Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
12-25-2024, 07:08 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-25-2024, 07:11 AM by richbaggie.)
Good post Birdy
Carlos has managed us brilliantly through the darkest period the club ever faced. He dragged us back from the brink of League 1 and potential oblivion. To then have the highest win percentage of any manager in our history for anyone coaching over 60 matches is quite incredible. Some fans seem determined to water his achievement down but looking at the reaction on social media, the vast majority recognise how good he has been for the club.
I'll forever be thankful and wish him nothing but good luck for the rest of his career and will watch his career closely.
Posts: 1,674
Threads: 93
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
8
(12-25-2024, 07:08 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Good post Birdy
Carlos has managed us brilliantly through the darkest period the club ever faced. He dragged us back from the brink of League 1 and potential oblivion. To then have the highest win percentage of any manager in our history for anyone coaching over 60 matches is quite incredible. Some fans seem determined to water his achievement down but looking at the reaction on social media, the vast majority recognise how good he has been for the club.
I'll forever be thankful and wish him nothing but good luck for the rest of his career and will watch his career closely.
+1.
Merry Christmas all!
Posts: 1,801
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
(12-25-2024, 07:08 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Good post Birdy
Carlos has managed us brilliantly through the darkest period the club ever faced. He dragged us back from the brink of League 1 and potential oblivion. To then have the highest win percentage of any manager in our history for anyone coaching over 60 matches is quite incredible. Some fans seem determined to water his achievement down but looking at the reaction on social media, the vast majority recognise how good he has been for the club.
I'll forever be thankful and wish him nothing but good luck for the rest of his career and will watch his career closely.
OP and this my sentiments exactly.
Merry Christmas!!
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
We only hope Brunty, Damia and Boaz were paying attention during tactics and training sessions.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
I'm ok with it. He was brilliant for us at a time when we most needed someone like him. Birdy, you sum his tenure up wonderfully.
I'm pleased for Carlos, he's got a great opportunity to turn around a home town club and let's be honest a real sleeping giant. I really hope he's afforded a bit of leeway to get results there and I genuinely want it to work out for him so fans across Europe can see what we've seen for the past two years.
I'm also excited, we've had late night comms from both Nestor and Shilen, I've got every faith that they'll be looking for someone to fit their model of how they can work. We can be hopeful that whoever is next through the door will benefit from the great work Carlos has done for the previous two years.
Posts: 1,764
Threads: 45
Joined: Feb 2022
Reputation:
3
Good post
I think this is the new owners big test will they go money ball approach
Unheard up and coming possibly or tried & tested
Personally money ball may work with players not sure with a gaffer
Need somebody who players will respect and follow the plan
Players are like us, someone they’ve never heard of may think
Not sure and want out.
Big days ahead this season depends on right decision
Glad I’m not making it.
Posts: 1,330
Threads: 20
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
4
Adios and thanks Carlos.
There was a West Bromwich Albion before you and there will be a West Bromwich Albion now you've gone. And I will always support them.
Merry Christmas everyone.
Posts: 406
Threads: 15
Joined: Jan 2024
Reputation:
3
(12-25-2024, 12:07 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think it's obvious I've been a massive supporter of him as manager here. I'm gutted he's going, he is what I like in a coach completely and I struggle to see us doing any better with someone else. Defensively sound and organised, meticulous planning, no over-the-top personality that overshadows the job itself, likeable and does it for the love of the game as much as the job.
Our loss is Valencia's gain, they don't have a terrible squad, and he'll keep them up, sure of that, whether he can satisfy the demands of their fanbase, known for being very demanding and lacking in patience, is another matter, but no way he could turn it down.
As for the future, well this is the first real test of the new owners, they've had it lucky in some ways, cutting the playing budget was offset by having a manager, who, outside of West Brom is considered the best in the Championship, truly, speak to other fans and listen to podcasts on the Championship, the reverence for CC is massive. I think we're about to find out why and that's if they get it right too. Potter is being hilariously linked, more chance of a Cuzer and me dream team with Klopp as our assistant. I can see us trying to sell the project to Cooper, and I'd be keen however, I think he'll hang on for a bit yet.
Bilic, absolutely no from me, he doesn't have Pereira now, if he can promise he comes too then it's a yes. Mowbray, never go back, but I wouldn't be too upset if he feels fit enough and wants it, he's developed a lot as a manager, and this squad would suit the manager he has become with only a small amount of change. Robins no thanks, suited Coventry and relied on Viveash heavily. Others we know of out of work don't interest me, and we won't pay compo.
So I think it's going to be some foreign name we've never heard of, someone doing well in a foreign lower league or an assistant or youth team manager for a big gun in Europe.Can be inspired, can be a disaster, only time will tell.
Overall, this is a bad day for West Bromwich Albion and very much an unwanted Christmas gift, but we carry on, we all knew this day would come.
As others have said, great post.
For me, Carlos has done a superb job in incredibly difficult circumstances. He took us from the bottom of the Championship to the play-offs, making us an attractive outfit on the pitch even when there was a circus off the pitch in the form of Lai & co. And even though we have since been blessed with Patel & Bilkul, the financial constraints continue to provide an enormous challenge, one which Corberan has risen to as Head Coach. Whilst this season’s table could obviously look a lot nicer had we converted some of those lacklustre draws into wins, we still find ourselves level on points with sixth, in with a fighting chance of getting to the play-offs once again.
I honestly believe that things could have panned out a lot differently if Corberan was not appointed. There’s every chance we would have been relegated that season he joined if we didn’t get the appointment right. And would a League One club in turmoil on and off the pitch have been attractive to our new owners? Would we actually find ourselves in administration, or worse? Who knows, but one thing is for sure - Carlos leaves our club in a far, far better state than what he found it. For that, his passion and all his efforts, he ranks very highly as one of the best West Bromwich Albion managers in my lifetime.
For what it’s worth, I bear no ill will against him for leaving, particularly as Valencia is somewhat of a homecoming for him. I wish him nothing but the best.
Adios, King Carlos, and thank you!
He’s gorra gew, Franksy!
Posts: 782
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
12-25-2024, 08:16 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-25-2024, 08:19 AM by Pontificator.)
(12-25-2024, 07:08 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Good post Birdy
Carlos has managed us brilliantly through the darkest period the club ever faced. He dragged us back from the brink of League 1 and potential oblivion. To then have the highest win percentage of any manager in our history for anyone coaching over 60 matches is quite incredible. Some fans seem determined to water his achievement down but looking at the reaction on social media, the vast majority recognise how good he has been for the club.
I'll forever be thankful and wish him nothing but good luck for the rest of his career and will watch his career closely.
All of that. CC gave the players back their raison d'être. The most important aspect of the managers job is to convince each individual they can win, improve their committment to the team, get them to understand that their roll on the pitch is at the behest of the manager, he will do that at Valencia. Beyond saving them from oblivion he will end up in the same financial boat and will finish his term there in the same way as here. The King is dead, long live the King
Posts: 1,735
Threads: 36
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
5
(12-25-2024, 12:07 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: I think it's obvious I've been a massive supporter of him as manager here. I'm gutted he's going, he is what I like in a coach completely and I struggle to see us doing any better with someone else. Defensively sound and organised, meticulous planning, no over-the-top personality that overshadows the job itself, likeable and does it for the love of the game as much as the job.
Our loss is Valencia's gain, they don't have a terrible squad, and he'll keep them up, sure of that, whether he can satisfy the demands of their fanbase, known for being very demanding and lacking in patience, is another matter, but no way he could turn it down.
As for the future, well this is the first real test of the new owners, they've had it lucky in some ways, cutting the playing budget was offset by having a manager, who, outside of West Brom is considered the best in the Championship, truly, speak to other fans and listen to podcasts on the Championship, the reverence for CC is massive. I think we're about to find out why and that's if they get it right too. Potter is being hilariously linked, more chance of a Cuzer and me dream team with Klopp as our assistant. I can see us trying to sell the project to Cooper, and I'd be keen however, I think he'll hang on for a bit yet.
Bilic, absolutely no from me, he doesn't have Pereira now, if he can promise he comes too then it's a yes. Mowbray, never go back, but I wouldn't be too upset if he feels fit enough and wants it, he's developed a lot as a manager, and this squad would suit the manager he has become with only a small amount of change. Robins no thanks, suited Coventry and relied on Viveash heavily. Others we know of out of work don't interest me, and we won't pay compo.
So I think it's going to be some foreign name we've never heard of, someone doing well in a foreign lower league or an assistant or youth team manager for a big gun in Europe.Can be inspired, can be a disaster, only time will tell.
Overall, this is a bad day for West Bromwich Albion and very much an unwanted Christmas gift, but we carry on, we all knew this day would come. Really good post Birdy.
|