anybody. He looked like a rabbit in the headlights and the game passed him by. I don't have a problem with anybody calling his first half display shite because it was. Match threads are there for people to comment on what they have watched up to the minute they decide to post. So anyone saying he was crap was spot on.

He pulled his socks up second half and looked ok. Fair play to him for that but Zidane he fucking wasn't! He played much better second half than the first. Not difficult.

People calling out a players shite first half performance were totally justified based on the 45 minutes they had watched. I'm not quite sure why people think otherwise. If people can't do that what is the point of a match thread? You're watching a game and posting minute by minute. Say what you are seeing at that minute.

I get equally annoyed with people who don't comment and then gleefully come on at full time calling out anyone who dared make an observation. The ol' righteous captain hindsights.

If posters want to get all defensive because they don’t like criticism of themselves from other posters because they felt the criticism of a player who’s barely played for us was fair then that’s up to them. Major Hypocrites
Reply
#57
(12-29-2024, 09:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 09:11 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:55 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

It's possible to say "a player hasn't looked very good" when he hasn't looked very good without it turning into not wanting him to do well. I hope Diakite comes good, but one of the reasons he gets credit for the second half performance is because it wasn't anywhere near as horrendous as the first half one, not because it was a stand out performance from a central midfielder.

Same thing happened last year with Kipre. Kipre had an absolute shocker in his first game and then once he started playing well everyone was on board. It's ok to change your opinion on players without having to pretend they've looked like world beaters when they haven't. Diakite looks out of his depth to me, and his ball control I think will be a major problem. Not just based on the game today but on the other times he has player.

I'm happy to be wrong as I was about Kipre.

This absolutely 100%.

I said after Derby Diakite deserved a shot as Racic hadn't done much for us but kept picking up game time. 

His first half today was poor and that's being kind. It wasn't the mistake. That can happen to anybody. He looked like a rabbit in the headlights and the game passed him by. I don't have a problem with anybody calling his first half display shite because it was. Match threads are there for people to comment on what they have watched up to the minute they decide to post. So anyone saying he was crap was spot on.

He pulled his socks up second half and looked ok. Fair play to him for that but Zidane he fucking wasn't! He played much better second half than the first. Not difficult.

People calling out a players shite first half performance were totally justified based on the 45 minutes they had watched. I'm not quite sure why people think otherwise. If people can't do that what is the point of a match thread? You're watching a game and posting minute by minute. Say what you are seeing at that minute.

I get equally annoyed with people who don't comment and then gleefully come on at full time calling out anyone who dared make an observation. The ol' righteous captain hindsights.

If posters want to get all defensive because they don’t like criticism of themselves from other posters because they felt the criticism of a player who’s barely played for us was fair then that’s up to them. Major Hypocrites

What are you on about? Is there a certain number of minutes a player is required to play before we can comment on how they've performed on the pitch?

If so, what is that number? And what's wrong with saying "I don't think this guy has looked very good so far"?
Reply
#58
(12-29-2024, 09:50 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 09:45 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 09:11 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:55 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

It's possible to say "a player hasn't looked very good" when he hasn't looked very good without it turning into not wanting him to do well. I hope Diakite comes good, but one of the reasons he gets credit for the second half performance is because it wasn't anywhere near as horrendous as the first half one, not because it was a stand out performance from a central midfielder.

Same thing happened last year with Kipre. Kipre had an absolute shocker in his first game and then once he started playing well everyone was on board. It's ok to change your opinion on players without having to pretend they've looked like world beaters when they haven't. Diakite looks out of his depth to me, and his ball control I think will be a major problem. Not just based on the game today but on the other times he has player.

I'm happy to be wrong as I was about Kipre.

This absolutely 100%.

I said after Derby Diakite deserved a shot as Racic hadn't done much for us but kept picking up game time. 

His first half today was poor and that's being kind. It wasn't the mistake. That can happen to anybody. He looked like a rabbit in the headlights and the game passed him by. I don't have a problem with anybody calling his first half display shite because it was. Match threads are there for people to comment on what they have watched up to the minute they decide to post. So anyone saying he was crap was spot on.

He pulled his socks up second half and looked ok. Fair play to him for that but Zidane he fucking wasn't! He played much better second half than the first. Not difficult.

People calling out a players shite first half performance were totally justified based on the 45 minutes they had watched. I'm not quite sure why people think otherwise. If people can't do that what is the point of a match thread? You're watching a game and posting minute by minute. Say what you are seeing at that minute.

I get equally annoyed with people who don't comment and then gleefully come on at full time calling out anyone who dared make an observation. The ol' righteous captain hindsights.

If posters want to get all defensive because they don’t like criticism of themselves from other posters because they felt the criticism of a player who’s barely played for us was fair then that’s up to them. Major Hypocrites

What are you on about? Is there a certain number of minutes a player is required to play before we can comment on how they've performed on the pitch?

If so, what is that number? And what's wrong with saying "I don't think this guy has looked very good so far"?

Read the criticism on the thread ii think it was over the top… feel free to disagree. No one is stopping anyone posting anything, some posters seem particularly thin skinned tonight because others felt their criticism was unfair. Hey-ho.
Reply
#59
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

This.
Hardly had a kick this season,  thrown  in against one of the better teams, had a poor 20 minutes and then showed big balls by not hiding and playing his part in a good team performance. 

The criticism is well over the top. He's got rough edges for sure but there's a player there. I enjoyed watching him.
Reply
#60
(12-29-2024, 10:07 PM)richbaggie Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 05:28 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: He's barely played, in a new country and league. He's 24, why are fans so eager to judge players as shit?

This.
Hardly had a kick this season,  thrown  in against one of the better teams, had a poor 20 minutes and then showed big balls by not hiding and playing his part in a good team performance. 

The criticism is well over the top. He's got rough edges for sure but there's a player there. I enjoyed watching him.
Well said Rich. We should be praising his character.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: