Our hero managers
#11
(12-27-2024, 05:18 PM)Squid Wrote:
(12-27-2024, 04:03 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Atkinson would have been because I was 10. But, even then, he tainted everything with the way he departed.
CC nowhere near him in terms of style of play, achievement or acquisitions, so, decent manager, yes, hero, you really are having a laugh.

It's a massively subjective claim so not really worth mockery.

It can be judged though… GM took a very poor, relegation threatened squad that was far worse than we have had at anytime since, kept it up, got to the Play-Offs the next season and promotion the season after, oh and another promotion after this.

If a hero is judged by doing something extraordinary then none of subsequent managers have done anything as impressive or fundamental to our clubs future.
Reply
#12
Fatko was one of the greatest frauds in football. A quick watch of Strachans view of him on the Man U documentary on Netflix tells you all you need to know. Rode on Giles coat tails.

SGM and Woy for the 5-1 for me.
Reply
#13
Megson was indeed a hero. Having not long had to sell Killer and Maresca to simply balance the books, we were nailed-on for relegation after that blow-dried secretary-humping Villa ponce nearly took us down. We were staring oblivion in the face at the tail-end of the Hale era and things really couldn’t look more grim. Yet 5 cheapo and loan signings later (including one Neil Clement and a Supes) and we somehow survived.

Yet even then, the bookies had us odds-on favourites for the drop under Megson. He brought some real heroes to the club and led us to a memorable play-off season, which TBF we simply weren’t good enough to triumph in. But the next season was one that none of us will EVER forget. Especially given who we usurped.

CC will always go down as one of the good guys, that can’t really be disputed. But to categorise him into the same echelon as SGM is laughable.
Reply
#14
What Megson did is unparalleled since the 60s. He absolutely dragged this club up at the turn of the century and the last 20 odd years have all been because of his achievements in taking up a team that punched way above its mean.

His squad had no right to be promoted and yet through his sheer belligerence we did it.

Uncle Roy was a better manager, but Megson has had the biggest (positive) influence on our club, certainly since Giles (first time) as a minimum.
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
#15
The term 'hero' maybe a little OTT but I have two managerial candidates from different eras who came to the club at differing stages in their careers at critical turning points in our history that I have much more time for than many of our dugout warmers. Johnny Giles and Sir Gary Megson.
Reply
#16
Megson is the only one that was movie script material. Those seasons keep a lot of us warm to this day. Atkinson was the manager when I first started going up so will always have a place in my good book of managers despite what he did. CC definitely set the foundations for a megson type reverence but didn’t see it through so it’s a no from me.

Other notable mentions for Woy and Clement Keys for setting the finance bar early doors.
Reply
#17
As an adult it has been Megson. Took us back to the top division when we were the equivalent to how Preston are now, and laid the foundations for the next decade or more. It’s just a pity he didn’t keep us up and had a fractious relationship with Peace.
As a kid it has to be Giles 2 years. We’d lost our way and were similar to what we are now in terms of time since being big hitters.
He got us up at the first time of asking, and then built a side that narrowly missed out on European football. He built virtually all the foundations that Big Fat Ron supped his champagne from.
There was a video on the official site the other day where Wile, Robertson and Bomber could not speak highly enough of him.
Reply
#18
Sir Gary will always be the ultimate Hawthorns hero in my 60+ years for those first 3 and a bit seasons. Relegation avoided, heroic play off battle against a much more financially backed Bolton then the season that will never be bettered and finally some happy memories in the first Prem season with tuppence halfpenny spent.
I know the vast majority will disagree and shout at me but TP was a hero of mine too but in a different way. We'd been virtually a constant yo yo club but he turned us round to avoid relegation and gave us the nouse to stay up on buttons.
After SGM we were the yo yo club that was a bit too good for the champ but never able to entice the players required to stay up. After TP whether you agree or not we went to shit. Lots never saw the gaps n cracks his football methods covered. Here's hoping we get a new hero now.
Reply
#19
(12-27-2024, 03:30 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Ray Harford was potentially SGM 3 years earlier

And he left around Christmas time (just before I think)

(12-27-2024, 06:10 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Megson was indeed a hero. Having not long had to sell Killer and Maresca to simply balance the books, we were nailed-on for relegation after that blow-dried secretary-humping Villa ponce nearly took us down. We were staring oblivion in the face at the tail-end of the Hale era and things really couldn’t look more grim. Yet 5 cheapo and loan signings later (including one Neil Clement and a Supes) and we somehow survived.

Yet even then, the bookies had us odds-on favourites for the drop under Megson. He brought some real heroes to the club and led us to a memorable play-off season, which TBF we simply weren’t good enough to triumph in. But the next season was one that none of us will EVER forget. Especially given who we usurped.

CC will always go down as one of the good guys, that can’t really be disputed. But to categorise him into the same echelon as SGM is laughable.

This exactly. Very depressing times. I lived in London then, so my own Albion attendance was lower than now. I'd been going since 1979, and even the Saunders' times , although personally the worst football ever,were not as scary.  Little was sending us into oblivion, the Villa bastard. He'd done an awful job at Stoke, so why Hale thought he'd be good with us is anyone's guess (I think he sacked Smith and brought in Little a week before the season started - what a mess). 

What is etched in my memory was around this time, in November 1999. Radio 2 did a series about Clubs which had fallen on hard times, but were rich in history, support, tradition etc . They did Albion one week (others were Burnley, Preston, Huddersfield I think). Little was manager and we were struggling to win games after drawing a load. I think we'd just beat Pompey for our first home win. So, not long before Hale quit and Kilbane was sold. 

Terry Wills was the Albion fan who was the 'talking head' interviewed. He actually said he never thought he'd see us in the Top Flight ever again (this was 13 years since we left the old Div 1). Two and half years later Megson ensured Wills would see us in the top flight. Legendary hero.
Reply
#20
"Heroes" ffs!  Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: