Council By Elections
#91
I’ve got some extra absorbent tissues on standby for the 0.1% of the adult population crucified by finding an extra 20% on the optional outlay they choose to make
Reply
#92
(12-29-2024, 10:00 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’ve got some extra absorbent tissues on standby for the 0.1% of the adult population crucified by finding an extra 20% on the optional outlay they choose to make

How hateful. Some people have had to cash in share options because of this vile pinko act. And I know of at least one person who has deferred this years sailing trip to the BVIs this summer. Bloody Trots!

The polling supports Phillipson on this (backed by 60%)

See Sunday Times today
Reply
#93
(12-29-2024, 10:00 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’ve got some extra absorbent tissues on standby for the 0.1% of the adult population crucified by finding an extra 20% on the optional outlay they choose to make

Alternatively

https://conservativepost.co.uk/unintende...ank-warns/


History will tell us who was correct.
Reply
#94
(12-30-2024, 11:20 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 10:00 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’ve got some extra absorbent tissues on standby for the 0.1% of the adult population crucified by finding an extra 20% on the optional outlay they choose to make

Alternatively

https://conservativepost.co.uk/unintende...ank-warns/


History will tell us who was correct.

Good to see you linking to a neutral source KKC!
Reply
#95
(12-30-2024, 01:09 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-30-2024, 11:20 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-29-2024, 10:00 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: I’ve got some extra absorbent tissues on standby for the 0.1% of the adult population crucified by finding an extra 20% on the optional outlay they choose to make

Alternatively

https://conservativepost.co.uk/unintende...ank-warns/


History will tell us who was correct.

Good to see you linking to a neutral source KKC!

There are plenty of others  Smile Anyone with half a brain has said this policy could cost the Government revenue.

To me, it's common sense. It costs the state £7.5K per child per year for education, I think I read. So those putting their children through private education are actually saving the state money. This is just a spiteful tax of envy (which most Labour taxes are) and will end up costing the country. This isn't the thinking of an Economist, it's simply Rachel from Accounts gouging the people that Labour don't like.
Reply
#96
It outright isn't common sense on the basis that demand for independent schools in the UK has consistently shown to be inelastic, i.e. price rises haven't effected demand for independent schools over the last 40 years.

Also, the principle (most likely) scenario of the ASI study that shite article refers to was that it was going to be cost neutral.
Reply
#97
(12-30-2024, 02:00 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: It outright isn't common sense on the basis that demand for independent schools in the UK has consistently shown to be inelastic, i.e. price rises haven't effected demand for independent schools over the last 40 years.

Also, the principle (most likely) scenario of the ASI study that shite article refers to was that it was going to be cost neutral.

As I have said history, not ideology, will prove the point. You may well be correct, but I'll have a fiver that you're not.

Meanwhile Rachel is facing record borrowing costs and an increased tax gouge in March, whilst party popularity plummets. 10 year gilts today at 4.63%, from 3.8% in July, and don't forget that extra borrowing burden that is effectively lumped on the taxpayers. Obviously all part of the "fully costed" plan.

It's all going very well.
Reply
#98
And history indicates that demand for independent schools is inelastic. Therefore common sense dictates that this isn't going to lead to 25% of independent school pupils moving over to the state sector for the numbers in that article (the scenario from the ASI study) to make sense.
Reply
#99
(12-30-2024, 02:47 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: And history indicates that demand for independent schools is inelastic. Therefore common sense dictates that this isn't going to lead to 25% of independent school pupils moving over to the state sector for the numbers in that article (the scenario from the ASI study) to make sense.

Let's revisit this in 18 months time, shall we? 

And to impose the tax from the 1st January 2025 is nothing but spiteful. How about the kids who are halfway through an academic year, who are now forced to leave? How are the state schools supposed to accommodate them when they are full?

It is just absolute spite from the Labour Party. FWIW I don't think too many would argue that Private School fees should be charged, but the impact on the economy and families has not been thought through (familiar story).

Going back to your previous point that the tax may be "neutral" on the economy, I would counter why do it? Answer : spite and envy. Labour are done for a generation, as they were in 2010. A new generation are seeing them as a party of tax and jealousy.
Reply
I've made my position clear in the past that I don't think the genuine provision of education should be taxed and would prefer measures to increase the number of scholars/bursary recipients in independent schools and improve access to independent school facilities for state school kids as a carrot for retaining charitable status. Ultimately though polling indicates that most people, especially people under the age of 30 and including those under 30 who went to an independent school, are in favour of it. And that is primarily going to be caused by demand being inelastic to the point that fees rising so much more than inflation has not reduced demand for places over the last 40 years, it's not two middle class parents in professional jobs sending kids to independent schools anymore unless they're getting a scholarship or bursary - that includes the modest independent schools. Even very privileged middle class families will need to over leverage themselves to afford fees.

The reason Labour are doing it is quite obviously because their indicative assessments suggest it being a net positive to the Treasury, the IFS suggested the same and even the ASI study put out a scenario suggesting the same if the number of independent school kids moving over to the state sector was held at up to 7%. That bump would be applied to a very small subset of the population.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)