Labour Austerity
#61
(12-13-2024, 07:31 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-13-2024, 07:24 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The hardship of your friends sounds unbearable.

I’ll start them a GoFundMe

Put VAT on Tuition Fees then. Universities are far more venal than independent schools ever were.

No problem, I’ll sort it Monday
Reply
#62
(12-13-2024, 07:21 AM)Protheroe Wrote: VAT on school fees is likely to accelerate that.

Materially?
Reply
#63
I’d expect in catchments like Arden and Haybridge, yes. You don’t get much change from £500k for a small family home here. Yet that’s far cheaper than sending two kids to RGS or Bromsgrove.
Reply
#64
So let’s say we lose 10% of the 600,000 private school kids, that’s 60,000 or roughly 30,000 families. Distributed around the 4000 or so relevant state schools, that’s less than 8 per school catchment area. Quite a stretch to suggest that is ramping up prices, to say the least
Reply
#65
It fits the narrative GD, I live in one of those areas being touted, prices have gone up pretty steadily over the last 25 years above the national average. There has been a spike recently following a large Chinese / Hong Kong immigration into the area, the likelihood that a dozen or so parents moving to the area is going to add another 10% to the house price is ridiculous.

It’ll be interesting to see the actual impact on numbers in private education when this kicks in. I suspect the change will be negligible. There are some real hot heads running around now that must have only recently got into politics because I don’t recall this reaction by them for Brexit or the revolving door period at No 10.
Reply
#66
It will be negligible. The demographic involved doesn't add up to equalling any effect. Unless the whole population affected all moved to Warwickshire say, at the same time.

It's a piss and bluster argument
Reply
#67
(12-13-2024, 09:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: So let’s say we lose 10% of the 600,000 private school kids, that’s 60,000 or roughly 30,000 families. Distributed around the 4000 or so relevant state schools, that’s less than 8 per school catchment area. Quite a stretch to suggest that is ramping up prices, to say the least

If you only count kids currently in independent schools, yes. You also need to consider those that make the same decision as we did and now won't go t independent schools.

It would be conservative to say that will be in the tens of thousands of families per annum, this isn't a one off hit.
Reply
#68
Tens of thousands? Even if that is the case not all of those tens of thousands would have got in, there simply aren't the places. Included in that cohort are the likes of you and I who considered it but decided the best course was to move to the catchment area of the better state schools, VAT on private school education did not impact those decisions as it didn't exist then but based on your wording we should be included in the figures.
Reply
#69
(12-13-2024, 10:11 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-13-2024, 09:11 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: So let’s say we lose 10% of the 600,000 private school kids, that’s 60,000 or roughly 30,000 families. Distributed around the 4000 or so relevant state schools, that’s less than 8 per school catchment area. Quite a stretch to suggest that is ramping up prices, to say the least

If you only count kids currently in independent schools, yes. You also need to consider those that make the same decision as we did and now won't go t independent schools.

It would be conservative to say that will be in the tens of thousands of families per annum, this isn't a one off hit.

You’re basically talking about something that has existed since the 1980s or before and making out it is a new problem or that this tiny extra number (in context) is somehow having a major additional effect.

So it’s old news and the idea that it’s either recent or significantly worse because of vat on school fees is frankly just plain wrong.

In fact, it was on the A level soc syllabus as far back as 1994.
Reply
#70
(12-13-2024, 10:49 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: somehow having a major additional effect.

Where have I claimed it's having a "major effect"?

(12-13-2024, 10:30 AM)baggy1 Wrote: Tens of thousands? Even if that is the case not all of those tens of thousands would have got in, there simply aren't the places. Included in that cohort are the likes of you and I who considered it but decided the best course was to move to the catchment area of the better state schools, VAT on private school education did not impact those decisions as it didn't exist then but based on your wording we should be included in the figures.

"who now won't go"

I'm not including you or I. I'm including the future you and I.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: