City good to bad.
#1
Has there ever been such a quick transition by a dominant club to such a feeble, pathetic and timid side? 

I can't believe how bad they've become and how rapid it has happened. It's usually a slow transition.
Reply
#2
Season from hell for them at their level. The pressure of continuing their dominance, the financial case going on and injuries to a couple of key players they've failed to compensate for. It'll do them good to 'suffer' like the rest of us
Reply
#3
Always said the test of a good manager is what they do to stop a losing run. Over rated that boy!
Pulis would stop the slide.
Reply
#4
Pep hasn’t had any real managerial hardship and has had the luxury of world class players and budgets his entire career. He’s not exactly showing great ability to get the best out of his world class players currently and I suspect with lesser resources he would struggle. Also he’s inflicted a tedious style of play on almost every club in the country.

Love to see him manage Walsall for example.
Reply
#5
(12-21-2024, 08:17 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pep hasn’t had any real managerial hardship and has had the luxury of world class players and budgets his entire career. He’s not exactly showing great ability to get the best out of his world class players currently and I suspect with lesser resources he would struggle. Also he’s inflicted a tedious style of play on almost every club in the country.

Love to see him manage Walsall for example.

The “could he manage Walsall?” argument is always absolute bullshit as it completely ignores the pressures and scrutiny that comes with the expectations of having to get close to perfection every year. To manage a dressing room full of world class players with massive egos and mould them into a functioning team is a damn site harder than it looks. I doubt Ray Graydon would produce the same results at City as Guardiola has.

Up until this season Guardiola has been brilliant at City. Now suddenly both him and his squad look completely burnt out, a lot of them are the wrong side of 30 and all of a sudden are really showing it. The whole squad needs a massive overhaul and I’m not sure Pep has the stomach for it anymore. What’s really telling is that he and his team have never experienced any sort of run like this before. They haven’t got the experience of turning around any loss of form because they’ve never needed to. This has completely fucked their heads up and it’s showing badly.
Reply
#6
(12-21-2024, 08:33 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(12-21-2024, 08:17 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Pep hasn’t had any real managerial hardship and has had the luxury of world class players and budgets his entire career. He’s not exactly showing great ability to get the best out of his world class players currently and I suspect with lesser resources he would struggle. Also he’s inflicted a tedious style of play on almost every club in the country.

Love to see him manage Walsall for example.

The “could he manage Walsall?” argument is always absolute bullshit as it completely ignores the pressures and scrutiny that comes with the expectations of having to get close to perfection every year. To manage a dressing room full of world class players with massive egos and mould them into a functioning team is a damn site harder than it looks. I doubt Ray Graydon would produce the same results at City as Guardiola has.

Up until this season Guardiola has been brilliant at City. Now suddenly both him and his squad look completely burnt out, a lot of them are the wrong side of 30 and all of a sudden are really showing it. The whole squad needs a massive overhaul and I’m not sure Pep has the stomach for it anymore. What’s really telling is that he and his team have never experienced any sort of run like this before. They haven’t got the experience of turning around any loss of form because they’ve never needed to. This has completely fucked their heads up and it’s showing badly.

He can mange egos but there no evidence he can build a team without having the luxury of the very best players, coaches, medical staff and budget in the World. Compared to say Ferguson who cut his teeth at Aberdeen and achieved success he’s always had a huge advantage to succeed as a manager. Give him a job with a middling Prem team and his record I doubt would look anywhere near as impressive. 

As for pressure, he could never win a game of football again and still be able to give him and his family a Hollywood lifestyle. Managers further down football pecking order have pressure, pressure to keep their jobs to support their families. Pressure is the same, circumstances different.

Man City have bought success and Pep was part of that but also the beneficiary. If he can’t turn around a down turn in form with the resources he’s got, then he’s not the genius he’s made out to be.
Reply
#7
Carlos is currently 3-1 for the job on the exchange sites
Reply
#8
Mat Sadler / Pep Guardiola in sensational job swap.

I'd watch that.
Reply
#9
I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.
Reply
#10
(12-22-2024, 08:12 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: I think calling Pep overrated, or implying it, is a bit harsh. I think Duffers is right. Yes, he's fallen lucky with budgets, squads, and world class talent, but you still have to manage that. City got nowhere near winning the Champions League until Pep arrived, despite possessing arguably the best squad in Europe for many years.

I believe Cities demise is due to the core squad lacking motivation. They've won the league 4 times in a row. 6 out of the last 7. The Champions League. They've achieved the treble. Set all sorts of points and wins records. There's literally nothing left for them to do. From the outside looking in, I find it extremely difficult to fathom how you can motivate yourself to keep performing when you've done it all.

Maybe that's too simplistic, and the issues are deeper than that.

I would agree Josh. One thing Fergie always did was keep his Yanited squad fresh. Every 3 or 4 years there seemed to be a turnover of players.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)