City good to bad.
#11
(12-22-2024, 09:45 AM)MrFizz Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I would agree Josh. One thing Fergie always did was keep his Yanited squad fresh. Every 3 or 4 years there seemed to be a turnover of players.

Fergie was utterly ruthless. At the first sign of a player being past their peak they were out and replaced with someone younger and usually better. Similarly anyone with a hint of an attitude or complacency or any off field distractions were out.

He was usually right too. There weren’t many players discarded by Ferguson who went on to do better after United.
Reply
#12
Thought Gary Neville called it right before the United game last week.

It's nigh on impossible to maintain City's levels forever, these players have played at the highest level, under the most immense pressure for club and country for pretty much four years straight. To come back last year and win the title after the efforts that would have gone into the treble season was impressive, this year's it's just a year too far for the likes of Gundogan, Silva, KDB, Ederson, Walker and when you add in the injury to their best player it's not hard to see.

They had a dodgy season when Guardiola came in, give him this season to figure out what needs sorting and they'll be back again next season. I'd say if they're still struggling this time next season then he'd be leaving himself well open for criticism.
Reply
#13
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.
Reply
#14
(12-22-2024, 10:15 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Thought Gary Neville called it right before the United game last week.

It's nigh on impossible to maintain City's levels forever, these players have played at the highest level, under the most immense pressure for club and country for pretty much four years straight. To come back last year and win the title after the efforts that would have gone into the treble season was impressive, this year's it's just a year too far for the likes of Gundogan, Silva, KDB, Ederson, Walker and when you add in the injury to their best player it's not hard to see.

They had a dodgy season when Guardiola came in, give him this season to figure out what needs sorting and they'll be back again next season. I'd say if they're still struggling this time next season then he'd be leaving himself well open for criticism.

Indeed, all great footballing sides end eventually.
Reply
#15
(12-22-2024, 10:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.

So Pep what first attracted you to the oil rich, state funded Man City?
Reply
#16
(12-22-2024, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.

So Pep what first attracted you to the oil rich, state funded Man City?

So Man City, what first attracted you to serial winner Pep Guardiola?
Reply
#17
(12-22-2024, 11:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.

So Pep what first attracted you to the oil rich, state funded Man City?

So Man City, what first attracted you to serial winner Pep Guardiola?

As I’ve said, give him an average Prem team and see if the team performs above its resources or below. IMO Ferguson, Clough to name two have proven they are good managers with and without huge relative to the time budgets.
Reply
#18
(12-22-2024, 11:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 11:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.

So Pep what first attracted you to the oil rich, state funded Man City?

So Man City, what first attracted you to serial winner Pep Guardiola?

As I’ve said, give him an average Prem team and see if the team performs above its resources or below. IMO Ferguson, Clough to name two have proven they are good managers with and without huge relative to the time budgets.

Also a completely different era of football. Would Clough’s methods work today?
Reply
#19
(12-22-2024, 11:25 AM)Duffers Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 11:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 11:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.

So Pep what first attracted you to the oil rich, state funded Man City?

So Man City, what first attracted you to serial winner Pep Guardiola?

As I’ve said, give him an average Prem team and see if the team performs above its resources or below. IMO Ferguson, Clough to name two have proven they are good managers with and without huge relative to the time budgets.

Also a completely different era of football. Would Clough’s methods work today?

Who knows, it’s one of those arguments you can never prove either way unless Pep decides to leave Man Cuty and take on Brentford, Forest etc.
Reply
#20
(12-22-2024, 11:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 11:07 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:50 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 10:16 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I think you’re absolutely right Josh.

Elite managers’ ability is all about squeezing more and more out of already famous and vastly wealthy individuals who’ve arguably achieved everything they need to. Pep has built a ruthless winning machine at City but their approach of buying younger players that can then be developed into world class stars hasn’t born the same quality in the last couple of seasons. Players like Doku and Nunes havent delivered what was needed, and the sale of Alvarez looks stranger with every game.

I think Pep is an excellent manager, and one who has impacted football (for better or for worse) more than any other manager in the last 30 years, and will be spoken about in the same terms as Michels and Cruyff in years to come, however he’s showing signs of fatigue as much as the squad is. 

I do agree though, the longer this run goes on, the more damage he’s doing to his reputation as the lazy “he couldn’t do it without the money” lines will be trotted out. Pep has spent no more than United, Chelsea, even Arteta in recent seasons and has still delivered dominance over English football.

So Pep what first attracted you to the oil rich, state funded Man City?

So Man City, what first attracted you to serial winner Pep Guardiola?

As I’ve said, give him an average Prem team and see if the team performs above its resources or below. IMO Ferguson, Clough to name two have proven they are good managers with and without huge relative to the time budgets.

I wonder why more mid table Prem managers don’t get a crack at top jobs if that’s the determining factor for success…?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)