21st Century Albion Managers Ranked
#11
(12-28-2024, 03:01 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Megson
Roy
Mowbray
Corberan
Bilic
Clarke
Di Matteo
Pulis
Moore
Big Sam
Mel
Ismael
Little
Pardew
Bruce

I'd query Bilic v Clarke, but otherwise this is a solid list.
Reply
#12
Clarke, 8th in the premier league, playing football that lead several commentators to say we were the best coached and organised team in the league and many neutrals favourite team to watch.

Bilic, scraped a promotion before making us humiliated in the premier league with the most disorganised and unfit team to play there, thankfully had a Pereira to at least make us entertaining while doing so.
Reply
#13
My list...

17th GBFS

Don't care about anyone else.
Reply
#14
(12-28-2024, 02:57 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote: 1. Megson 
2. Clarke
3. Mowbray
4. Hodgson
5. Corberan
6. Di Matteo
7. Bilic
8. Pulis
9. Robson
10. Moore
11. Ismael
12. Mel
13. Irvine
14. Bruce
15. Allardyce 
16. Little
17. Pardew

RDM above Mowbray for me, his promotion season very underrated, highest points total, scored more goals, conceded fewer goals and all this with Morrison injured for most of the season and a forward line of Bednar and Luke Moore. Then in the Premier League a great start that included the win at Arsenal, wheels only came off after the Boy Ref shafted us at Blackpool.
Reply
#15
1. Megson
2. Corberán
3. Mowbray
4. Hodgson
5. Pulis
6. Clarke (as generous as possible)
7. RDM
8. Moore
9. Allardyce
10. Slav
11. Robson
12. Ismael
13. Mel
14. Little
15. Irvine
16. Bruce
17. Pardew
Reply
#16
(12-28-2024, 06:37 PM)Jacko Wrote: 1. Megson
2. Corberán
3. Mowbray
4. Hodgson
5. Pulis
6. Clarke (as generous as possible)
7. RDM
8. Moore
9. Allardyce
10. Slav
11. Robson
12. Ismael
13. Mel
14. Little
15. Irvine
16. Bruce
17. Pardew

Allardyce above Bilic?
Reply
#17
(12-28-2024, 04:26 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:04 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: How is Clarke above Hodgson?

Highest ever PL position

Built on Hodgson’s legacy

The Giles/Atkinson debate then?

We feared nobody under Clarke - much more attractive to watch as well.

He’s a better international coach than RH as well.

I take it you weren't at Newcastle then when he stood there like a lemon - doing nothing and not knowing what to do as we got tore a new one.
Reply
#18
This really needs two lists. One for achievements, and one for their actual coaching/managerial abilities.

Megson is a super example of this. In terms of achievement and what he did for the club, he's by far and away the best manager we've had in my lifetime. But purely based on his managerial abilities, I doubt he's top 5!

Hodgson, Big Sam, Corberan are certainly better coaches/managers, and like it or not, I believe you could put Bruce above Megson if you're basing it on historical management (not necessarily during their time here).

Pulis is by far away at the bottom of the list. With Pardew a distant second worse.
Reply
#19
Not sure you’d say Pulis is a bad coach. A coach needs to translate ideas from the training ground to the pitch and he certainly is able to do that. However bad they are on the eye.
Reply
#20
(12-28-2024, 06:55 PM)Brentbaggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:26 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:07 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:04 PM)Bristol Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 04:00 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: How is Clarke above Hodgson?

Highest ever PL position

Built on Hodgson’s legacy

The Giles/Atkinson debate then?

We feared nobody under Clarke - much more attractive to watch as well.

He’s a better international coach than RH as well.

I take it you weren't at Newcastle then when he stood there like a lemon - doing nothing and not knowing what to do as we got tore a new one.

Similar to the Liberty under RH then
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: