Labour Austerity
#51
(12-12-2024, 06:56 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: It’s just fair and proper. Those organisations are about as much of a charity as Jim Ratcliffe.

And as we’ve already seen, but hasn’t been acknowledged, there are plenty of excellent post 16 state providers and according to some of you the people bailing out are so awash with spare cash they are driving up house prices inordinately.

What’s the actual problem? Other than a few people sobbing that they’ve now got to contribute fairly

So something that's "fair and proper" yet raises no money but causes genuine hardship to friends of mine is worth it? OK.

Why do it at all unless you just wanted to be cunty to people your party members (and plenty on here) resent?
Reply
#52
Genuine hardship.

How does that work?

As usual, you seem to post about small segments of your own bubble and think everyone else should be giving a shit on their behalf.

Why do you think these organisations should be treated as charitable when they are anything but?

And you’ve still not explained or answered how they are so hard up but can drive up house prices. I wonder why.
Reply
#53
FWIW, ever since we moved to where we live now , people have been saying that young families move to the area because the schools are good. I believe you fund the local school adequately according to it's needs and parents should support it.
Reply
#54
(12-12-2024, 07:20 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Genuine hardship.

How does that work?

As usual, you seem to post about small segments of your own bubble and think everyone else should be giving a shit on their behalf.

Why do you think these organisations should be treated as charitable when they are anything but?

And you’ve still not explained or answered how they are so hard up but can drive up house prices. I wonder why.

I actually wonder why mealy mouthed pinkoes hate parents who pay for independent schools so much. 

If we’re going to be consistent on applying VAT to education then I expect you’ll support the application of VAT to university tuition fees. If you going to be spitefully cunty about things, then at least be consistent.

And buying a house in a good catchment is considerably cheaper than school fees, even before the application of VAT.
Reply
#55
Still no answer to the question.

Because we all know that both things can’t be true. It’s one thing being angry, but another to be caught out just spouting bollocks and swerve the truth

Cheers Boris

(12-12-2024, 09:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-12-2024, 07:20 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Genuine hardship.

How does that work?

As usual, you seem to post about small segments of your own bubble and think everyone else should be giving a shit on their behalf.

Why do you think these organisations should be treated as charitable when they are anything but?

And you’ve still not explained or answered how they are so hard up but can drive up house prices. I wonder why.

I actually wonder why mealy mouthed pinkoes hate parents who pay for independent schools so much. 

If we’re going to be consistent on applying VAT to education then I expect you’ll support the application of VAT to university tuition fees. If you going to be spitefully cunty about things, then at least be consistent.

And buying a house in a good catchment is considerably cheaper than school fees, even before the application of VAT.

Yet according to you and KKC these people have so much surplus to spend on their mortgage that house prices are out of control. It’s laughable and you’ve been caught out. Just own it.
Reply
#56
Sorry? What question? It’s far cheaper to buy a house in a catchment than send two kids to private school. And you can spread the cost over 25 years, and hopefully obtain some capital appreciation.

The premium where I live is ridiculous - same in so many other places surrounding Brum.
Reply
#57
(12-12-2024, 09:54 PM)Protheroe Wrote: Sorry? What question?

Is VAT on private education going to materially make a difference to house prices in catchment areas of good state schools?
Reply
#58
Did I not answer that above? The price of private education has been affecting house prices in certain areas for a decade or more. It’s behind the decision we made to move here. VAT on school fees is likely to accelerate that.
Reply
#59
The hardship of your friends sounds unbearable.

I’ll start them a GoFundMe
Reply
#60
(12-13-2024, 07:24 AM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: The hardship of your friends sounds unbearable.

I’ll start them a GoFundMe

Put VAT on Tuition Fees then. Universities are far more venal than independent schools ever were.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: