Our hero managers
#41
Tom Silk if you are talking about other roles and impact on club
Reply
#42
(12-28-2024, 10:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 10:11 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 09:34 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 06:58 AM)Everything Zin Wrote: And it’s laughable to read criticism of Atkinson’s departure while conveniently forgetting Megson effectively forcing Albion to sack him. Megson did great things for this club but his achievements were soured by his part in the resignation of potentially a great Chairman and his last few weeks with us.

Putting that racist immoral self indulgent fat knacker in the same breath as Megson is treason

Give it a rest, eh? Ron was a huge figure in our history. Megson had his dark side too. Remember him playing Junichi Inamoto in his last game just to fuck the club over with his contract? Telling Lee Marshall he was playing on Boxing Day then telling him to fuck off home when he turned up for the match? I wouldn't want to go anywhere near either of these flawed human beings, but they both did great things for our club.

Atkinson rode on others coat tails and was handed a side on a plate.

Megson took over as we were headed for league one and was handed 3 players at a cost of 150k to keep us up. Two seasons later he had us in the prem.

Let’s not re write history or the scale of the job one did over the other. Chalk and cheese.

No, just absolutely no. I'm guessing you weren't around at the time? We're all allowed opinions but that doesn't give you licence to change the facts to suit your opinion. Super-fans like you dismissing the work of Ron Atkinson leave me dumb-founded. Next we'll have someone saying "That Jeff Astle scored a few goals but he was no Diomansy Kamara". As they say on this bored, give your head a wobble, my man.
Reply
#43
Megson is the manager who changed our fortunes more than any other, and always gave the impression he was fully committed to the cause. What he achieved was remarkable, I think CC could have got close if he stayed but now we’ll never know.
Atkinson was clearly a good manager, you just need to look at his career to see that, but we were never more than a stepping stone for something bigger and better. Sames true of Mowbray, Ardiles Hodgson and Di Matteo. Think Bilic loved it here and would have been happy to stay, but he lost the confidence of the board post COVID, unfairly IMO.
For me Megson is the only manager that gets close to hero status.
Reply
#44
(12-28-2024, 10:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 09:24 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 08:45 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: As the alleged perpetrator of this thread... yes, "hero" is a bit OTT. As Dylan said after meeting Woody Guthrie, his first and last hero, they all have feet of clay.
Except for the Great Johnny Kaye of course.

This wasn't a pop at you at all JK. More of a thought about how few managers have hero status. It is interesting to see what others have said. 

I'm still a teenager.....as I have still have plenty of hero players....The whole 78/9 team, Bob Taylor, Balis.....

None taken!
It's my belief that we've never had a Great manager.
Some have promised much, a few have delivered something (no mention for Ashman?), but noone has made a real mark on our history the way Stan Cullis, Graham Taylor, Revie have on clubs further down the pyramid than the obvious candidates.
Vic Buckingham could have been that man, but we didn't have the imagination to keep him.
Nearest we have are Fred and Alan Everiss, who were "Secretaries" iirc.
They, along with Billy Bassett, probably made our club something bigger than a minor suburban neighbour to the Giants down the road.

I think you should have a bit more of a look at Vic Buckingham as he almost got the Albion to be the first club to win FA cup and league in 1954. If you read from old news papers at the time Albion were dubbed ‘ Team of the Century’. Agree with you about letting him leave but in those days managers didn’t get paid much and were valued less than today. Shankley left Liverpool for the same reason.
Reply
#45
Not one mention of the work of JP in the huge advancement of our club you ungrateful and in denial feckers
Reply
#46
(12-28-2024, 11:48 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 10:36 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 10:11 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 09:34 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 06:58 AM)Everything Zin Wrote: And it’s laughable to read criticism of Atkinson’s departure while conveniently forgetting Megson effectively forcing Albion to sack him. Megson did great things for this club but his achievements were soured by his part in the resignation of potentially a great Chairman and his last few weeks with us.

Putting that racist immoral self indulgent fat knacker in the same breath as Megson is treason

Give it a rest, eh? Ron was a huge figure in our history. Megson had his dark side too. Remember him playing Junichi Inamoto in his last game just to fuck the club over with his contract? Telling Lee Marshall he was playing on Boxing Day then telling him to fuck off home when he turned up for the match? I wouldn't want to go anywhere near either of these flawed human beings, but they both did great things for our club.

Atkinson rode on others coat tails and was handed a side on a plate.

Megson took over as we were headed for league one and was handed 3 players at a cost of 150k to keep us up. Two seasons later he had us in the prem.

Let’s not re write history or the scale of the job one did over the other. Chalk and cheese.

No, just absolutely no. I'm guessing you weren't around at the time? We're all allowed opinions but that doesn't give you licence to change the facts to suit your opinion. Super-fans like you dismissing the work of Ron Atkinson leave me dumb-founded. Next we'll have someone saying "That Jeff Astle scored a few goals but he was no Diomansy Kamara". As they say on this bored, give your head a wobble, my man.

What an odd reply
Reply
#47
(12-28-2024, 01:29 PM)Baggiejacko Wrote: Not one mention of the work of JP in the huge advancement of our club you ungrateful and in denial feckers

Roland sold to Lai.

Lai sold to Patel.

Lai > Peace
Would rather talk to ChatGPT
Reply
#48
(12-27-2024, 06:10 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Megson was indeed a hero. Having not long had to sell Killer and Maresca to simply balance the books, we were nailed-on for relegation after that blow-dried secretary-humping Villa ponce nearly took us down. We were staring oblivion in the face at the tail-end of the Hale era and things really couldn’t look more grim. Yet 5 cheapo and loan signings later (including one Neil Clement and a Supes) and we somehow survived.

Yet even then, the bookies had us odds-on favourites for the drop under Megson. He brought some real heroes to the club and led us to a memorable play-off season, which TBF we simply weren’t good enough to triumph in. But the next season was one that none of us will EVER forget. Especially given who we usurped.

CC will always go down as one of the good guys, that can’t really be disputed. But to categorise him into the same echelon as SGM is laughable.

That’s a surprisingly brilliant post.
Reply
#49
Sir Gary Megson Nuff said.
Alan Ashman Won us our last major trophy
Roy   Made us a proper Premiership side.
Johnny Giles. Brought us out of the wilderness and got us beating the best.

Honourable mentions for;
Ray Harford
Big Dave
Carlos.

This fred gives me a chance to repeat the phone in story.
Caller. Bloody Hell Tom, why would Harford leave Albion to go to QPR?
Tom Ross. Family reasons.
Caller. What?
Tom Ross. His wife wants him working nearer to home at his age, she has put her foot down.
Caller. Bloody Hell Tom, I've lost two wives following the Albion. The money he's got he'll get another.
Reply
#50
(12-28-2024, 12:13 PM)Jerry Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 10:37 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 09:24 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-28-2024, 08:45 AM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: As the alleged perpetrator of this thread... yes, "hero" is a bit OTT. As Dylan said after meeting Woody Guthrie, his first and last hero, they all have feet of clay.
Except for the Great Johnny Kaye of course.

This wasn't a pop at you at all JK. More of a thought about how few managers have hero status. It is interesting to see what others have said. 

I'm still a teenager.....as I have still have plenty of hero players....The whole 78/9 team, Bob Taylor, Balis.....

None taken!
It's my belief that we've never had a Great manager.
Some have promised much, a few have delivered something (no mention for Ashman?), but noone has made a real mark on our history the way Stan Cullis, Graham Taylor, Revie have on clubs further down the pyramid than the obvious candidates.
Vic Buckingham could have been that man, but we didn't have the imagination to keep him.
Nearest we have are Fred and Alan Everiss, who were "Secretaries" iirc.
They, along with Billy Bassett, probably made our club something bigger than a minor suburban neighbour to the Giants down the road.

I think you should have a bit more of a look at Vic Buckingham as he almost got the Albion to be the first club to win FA cup and league in 1954. If you read from old news papers at the time Albion were dubbed ‘ Team of the Century’. Agree with you about letting him leave but in those days managers didn’t get paid much and were valued less than today. Shankley left Liverpool for the same reason.
Didn't Buckingham go on to have great success at Ajax?
And, while we're on the subject, Jimmy Hagan did likewise in ? Portugal.
2 managers to add to the should've kept list .
It's a long list!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: