Posts: 9,625
Threads: 516
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
12-09-2024, 09:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2024, 09:29 PM by Lurker#3.)
(12-09-2024, 04:36 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Some interesting mind-sets emerging in this fred.
We all know SW4 loves a back 3/5 - probably as much as I hate it.
Lurker seems to think that Ajayi might be an answer - although many of us think that if Ajayi is the answer there's something wrong with the question But why have so many posters dismissed Holgate? He's been OK and it's very early to judge. Remember how much we liked Kipre to start with???
We probably all agree that Frabotta's inability to break through is giving us issues and preventing CC from trying Styles in centre midfield. That's if the notion ever occurred to CC of course. Frabotta at LB gives us more height at the back, allows Styles to challenge Mowatt and Molumby and leaves Bartley and Holgate to vie for the place alongside Heggem. Although I reckon there's time for Barts to have another injury this season, with his ongoing knee thing.
I disagree very strongly with Fido's "Fellows is not a wing back" stance. He has good defensive instincts IMO and is learning to throw his weight about a bit. Truly classy players can adapt to almost anything, and Fellows is truly classy.
I actually don't overly rate Semi. But compared to Holgate he's Sol Campbell
But in terms of pushing Styles into midfield we need another CB. And he's the lesser of two evils. Fwiw, it's got to be worth a look at Frabotta at LB with Stylesbin CM surely?
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 4,261
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
12-09-2024, 10:32 PM
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2024, 10:44 PM by Cheshire East Baggie.)
Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions
Posts: 7,724
Threads: 172
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation:
23
With Lurker here. Holgate is rubbish, was obvious 5 years ago with us. Obvious throughout his Everton tenure aside from 6 months under Ancelotti, obvious on BOTH of his loans last year, and easily the worst performer in our superbly coached defence, including the woeful Ajayi.
Posts: 9,625
Threads: 516
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
12-10-2024, 06:54 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2024, 06:56 AM by Lurker#3.)
(12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions 
The stats actually show both Semi and Holgate to be very competent  but that is very much down to the tactical set up CC uses.
Our defensive "output", so number of tackles, blocks and interceptions are some of the lowest in the league. Because our shape and structure doesn't out our players in the scenarios where they have to defend too often.
What we do have is a really high number of clearances. This is because we manage to opposition's possession into 'safe' wider/deeper areas and often make them play a low percentage final pass which our defenders clear away comfortably.
My issue is both Semi and Holgate read the game so poorly when they are required to make proper game based decisions. They never take up the right starting positions, they always seem to get dragged out of shape and they are always prone to playing a rash pass into a poor area.
Compare this to Bartley who rarely if ever makes a basic error.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
12-10-2024, 07:20 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2024, 07:21 AM by Sliced.)
(12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions 
I find it bizarre how you throw a hissy fit when others have valid opinions on players that you disagree with, but you have no problem shitting on the players that you don't rate. The fact is we've conceded less goals with Ajayi at CB than any other centre back because his pace gets us out of trouble when his other centre back partner makes a mistake which, lets face it, any one of our centre backs have a tendency to do.
(12-10-2024, 06:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions 
The stats actually show both Semi and Holgate to be very competent but that is very much down to the tactical set up CC uses.
Our defensive "output", so number of tackles, blocks and interceptions are some of the lowest in the league. Because our shape and structure doesn't out our players in the scenarios where they have to defend too often.
What we do have is a really high number of clearances. This is because we manage to opposition's possession into 'safe' wider/deeper areas and often make them play a low percentage final pass which our defenders clear away comfortably.
My issue is both Semi and Holgate read the game so poorly when they are required to make proper game based decisions. They never take up the right starting positions, they always seem to get dragged out of shape and they are always prone to playing a rash pass into a poor area.
Compare this to Bartley who rarely if ever makes a basic error.
Come on now.......
Posts: 9,648
Threads: 411
Joined: Aug 2024
Reputation:
33
(12-10-2024, 06:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions  Compare this to Bartley who rarely if ever makes a basic error. Oh, pack it in, lad
He's had a good season so far, but this is not correct at all!
Posts: 8,005
Threads: 188
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
37
(12-09-2024, 09:56 AM)Vinebaggie Wrote: Personally I'd stick with the team we started with yesterday, good attacking performance against the top-o-the-league team and we should have won. Hopefully this will be the settled side for what will be a critical period over Christmas.
Same. If we can avoid having a mad 5 minutes at the back, and some terrible luck, we'll win comfortably.
I have a question though, for the stattos, has Fellows ever won a penalty? I can't remember one, which is bizarre for one so tricky. Probably because he either goes down the line or cuts inside before he hits the penalty area. I'd be telling him run at the defenders in the box more, he would terrify a less mobile CH.
Posts: 8,846
Threads: 270
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(12-10-2024, 07:20 AM)Sliced Wrote: (12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions 
I find it bizarre how you throw a hissy fit when others have valid opinions on players that you disagree with, but you have no problem shitting on the players that you don't rate. The fact is we've conceded less goals with Ajayi at CB than any other centre back because his pace gets us out of trouble when his other centre back partner makes a mistake which, lets face it, any one of our centre backs have a tendency to do.
(12-10-2024, 06:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions 
The stats actually show both Semi and Holgate to be very competent but that is very much down to the tactical set up CC uses.
Our defensive "output", so number of tackles, blocks and interceptions are some of the lowest in the league. Because our shape and structure doesn't out our players in the scenarios where they have to defend too often.
What we do have is a really high number of clearances. This is because we manage to opposition's possession into 'safe' wider/deeper areas and often make them play a low percentage final pass which our defenders clear away comfortably.
My issue is both Semi and Holgate read the game so poorly when they are required to make proper game based decisions. They never take up the right starting positions, they always seem to get dragged out of shape and they are always prone to playing a rash pass into a poor area.
Compare this to Bartley who rarely if ever makes a basic error.
Come on now.......
+1
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Shockingly Lurker is once again spot on in his assessment of our defenders.
In terms of output and attributes Bartley is almost perfect for the way CC sets up a defence. Add to that the fact he seems to perform better with the added responsibility of being captain.
Posts: 9,625
Threads: 516
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
12-10-2024, 09:56 AM
(This post was last modified: 12-10-2024, 09:59 AM by Lurker#3.)
(12-10-2024, 08:01 AM)Josh1873 Wrote: (12-10-2024, 06:54 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (12-09-2024, 10:32 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Lurker you really are rushing to judgement about Holgate. Why do we do this with players?
"Compared to Holgate, Semi is Sol Campbell". That's brutal and way wide of the mark. I can barely think of a centre back who's played for us who would deserve that insult, apart from a very few complete misfits. I can't think of anyone who's played as many games for us at CB as Semi with so few of the basic skills required in that position. Maybe your stats-based view of the game distorts your opinions  Compare this to Bartley who rarely if ever makes a basic error. Oh, pack it in, lad 
He's had a good season so far, but this is not correct at all!
I haven't said he doesn't make errors. He just doesn't make many if any really basic, fundamental defensive mistakes.
9/10 he is in the right spot, makes the appropriate movements, marks his man effectively, heads things clear, makes sensible decisions when in possession.
All the basics for a defender that both Semi and Holgate don't do anywhere near consistently enough. Both of whom have much better "attributes" than Bart's. Semi has the physicality to be a top defender, Holgate has good agility and technical ability, but neither have a natural, high level defensive IQ.
"IMO of course..."
|