The cost of NIMBYism and obstructive planning in the energy sector
#41
(12-07-2024, 10:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: So what are you asking for? You live in a built up area with no space that you want redeveloped. You don’t want people to have to move out to the town outskirts? How would that be possible? And what numbers are you talking about?

Brown field sites should be used as a first option and no waahhh it’s too expensive. 

Town centres that will never recover to the size they once were should be reduced in size and politicians should stop pretending they can save the high street. 

Force through legislation large companies to either build/start work on land within twelve months of purchase instead of leaving land to rot for years. There are areas across the BC that have stood empty for years. Why is that land not utilised? 

Build proper new towns adjacent to rail and existing road links and ensure that those towns have the facilities to function properly. 

Avoid building on every patch of green space cuz it’s cheaper in built up areas that are already struggling to cope with traffic, lack of schools, local jobs etc. 

If you want Farage and co in charge then imposing thousands of cheap housing on already struggling communities whilst ignoring more difficult but less impactful options is the way to go. Labour are sleep walking into leaving the door open for them… their support in working class areas is wafer thin.
Reply
#42
If you simply don’t understand that there are nowhere near enough Brownfield sites to provide the housing required then there’s no point in you actually being part of the debate Dekka. Essentially we need to build a city the size of Leicester every year. You’re not going to do that building on urban infill, you need entirely new towns in high growth areas like Oxford-Cambridge, down the M40 and around London. If you don’t recognise that simple truth then there’s no hope for you.
Reply
#43
When we are in a position that me and Proth agree on something then you need to look at your view.

Here’s a good example - the government are getting praised by an industry specialist for building brownfield first, but it is 5k houses being talked about in a target of 1.5M. https://thenegotiator.co.uk/news/uk-hous...ing-drive/

I agree there should be a number of solutions but redeveloping towns and brownfield will not be the big wins needed here.
Reply
#44
Unlike Dekka I also happen to have built in the Black Country on sites that are ecologically dead and / or massively constrained by legacy & current infrastructure. There are limited uses for such sites and very little demand - and if you want them cleaned up you’re talking decades and £tens of millions with no likely ROI.

Everything easy had been brought forward for development 20 years ago or more. And if you’re only going to build housing on urban sites then where do all the warehouses, factories & offices go?
Reply
#45
I haven’t got your experience in this field Proth but the numbers simply don’t add up. The government needs to focus a limited source of funds in areas with the greatest return of houses.
Reply
#46
Absolutely. And they’ve all failed in this duty for 50 years.

The last site I built an industrial park on in Tipton had 9 mineshafts to cap, two pylons and power lines, a high pressure gas main, high levels of cadmium, lead & mercury & part of it was a fly ash tip. We had to pile the foundations for every building. We were constrained by the canal, a river and the Black Country New Road. Land value was MINUS £200,000 per acre for our appraisal.

You can’t build housing on sites like that. You can only build anything with massive public sector support which is simply not feasible these days.
Reply
#47
The average house price in fucking Sandwell is £215k. Do you seriously not grasp the scale of the housing crisis? Why are you talking like £180k-£350k is an anomaly?
Reply
#48
(12-07-2024, 10:59 AM)Protheroe Wrote: If you simply don’t understand that there are nowhere near enough Brownfield sites to provide the housing required then there’s no point in you actually being part of the debate Dekka. Essentially we need to build a city the size of Leicester every year. You’re not going to do that building on urban infill, you need entirely new towns in high growth areas like Oxford-Cambridge, down the M40 and around London. If you don’t recognise that simple truth then there’s no hope for you.

Milton Keynes? x8

I think Derek was saying we use every means available to us - not just brownfield sites.

The state needs to take the hit on cleaning up the sites that are so contaminated. They will stay there abandoned forever more otherwise.
Reply
#49
(12-07-2024, 01:00 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-07-2024, 10:59 AM)Protheroe Wrote: If you simply don’t understand that there are nowhere near enough Brownfield sites to provide the housing required then there’s no point in you actually being part of the debate Dekka. Essentially we need to build a city the size of Leicester every year. You’re not going to do that building on urban infill, you need entirely new towns in high growth areas like Oxford-Cambridge, down the M40 and around London. If you don’t recognise that simple truth then there’s no hope for you.

Milton Keynes? x8

I think Derek was saying we use every means available to us - not just brownfield sites.

The state needs to take the hit on cleaning up the sites that are so contaminated. They will stay there abandoned forever more otherwise.

Dekka has been very clear about what he doesn't want previously. He's the board's NIMBY in chief.

Why should the state clear up contaminated sites that will provide a negative ROI? There simply isn't the demand and never will be in many Northern towns & cities for housing or any other uses.
Reply
#50
(12-07-2024, 11:06 AM)baggy1 Wrote: When we are in a position that me and Proth agree on something then you need to look at your view.

When did I say only build on brownfield sites? 

With respect to you and Proth who by what I can guess from this site are comfortably well off and live in areas where you won’t be particularly adversely affected imposing thousands of homes on already struggling working class areas solves one problem and creates far more. Your example of a Dickens Heath summed up the gap between the areas I’m talking about and where you are at with this.

It’s an incredibly patronising way to think, and will open the door to Reform even further. ‘We know what’s best for you… and if you disagree we don’t care and what’s more we shall insult you by calling you nimbys.‘ Ring any bells with what happened with Brexit? 

Once upon a time governments had imagination and decided to build proper new towns, garden cities and villages with the amenities to support them. Now the thinking is cram as many cheaply built houses into as small a footprint as possible in poor areas whilst more affluent areas get the better, bigger and better designed estates and a new forest. 

Last point I’m not taking any lectures on NIMBYism or affordable houses from anyone who rents out second or third home…

(12-07-2024, 01:15 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(12-07-2024, 01:00 PM)man in the corner shop Wrote:
(12-07-2024, 10:59 AM)Protheroe Wrote: If you simply don’t understand that there are nowhere near enough Brownfield sites to provide the housing required then there’s no point in you actually being part of the debate Dekka. Essentially we need to build a city the size of Leicester every year. You’re not going to do that building on urban infill, you need entirely new towns in high growth areas like Oxford-Cambridge, down the M40 and around London. If you don’t recognise that simple truth then there’s no hope for you.

Milton Keynes? x8

I think Derek was saying we use every means available to us - not just brownfield sites.

The state needs to take the hit on cleaning up the sites that are so contaminated. They will stay there abandoned forever more otherwise.

Dekka has been very clear about what he doesn't want previously. He's the board's NIMBY in chief.

Why should the state clear up contaminated sites that will provide a negative ROI? There simply isn't the demand and never will be in many Northern towns & cities for housing or any other uses.

Stop putting words in my mouth… I have given a number of options even on this thread not just brownfield sites. You as is your level of imagination only want to go for the laziest, cheapest and most profitable options, you couldn’t careless how it affects the communities that already live in struggling areas and you offer absolutely no solutions. 

As I said I’m taking no lectures on a housing shortage from those who are profiting by renting out houses they clearly don’t currently need. They are and always have been part of the problem the bloody hypocrites.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)