My view on CC departure
#31
(12-24-2024, 09:28 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:25 AM)MrBater Wrote: Why pay off a debt that actually won't benefit you to pay off? It's not like that's what Patel sort of said... But hey ho.

Because it costs you money to keep it, that could go into the football budget.

Most people don't pay off debt because they are potless. We are about to see the truth about our new owners.

There are big early repayment penalties to repay it before (I think) summer 2025.
Reply
#32
I've seen all the usual comments in the press and on here. Which players will he "try to take with him"? Which players will want to leave once he's gone? Some of these comments coming from the same corners of the press which were talking about "maybe it's time for a change at The Hawthorns" just a couple of weeks ago.

I'll put a different perspective on it. I read on here (so it must be true) that Nestor has set a target of fourth place finish, i.e. an improvement on last season. CC's agent has been touting him for every job going since the summer and tbh CC himself hasn't done a very convincing job of denying any of the "rumours". So the players see a manager who isn't confident that he can meet that 4th place finish target, who feels that he needs to leap on any passing ladder because he's scared he might find himself on a snake. Has that been good for morale? Surely these guys know that playing in a winning team, being in the promotion mix, getting good visibility in the game is the way to advance their careers - because the transfer market for players works very differently.

Not many weeks ago people were posting "something's wrong, that's why the results are poor". Maybe this is what's been wrong. Carlos has been great for us and hopefully has a big career ahead of him. If he "cuts and runs" now he takes two risks - firstly the Klopp effect - someone else might come in and do better - secondly there's more pressure to deliver next time - one day he needs to be a manager who follows the job through instead of just stopping the rot and reaching his limit.
Reply
#33
It's not that deep. I've seen nothing to suggest that the players aren't giving their best for the club. CC is a good but not perfect manager working with a good but not amazing championship squad. We're around about where we should be but we really need to get this appointment right. If we do then we can get the playoffs
Reply
#34
(12-24-2024, 12:33 PM)Sliced Wrote: It's not that deep. I've seen nothing to suggest that the players aren't giving their best for the club. CC is a good but not perfect manager working with a good but not amazing championship squad. We're around about where we should be but we really need to get this appointment right. If we do then we can get the playoffs

I think it's been a tremendous season so far, no suggestion that anyone isn't doing their best. It's just that this situation must be a little unsettling for everyone on the playing/coaching side. Better to get it done, get someone in who is committed to meeting a new target. Maybe 18 to 30 months is the lifecycle for most coaches at most clubs nowadays. As you say, it's important to get the appointment right.
Reply
#35
(12-24-2024, 11:40 AM)MrBater Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 11:15 AM)Malcolm Tucker Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:28 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(12-24-2024, 09:25 AM)MrBater Wrote: Why pay off a debt that actually won't benefit you to pay off? It's not like that's what Patel sort of said... But hey ho.

Because it costs you money to keep it, that could go into the football budget.

Most people don't pay off debt because they are potless. We are about to see the truth about our new owners.

You don’t know what the terms of the loans are, so how can you know for certain it’s cheaper than paying it back per the original schedule?

Oddly I doubt you do either, however we know what Patel has said, and strange as it may seem, I think he does know, so for me, what he said is the right thing to have done....

Well yes, that was my point…
Reply
#36
(12-24-2024, 09:00 AM)RonnieWallwork Wrote: Assuming he’s going………..

I’m fairly relaxed about it. 

I’m a big CC fan but do I think he had/has the ability to get us up?  No.  Mainly due to the resources at his disposal but also I believe he’s more suited to keeping a side up.  If we went up I’d like no one else to be given a crack at keeping us in the PL, but I realise that’s ridiculous.   I think he’d be better suited to a survival fight with his organisational skills and getting the best out of, what would be a very second rate PL side. 

Where we’re at now, I think there’s plenty of options who would not only maintain our progress but also push us on with their experience of promotion - not this season but over the course of whatever contract they sign.

£3m rumoured compo sorts out any financial concerns about paying for the right man.  WBA don’t need to look at someone in a job currently.  Therefore the money goes on the new chaps wages/contract.

I don’t think we’ve a cat in hells chance of Potter.  

Cooper is my No.1 choice and even then we’d have to sell him the dream (and that dream means a right budget!) 

Beyond those two….Mowbray, Eustace, Robins would all fit i think. 

Big Sam - now I’ll be mocked for this but if the new owners want to give themselves more than a 50/50 chance of promotion in the next 2 years, someone tell me why we wouldn’t?  The football….we all know he can play some nice stuff with his sides but he also knows what it takes. His networks are fantastic.  He nearly kept us up and WANTED to stay.  

No doubt it’ll be none of the above and they’ll be a mixture of joy excitement and worry about our fanbase.

I don't want Mowbray anywhere near thanks. Small Heath was quite close enough.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)