Posts: 13,262
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(12-17-2024, 08:08 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (12-17-2024, 11:27 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: (12-16-2024, 05:30 PM)Johnnykayeengland Wrote: The liquidator podcast reckons Villa will recall Dobbin in January because he's not getting the minutes.
Typical Seals. They recall him because we don't play him - not because we think he is shite.
It’s fine- if they choose to recall him we won’t get lumbered with paying his wages… if we send him back, we will.
Absolute waste of a spot on the bench, and a complete waste of a wage, along with Cole (given CC doesn’t rate him).
We have a big squad for this level and think we need to do a bit of sensible squad reduction in Jan. it was always going to be a huge ask to recycle the squad in one window given the constraints we had. We just have to trust the process, as I do think we are getting more right than wrong.
Not necessarily. If there's a break clause then we won't. If we just send him back without that clause and no agreement then we will.
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
Not out the question that we see Dobbins sent back and we get Louis Barry as replacement.
That'll boil some piss.
Posts: 8,006
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(12-18-2024, 09:32 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not out the question that we see Dobbins sent back and we get Louis Barry as replacement.
That'll boil some piss.
Can't see it. Whether he is recalled or sent back, Villa will be disappointed with the opportunity he has been offered so can't see any way they send us another one.
Fully expect to see Barry rock up in the Championship in Jan though, hopefully to someone we have already played twice!!
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(12-18-2024, 09:34 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (12-18-2024, 09:32 AM)richbaggie Wrote: Not out the question that we see Dobbins sent back and we get Louis Barry as replacement.
That'll boil some piss.
Can't see it. Whether he is recalled or sent back, Villa will be disappointed with the opportunity he has been offered so can't see any way they send us another one.
Fully expect to see Barry rock up in the Championship in Jan though, hopefully to someone we have already played twice!!
To be fair to us, Dobbins has had a fair few minutes and simply hasn't taken the opportunity to impress. Villa will have monitored his performances closely. I don't see why their disappointment would be aimed at us, especially as Emery and Carlos are very close.
Posts: 8,127
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
12-18-2024, 09:42 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 10:44 AM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Wildchild - dunno
Colgate - keeps his teeth nice and clean. Cleaner than his sheets anyway.
Hedgehog - been largely ace so far. Gem of a signing.
McNerr - unlucky
Frabotcheeks - I think he'll turn out to be shit but enjoy Marek Cech levels of slurp on here in the process.
'Arry Styles - so far so good
Diarolakyte - hmmmm
Ratchet - he'd have a part to play if we were on the moon. But we're not. Too slow.
Boris Johnston - only just starting to play. Overall a poor return - should have been a better striker coming in instead of him and Cole.
Dobbler - "What day is it again?"
Cole - it's a bit hard to judge on game time, not holding out much hope.
Summary - some good, some bad, mostly average. I think we had more success on the outgoings than the incomings.
Posts: 9,655
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
12-18-2024, 11:05 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 11:07 AM by Josh1873.)
Still 55% of the season to go. It's still fair too early to judge.
Heggem is clearly a success. I'm pretty sure Styles will be, too.
We all know what Johnston is capable of, so I won't be told that's a poor signing, because absolutely no one questioned it at the time. In fact - it was the opposite. Everyone was buzzing. Ditto Holgate. So that's 4 signings right off the bat I would deem good and sensible.
With regards to Racic, Diakite, and Cole. They've not really figured much, but I've seen glimpses in their play to suggest each one could be a good or solid player given a run of games to allow them to get up to speed. But they simply need more time to judge.
Dobbins, jury is very much out.
Frabotta - bizarre. Good CV, but has seemingly been frozen out.
In summary, too early to judge. 4 good signings, 3 signings where you need more opportunity to judge. 2 apparent busts, but similarly they need more opportunity.
Also, I seem to recall most reasonable people agreed we had an excellent summer, transfer business wise. I still believe that to be the case.
Posts: 1,904
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
12-18-2024, 02:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 04:30 PM by ericlegrisly.)
(12-18-2024, 11:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Still 55% of the season to go. It's still fair too early to judge.
Heggem is clearly a success. I'm pretty sure Styles will be, too.
We all know what Johnston is capable of, so I won't be told that's a poor signing, because absolutely no one questioned it at the time. In fact - it was the opposite. Everyone was buzzing. Ditto Holgate. So that's 4 signings right off the bat I would deem good and sensible.
With regards to Racic, Diakite, and Cole. They've not really figured much, but I've seen glimpses in their play to suggest each one could be a good or solid player given a run of games to allow them to get up to speed. But they simply need more time to judge.
Dobbins, jury is very much out.
Frabotta - bizarre. Good CV, but has seemingly been frozen out.
In summary, too early to judge. 4 good signings, 3 signings where you need more opportunity to judge. 2 apparent busts, but similarly they need more opportunity.
Also, I seem to recall most reasonable people agreed we had an excellent summer, transfer business wise. I still believe that to be the case.
Ahem. I certainly did.
As for the rest:
Racic - No. Too ponderous, not good enough.
Styles - Yes. Done OK.
Frabotta - I think I share Corberan's reservations.
Dobbins - Shit
Diakite - Not good enough
Heggem - Yes.
Cole - No idea.
Should point out I'm not moaning about this - we find ourselves where we are and gamble signings are a bit of a necessity. They were never likely to all come off.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
I think a couple of these were signed early in the window and purely to fill squad numbers. As things moved along we recruited better so they have played little part. Overall I wouldn't say it was poor business, considering the outgoings we have steadied the ship nicely and added a couple of gems. (Heggem and Styles). Of the new guys I think there is potential to get more from Diakite and Racic. I'd struggle to justify Dobbin but he is exactly the type required, 12 Premier League games, England junior international etc. Loans are always a gamble so if we can send him back and get similar but a better fit for our club, then all is well and good. Considering the financial straightjacket if anyone does come in then it's a bonus.
Posts: 2,420
Threads: 158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
(12-18-2024, 11:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Still 55% of the season to go. It's still fair too early to judge.
Heggem is clearly a success. I'm pretty sure Styles will be, too.
We all know what Johnston is capable of, so I won't be told that's a poor signing, because absolutely no one questioned it at the time. In fact - it was the opposite. Everyone was buzzing. Ditto Holgate. So that's 4 signings right off the bat I would deem good and sensible.
With regards to Racic, Diakite, and Cole. They've not really figured much, but I've seen glimpses in their play to suggest each one could be a good or solid player given a run of games to allow them to get up to speed. But they simply need more time to judge.
Dobbins, jury is very much out.
Frabotta - bizarre. Good CV, but has seemingly been frozen out.
In summary, too early to judge. 4 good signings, 3 signings where you need more opportunity to judge. 2 apparent busts, but similarly they need more opportunity.
Also, I seem to recall most reasonable people agreed we had an excellent summer, transfer business wise. I still believe that to be the case.
Frabotta has played for 10 clubs yet never played more than 22 games for any of them. He could do with staying with one club for sometime
Posts: 7,727
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
12-18-2024, 05:07 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-18-2024, 05:08 PM by Jacko.)
(12-18-2024, 04:09 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: (12-18-2024, 11:05 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: Still 55% of the season to go. It's still fair too early to judge.
Heggem is clearly a success. I'm pretty sure Styles will be, too.
We all know what Johnston is capable of, so I won't be told that's a poor signing, because absolutely no one questioned it at the time. In fact - it was the opposite. Everyone was buzzing. Ditto Holgate. So that's 4 signings right off the bat I would deem good and sensible.
With regards to Racic, Diakite, and Cole. They've not really figured much, but I've seen glimpses in their play to suggest each one could be a good or solid player given a run of games to allow them to get up to speed. But they simply need more time to judge.
Dobbins, jury is very much out.
Frabotta - bizarre. Good CV, but has seemingly been frozen out.
In summary, too early to judge. 4 good signings, 3 signings where you need more opportunity to judge. 2 apparent busts, but similarly they need more opportunity.
Also, I seem to recall most reasonable people agreed we had an excellent summer, transfer business wise. I still believe that to be the case.
Frabotta has played for 10 clubs yet never played more than 22 games for any of them. He could do with staying with one club for sometime
A bit disingenuous. 7 of these were loans. He's played for Bologna, Juve and now us as parent clubs. As an example Leicester City were Chris Wood's 10th club, after 6 loan spells from us. 23 games on loan at Blues was his most.
|