Cleary
#11
(12-04-2024, 10:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I haven't seen enough of him to have a strong opinion but it seems to me that he has one attribute, he can finish, but little else to his game.

It's a great attribute but you can't carry a player at pro level just to have them on the pitch to finish.

He'll end up knocking around semi pro level scoring bags of goals but can't see him ever breaking through at pro level based on his career so far.

Can't we just bring him on for the last 10 to do a bit of goal hanging? None of our usual subs could finish their dinner!
Reply
#12
There was an article in the Express and Star the other week that said Walsall were happy with his progress at the club.

Maybe they see him as a longer term prospect, expecting to be able to sign him permanently at the end of the season.
Reply
#13
(12-04-2024, 10:32 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: There was an article in the Express and Star the other week that said Walsall were happy with his progress at the club.

Maybe they see him as a longer term prospect, expecting to be able to sign him permanently at the end of the season.

Let them have him on a free in January, with a sell-on clause.
Reply
#14
(12-04-2024, 10:32 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: There was an article in the Express and Star the other week that said Walsall were happy with his progress at the club.

Maybe they see him as a longer term prospect, expecting to be able to sign him permanently at the end of the season.

It wouldn't surprise me given they have persisted with the terminally useless Douglas James-Taylor despite him showing nothing in his original loan spell from Stoke or last season when they signed him permanently. They still gave him a new contract for another year though he has been loaned out to Ireland.
Reply
#15
I watch a lot of youth football and he’s the most natural finisher I’ve seen down here in a long time

We also have another couple of young strikers with promise so this season is very much make or break for him with us, shame he’s not featured more for Walsall however they’re flying and the jump up from kids to mens football is a chasm as we well now

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#16
(12-04-2024, 10:13 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-04-2024, 10:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I haven't seen enough of him to have a strong opinion but it seems to me that he has one attribute, he can finish, but little else to his game.

It's a great attribute but you can't carry a player at pro level just to have them on the pitch to finish.

He'll end up knocking around semi pro level scoring bags of goals but can't see him ever breaking through at pro level based on his career so far.

Can't we just bring him on for the last 10 to do a bit of goal hanging? None of our usual subs could finish their dinner!

We should.

I'm bored of saying it, we are way, way too cautious with youth, Cole shouldn't have been signed and Cleary or Faal should have had a chance to come off the bench and win games. Wallace coming on up front is even worse but another argument there.

The jump from youth to adult can only be done by playing senior football, there is no other way, and loans aren't always the best way for that. If there is even a half belief a player can make it, get them on the pitch now and then to show it.
Reply
#17
Oh, and fans need to accept young players take time, lots of it to be at first team standard, they'll.make.lots of mistakes and sometimes just seem hopeless, give them support.
Reply
#18
I agree with much of the above.

We should always have 3 emerging talents on the bench. With so many named subs it's the right thing for the club to do.

Having people like Callum Styles helps massively with his versatility as you have senior players capable of covering multiple positions.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#19
(12-04-2024, 11:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-04-2024, 10:13 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-04-2024, 10:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I haven't seen enough of him to have a strong opinion but it seems to me that he has one attribute, he can finish, but little else to his game.

It's a great attribute but you can't carry a player at pro level just to have them on the pitch to finish.

He'll end up knocking around semi pro level scoring bags of goals but can't see him ever breaking through at pro level based on his career so far.

Can't we just bring him on for the last 10 to do a bit of goal hanging? None of our usual subs could finish their dinner!

We should.

I'm bored of saying it, we are way, way too cautious with youth, Cole shouldn't have been signed and Cleary or Faal should have had a chance to come off the bench and win games. Wallace coming on up front is even worse but another argument there.

The jump from youth to adult can only be done by playing senior football, there is no other way, and loans aren't always the best way for that. If there is even a half belief a player can make it, get them on the pitch now and then to show it.

Exactly. Is he really worse than Marshall or Dobbin? I doubt that's even possible, yet they still got chances. I also doubt that either can match his scoring record at U21 level.
Seems we put more trust in younger players from other clubs than our own, at times.
Reply
#20
(12-04-2024, 11:52 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(12-04-2024, 10:13 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(12-04-2024, 10:09 AM)richbaggie Wrote: I haven't seen enough of him to have a strong opinion but it seems to me that he has one attribute, he can finish, but little else to his game.

It's a great attribute but you can't carry a player at pro level just to have them on the pitch to finish.

He'll end up knocking around semi pro level scoring bags of goals but can't see him ever breaking through at pro level based on his career so far.

Can't we just bring him on for the last 10 to do a bit of goal hanging? None of our usual subs could finish their dinner!

We should.

I'm bored of saying it, we are way, way too cautious with youth, Cole shouldn't have been signed and Cleary or Faal should have had a chance to come off the bench and win games. Wallace coming on up front is even worse but another argument there.

The jump from youth to adult can only be done by playing senior football, there is no other way, and loans aren't always the best way for that. If there is even a half belief a player can make it, get them on the pitch now and then to show it.

Interesting. I said back in April that I was very impressed with Faal with the appearances I'd seen of him at Walsall and he looked a good prospect. Your response - 'Nowhere near what we need'. So much for fans needing to show patience with young players as you state. Happy to bump the thread to remind you. Now apparently these players should be playing for our first team! You completely contradict yourself at times.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: