Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(12-15-2024, 09:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (12-15-2024, 09:42 PM)Squid Wrote: Harsh to say Johnston has gone to pot, he was one of the best players on the pitch on Wednesday.
I really think people underestimated how difficult Yokuslu would be to replace. He did so much for us and made it look easy.
Overall, I think we've done as well as could be expected with our budget. Heggam is a truly excellent buy.
Yokuslu wouldn't fix our biggest issue now mind, we need a ball carrier who can create in midfield. Put a Mozza, Dorrans or Pereira in this team we're near the top of the league.
It would make a big difference but they aren't cheap!
Posts: 7,727
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
(12-15-2024, 09:42 PM)Squid Wrote: Harsh to say Johnston has gone to pot, he was one of the best players on the pitch on Wednesday.
I really think people underestimated how difficult Yokuslu would be to replace. He did so much for us and made it look easy.
Overall, I think we've done as well as could be expected with our budget. Heggam is a truly excellent buy.
Bang on. Molumby is rubbish. A functional, energiser bunny midfielder. Nearly contrived to miss the chance today. Yokuşlu would make a huge difference. That said I also agree we need someone to play where Swift and Grady contributed so much last season. The lack of productivity from attacking midfield is killing us.
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(12-15-2024, 09:02 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Wildsmith - Hasn't played
Holgate - Ok as cover but don't think he's good enough - Fail
Heggem - Resounding success
McNair - injured so impossible to say
Frabotta - Fail
Styles - success
Diakete - Has hardly been able to make the first XI - fail
Racic - A few promising moments but overall fail
Johnston - So far a fail but has shown some signs of improvement
Dobbin - fail
Cole - fail
What do people think of this recruitment? Is this the sort of success rate we can expect for our budget or should we be doing better? And is it the recruitment dept or CC who is ultimately responsible for it?
Ludicrously harsh judgements, Tartan, slap bang in "glass half empty" territory. Try this instead:
Wildsmith - hasn't played
Holgate - doing OK
Heggem - impressive
McNair - waste of a wage, lasted what, 150 minutes?
Frabotta - haven't seen enough to judge, haven't needed him to step up yet
Styles - looks lively
Diakite - jury's still out, disappointing that he's been injured a couple of times we needed him
Racic - doesn't look out of place, still settling in but promising
Johnston - picking up some form now, although he hasn't re-captured last season's magic yet
Dobbin - loans of young high-value players are a lottery, this one may turn out to be a fail
Cole - CC clearly doesn't rate him, if this doesn't change then it's a fail
Consider what these guys are replacing. Adam Reach, perennial spacegoat. Matt Phillips, great for 20 games max per season guaranteed to miss at least 15. Conor Townsend, getting plenty of criticism as the season wore on. Pieters, knocking on a bit, Chalobah never impressed, Weimann, squad filler, M'Vila and Pipa, why were they even here? Saved the best until last. Martin Kelly FFS. I'd say only Matty Phillips when on fire and of course Cedric Kipre are missed. Our recruitment has been pretty good in the circumstances. Don't rush to judgement, it's early days for these players.
Posts: 3,161
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(12-15-2024, 11:53 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (12-15-2024, 09:02 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Wildsmith - Hasn't played
Holgate - Ok as cover but don't think he's good enough - Fail
Heggem - Resounding success
McNair - injured so impossible to say
Frabotta - Fail
Styles - success
Diakete - Has hardly been able to make the first XI - fail
Racic - A few promising moments but overall fail
Johnston - So far a fail but has shown some signs of improvement
Dobbin - fail
Cole - fail
What do people think of this recruitment? Is this the sort of success rate we can expect for our budget or should we be doing better? And is it the recruitment dept or CC who is ultimately responsible for it?
Ludicrously harsh judgements, Tartan, slap bang in "glass half empty" territory. Try this instead:
Wildsmith - hasn't played
Holgate - doing OK
Heggem - impressive
McNair - waste of a wage, lasted what, 150 minutes?
Frabotta - haven't seen enough to judge, haven't needed him to step up yet
Styles - looks lively
Diakite - jury's still out, disappointing that he's been injured a couple of times we needed him
Racic - doesn't look out of place, still settling in but promising
Johnston - picking up some form now, although he hasn't re-captured last season's magic yet
Dobbin - loans of young high-value players are a lottery, this one may turn out to be a fail
Cole - CC clearly doesn't rate him, if this doesn't change then it's a fail
Consider what these guys are replacing. Adam Reach, perennial spacegoat. Matt Phillips, great for 20 games max per season guaranteed to miss at least 15. Conor Townsend, getting plenty of criticism as the season wore on. Pieters, knocking on a bit, Chalobah never impressed, Weimann, squad filler, M'Vila and Pipa, why were they even here? Saved the best until last. Martin Kelly FFS. I'd say only Matty Phillips when on fire and of course Cedric Kipre are missed. Our recruitment has been pretty good in the circumstances. Don't rush to judgement, it's early days for these players.
I agree with your assessments except for McNair and Pieters. Yes we didn’t get any value out of them because of their injuries, but players don’t get injured on purpose. McNair had a very good fitness record when we signed him, so we were unlucky there. (Kelly had a long injury history so was a big risk when we signed him and that risk proved accurate). Pieters was an outstanding signing, given how well he performed (despite his age).
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
12-16-2024, 08:54 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2024, 08:54 AM by TartanRug.)
(12-15-2024, 11:53 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: (12-15-2024, 09:02 PM)TartanRug Wrote: Wildsmith - Hasn't played
Holgate - Ok as cover but don't think he's good enough - Fail
Heggem - Resounding success
McNair - injured so impossible to say
Frabotta - Fail
Styles - success
Diakete - Has hardly been able to make the first XI - fail
Racic - A few promising moments but overall fail
Johnston - So far a fail but has shown some signs of improvement
Dobbin - fail
Cole - fail
What do people think of this recruitment? Is this the sort of success rate we can expect for our budget or should we be doing better? And is it the recruitment dept or CC who is ultimately responsible for it?
Ludicrously harsh judgements, Tartan, slap bang in "glass half empty" territory. Try this instead:
Wildsmith - hasn't played
Holgate - doing OK
Heggem - impressive
McNair - waste of a wage, lasted what, 150 minutes?
Frabotta - haven't seen enough to judge, haven't needed him to step up yet
Styles - looks lively
Diakite - jury's still out, disappointing that he's been injured a couple of times we needed him
Racic - doesn't look out of place, still settling in but promising
Johnston - picking up some form now, although he hasn't re-captured last season's magic yet
Dobbin - loans of young high-value players are a lottery, this one may turn out to be a fail
Cole - CC clearly doesn't rate him, if this doesn't change then it's a fail
Consider what these guys are replacing. Adam Reach, perennial spacegoat. Matt Phillips, great for 20 games max per season guaranteed to miss at least 15. Conor Townsend, getting plenty of criticism as the season wore on. Pieters, knocking on a bit, Chalobah never impressed, Weimann, squad filler, M'Vila and Pipa, why were they even here? Saved the best until last. Martin Kelly FFS. I'd say only Matty Phillips when on fire and of course Cedric Kipre are missed. Our recruitment has been pretty good in the circumstances. Don't rush to judgement, it's early days for these players.
Holgate for me does well in patches but isn't reliable at all and often gets caught out of position. Some of the others I've put 'fail' simply because they've barely played - we need players who can have an impact and if these players can't make the first XI or at least coming off the bench then has to be marked as a failure, of course this can change if they have an impact on the rest of the season.
I've been fairly disappointed in Racic, in one of his first games I thought he might be the player who could break into the box and get shots away or assists but this hasn't happened and we look better with Molumby/Mowatt there.
The players they are replacing were hit and miss but I'm not convinced the new batch barring a couple are much better.
Posts: 1,802
Threads: 27
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation:
7
12-16-2024, 10:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2024, 10:36 AM by Vinebaggie.)
If I was going to do a classic RAG rating where Red is fail, Amber is OK / jury still out, and Green is success I'd go as follows
Wildsmith - Amber
Holgate - Amber
Heggem - Green
McNair - Red
Frabotta - Red
Styles - Green
Diakete - Amber
Racic - Amber
Johnston - Amber
Dobbin - Red
Cole - Red
So I'm getting 4 Reds, 5 Ambers and only 2 Greens, which is kind of a reflection on the fact we haven't got a pot to piss in
Posts: 1,963
Threads: 80
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
It amazes me how many people I see absolutely slate the recruitment despite us having to drastically reduce wage bill and have so little cash for transfers.
It's not rocket science to work out why it's ended up hit and miss.
Posts: 3,595
Threads: 27
Joined: Apr 2019
Reputation:
14
(12-16-2024, 10:42 AM)richbaggie Wrote: It amazes me how many people I see absolutely slate the recruitment despite us having to drastically reduce wage bill and have so little cash for transfers.
It's not rocket science to work out why it's ended up hit and miss.
Don't come on here spouting sense - that's not what this bored is for.
Posts: 7,409
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
Wildsmith done what he was bought in for. Fair.
Holgate hasn’t done much wrong good cover. Fair
Heggem absolutely outstanding. Excellent
McNair unlucky did well in the one full match. Fair
Fabrotta bought in as cover hasn’t looked the part in small cameo’s. jury out.
Styles done well in left back role. Very Good
Diakate looked good in pre season, jury out.
Ragic ok sometimes. Fair.
Johnston nothing like last season but improving. Needs to step up now.
Dobbin send back doesn’t do enough poor.
Cole has he played doesn’t even look a decent player. poor.
Posts: 480
Threads: 7
Joined: Sep 2022
Reputation:
7
12-16-2024, 01:01 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2024, 01:09 PM by B68Baggy.)
(12-15-2024, 09:50 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (12-15-2024, 09:42 PM)Squid Wrote: Harsh to say Johnston has gone to pot, he was one of the best players on the pitch on Wednesday.
I really think people underestimated how difficult Yokuslu would be to replace. He did so much for us and made it look easy.
Overall, I think we've done as well as could be expected with our budget. Heggam is a truly excellent buy.
Yokuslu wouldn't fix our biggest issue now mind, we need a ball carrier who can create in midfield. Put a Mozza, Dorrans or Pereira in this team we're near the top of the league.
We lost our two best defensive distributors, which continues to impact the whole team.
Kippers and Yuk were responsible for playing through the lines from defense, allowing Mowatt to play higher and Swift to play as a genuine number 10.
At times Mowatt is having to play the quarter back role and Swift is picking up deep into his own half when he is on the pitch, they are taking on these roles as they are the players with real quality and composure on the ball. As has been mentioned on the fred, neither are able to then get up the pitch with pace, so our build up is slow.
It's such a shame we didnt get to see the spine of Kippers, Yok and Maja working together. Such a technically proficient spine.
First view on Racic was very positive, showing real elements of Yuks play, but he just seems to lack any kind of engine/stamina or match sharpness. DIateke seemed to be bought in as a DM but may be one we are giving time to with his injury record.
I think McNair would have been given responsibility for distribution but injury put pay to that. Holgate was only ever bought in as versatile cover and as much as we all love Heggem, we've seen errors from him on the ball. So we are left without a natural ball player to come out and start attacks, and losing Semi means we have to defend deeper still.
So yes, the real issue here is we didnt replace those players effectively BUT I think we all know why and there is a certain acceptance if it.
As we start deeper we are relying on out ball carriers out wide. Fellows and Grant have had good seasons so far but after that we have struggled. Mikey has shown glimpses but is often running into three or four defenders as he is starting deeper and no more needs to be said on Dobbins. Overly spacegoated but doesnt offer an answer.
Cole of course is the big WHY? As a fan there is nothing more frustrating than seeing a player left on the bench as we dont see him train. Just give him some time CC....how can our last 20s be any worse for it.
So agreed Birdy. We are desperate for extra legs and a ball carrier but the whole team is massively impacted by our distribution from the back. However ball playing center halves are probably as difficult to find as quality centre forwards and top defensive midfielders in today's game are gold dust.
It will be interesting to see what plans they have for Jan, or maybe not as we know the financial situation. We surely do need to play the loan market better though....any Harvey Barnes going spare??
|