The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector
#81
(12-09-2024, 03:45 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Using the ignore function on a debate forum is proper toys out of the pram stuff. This isn’t a teenage Instagram account

If CC can let me have a contribution to ANY debate I'll be happy to debate it with him.
Reply
#82
(12-09-2024, 08:28 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(12-09-2024, 12:33 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-09-2024, 12:05 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Can you give me some examples of where that has happened?

Well as someone who works with the disabled on occasion… I and many in that community feel they have been on the receiving end of barbed comments, the blame game and little if any positive messaging. 

The ‘hard working person’ is alway in the context of someone going to work it never acknowledges those who can’t work as they care for a loved one who needs 24hr support. They are lumped in with those who refuse to get a job in the messaging

OAPs barely above the cut off line for winter fuel support have been told it’s tough unless they want to go through the labyrinthine UC system. 

Civil servants seem to be the next in line for criticism. 

Those worried by inappropriate house building are accused of being NIMBY’s, blockers, tree huggers etc 

As much as I’m not that sympathetic to farmers, the messaging again has been tough get over it. No real acknowledgment that this will be difficult for them. 

The same for small business’s, again the message is we know what’s best and get over it. 

These things may not affect you but they do others and the messaging and optics shout… we couldn’t give a fuck what you think, this is our way and we know what’s best’. This same misplaced confidence/arrogance and shouting down of critics was a major reason Labour lost the last time… who can forget Brown’s infamous ‘bigited woman’ comment. 

I know you’re a member of the Labour Party now B1 but taking the red rosette off for a moment you can see your party is annoying vast swathes of the country and offering very little hope for the future in return.

You’ll be unsurprised that most of the messaging is the interpretation delivered from the media rather than the original message. Take a look at the white paper and tell me that you feel the messaging is anti-disabled. It recognises the various struggles and lost opportunities within the document - before you take the summary, if any media actually bother to read it, look at what is actually being said: https://www.gov.uk/government/publicatio...hite-paper

WFA is an anomaly - I have said for years that it shouldn’t be dished out to everyone as I’ve watched both my Dad and Uncle benefit from it without ever needing it. I can also see that those at the poorer end will need it but where to cut off. It is the logical approach that the PC (not UC as you state) is the best point rather than make up an arbitrary amount that would be impossible to measure against.

Civil Servants - in what way? Adding manpower and recognising where the pinch points are again appear to be the sensible approach, I don’t see the criticism.

Farmers have gone hook line and sinker for the GB News spin, the vast majority of them won’t be impacted at all by the changes. The irony of Clarkson being their spokesperson whilst he invested in a farm to avoid IT is not lost.

Small businesses - The option was to do nothing and someone had to take the hit, it will be eased over the next four years and the direction of travel is to reduce the paperwork and therefore spend on those that export through closer ties with the EU.

The problem with messaging and optics is the lens you are looking through, Read the actual message and not just what the messenger wants you to hear.

And btw I am no longer a Labour Party member - I joined for one purpose and that was to get the crooks out of power and get someone in that will take away the hyperbole and bullshit and focus on getting the country steady again.

If you don’t think that news is being filtered before it gets to you then consider this. There have been around 6000 deportation of failed asylum seekers since the new government got in. You’d have thought that would have been headline news wouldn’t you?

Can you let us know when they start?
Reply
#83
Can’t have it both ways - it’s either miserable messaging that gives no one hope, or bullshit to make everyone feel like it’s better than it is.
Reply
#84
In comparison with France & Germany we're doing just fine. At least we have a government who were bold enough to raise taxes (even if they were the wrong taxes) and suggest, at least - that they might reform the pubic sector. And FPTP means at least we have a stable government unlike those poor deluded souls across the Channel.
Reply
#85
(12-09-2024, 08:33 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Can’t have it both ways - it’s either miserable messaging that gives no one hope, or bullshit to make everyone feel like it’s better than it is.

The link to the disability white paper doesn’t even address the fact some people cannot work and those that look after them work for next to nothing as carers. It’s an insult to unpaid carers that they should even be part of these plans and rhetoric the millions they save the country. They should be paid a proper living wage instead the government tinker around the edges of how much on top of the back breaking and exhausting caring duties a person can work.
Reply
#86
(12-09-2024, 08:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In comparison with France & Germany we're doing just fine. At least we have a government who were bold enough to raise taxes (even if they were the wrong taxes) and suggest, at least - that they might reform the pubic sector. And FPTP means at least we have a stable government unlike those poor deluded souls across the Channel.

 "They might reform the pubic sector."

I understand that reform of the pubic sector has been a thing for some time. Though not so much in France and Germany traditionally.
Reply
#87
(12-09-2024, 11:38 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-09-2024, 08:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In comparison with France & Germany we're doing just fine. At least we have a government who were bold enough to raise taxes (even if they were the wrong taxes) and suggest, at least - that they might reform the pubic sector. And FPTP means at least we have a stable government unlike those poor deluded souls across the Channel.

 "They might reform the pubic sector."

I understand that reform of the pubic sector has been a thing for some time. Though not so much in France and Germany traditionally.

I certainly reform mine every couple of weeks. #trim
Reply
#88
(12-09-2024, 11:38 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-09-2024, 08:39 PM)Protheroe Wrote: In comparison with France & Germany we're doing just fine. At least we have a government who were bold enough to raise taxes (even if they were the wrong taxes) and suggest, at least - that they might reform the pubic sector. And FPTP means at least we have a stable government unlike those poor deluded souls across the Channel.

 "They might reform the pubic sector."

I understand that reform of the pubic sector has been a thing for some time. Though not so much in France and Germany traditionally.

Arf.
Reply
#89
(12-09-2024, 03:45 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Using the ignore function on a debate forum is proper toys out of the pram stuff. This isn’t a teenage Instagram account

I would generally agree. But it is acceptable for exceptions to be made. I had that FF on ignore. Perfectly reasonable, by any assessment.

Not had anyone else on ignore. Even the Tories on here Big Grin
Reply
#90
(12-10-2024, 09:03 AM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-09-2024, 03:45 PM)tHEgLASSdOORS Wrote: Using the ignore function on a debate forum is proper toys out of the pram stuff. This isn’t a teenage Instagram account

I would generally agree. But it is acceptable for exceptions to be made. I had that FF on ignore. Perfectly reasonable, by any assessment.

Not had anyone else on ignore. Even the Tories on here Big Grin

I did too. I can handle disagreement, but not pointless inanity.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)