Football making political statements thoughts?
#1
I know a lot has been said over the years about James McClean and his relationship with the poppy, but just wondering the thoughts of the board regarding social/ political statements that seem to pressurise footballers.
At the weekend Ipswich’s Sam Morsey refused on religious grounds to wear a rainbow armband as it was some LGBTQ sort of weekend.
I noted that watching Match of the Day as they mentioned this symbol of tolerance and equality on both Saturday and Sunday, just as they do every week for years when players take the knee.
Personally I think we are in a country liberal and accepting enough that there’s no need for these forced symbols. Of course you’ll find exceptions to the contrary if you look for them, but not sure that after years of gay marriage and strong anti racial laws that forcing players into making them partake in some symbolic gesture is particularly wise and does encroach a bit on liberty. 
It’s a little bit of a prickly subject but just wonder am I in the minority as there seems to be so much more of this kind of thinking pushed into football now.
Reply
#2
(12-02-2024, 10:38 PM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote: I know a lot has been said over the years about James McClean and his relationship with the poppy, but just wondering the thoughts of the board regarding social/ political statements that seem to pressurise footballers.
At the weekend Ipswich’s Sam Morsey refused on religious grounds to wear a rainbow armband as it was some LGBTQ sort of weekend.
I noted that watching Match of the Day as they mentioned this symbol of tolerance and equality on both Saturday and Sunday, just as they do every week for years when players take the knee.
Personally I think we are in a country liberal and accepting enough that there’s no need for these forced symbols. Of course you’ll find exceptions to the contrary if you look for them, but not sure that after years of gay marriage and strong anti racial laws that forcing players into making them partake in some symbolic gesture is particularly wise and does encroach a bit on liberty. 
It’s a little bit of a prickly subject but just wonder am I in the minority as there seems to be so much more of this kind of thinking pushed into football now.

Totally agree.
Reply
#3
Ultimately no football or employee anywhere should be forced into making political statements they don't agree with.
Reply
#4
He can do what he wants which he did, I'm going to call him a homophobic prick though because I'm allowed to.
Reply
#5
(12-02-2024, 11:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: He can do what he wants which he did, I'm going to call him a homophobic prick though because I'm allowed to.

But here’s the point, why should he be forced into being placed into a position where his views on homosexuality has to be put under a spotlight where you come to this conclusion.
Also he’s from a country not as liberal as we are in the west. Who knows what grief he might have got in Egypt when he returns there for international matches.
The problem is the liberal west expects the rest of the world to accept as read the way they are so liberal now, but not every country has the collective mindset to accept such rapid change.
We’ve actually seen this in America and made it a very divided country.
The way we seem over the top championing things now for a minority in a public way just doesn’t sit well with me.
I’ve gay people in my family. I’ve relations who have married across colour and cultural boundaries but I don’t feel the need to wave a multicoloured flag or get on one knee when I see my relations of beyond these boundaries. I just talk to them like equals as I’m not compelled to upset them by making a quip about life in the jungle or telling them I wouldn’t like to pick up the soap in a shower besides them. It’s because it’s not 1974.
I think 99.99 percent of people are the same. 
When I meet these people they are just John or Chris- not gay John or black Chris. 
I really don’t like the politicising where guys like McClean or Morsy are pushed into such corners when their job is just to play football.
Where does being a gay advocate fit into the footballer narrative and why do we have to have a special weekend with some multicoloured flag to show consenting adults it’s ok to sleep together with someone of your gender just because the vast majority aren’t of your orientation.
I’d like to think I would refuse to take part in taking the knee, rainbow flag stuff and poppies for all the above reasons.
Reply
#6
(12-03-2024, 04:23 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(12-02-2024, 11:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: He can do what he wants which he did, I'm going to call him a homophobic prick though because I'm allowed to.

But here’s the point, why should he be forced into being placed into a position where his views on homosexuality has to be put under a spotlight where you come to this conclusion.
Also he’s from a country not as liberal as we are in the west. Who knows what grief he might have got in Egypt when he returns there for international matches.
The problem is the liberal west expects the rest of the world to accept as read the way they are so liberal now, but not every country has the collective mindset to accept such rapid change.
We’ve actually seen this in America and made it a very divided country.
The way we seem over the top championing things now for a minority in a public way just doesn’t sit well with me.
I’ve gay people in my family. I’ve relations who have married across colour and cultural boundaries but I don’t feel the need to wave a multicoloured flag or get on one knee when I see my relations of beyond these boundaries. I just talk to them like equals as I’m not compelled to upset them by making a quip about life in the jungle or telling them I wouldn’t like to pick up the soap in a shower besides them. It’s because it’s not 1974.
I think 99.99 percent of people are the same. 
When I meet these people they are just John or Chris- not gay John or black Chris. 
I really don’t like the politicising where guys like McClean or Morsy are pushed into such corners when their job is just to play football.
Where does being a gay advocate fit into the footballer narrative and why do we have to have a special weekend with some multicoloured flag to show consenting adults it’s ok to sleep together with someone of your gender just because the vast majority aren’t of your orientation.
I’d like to think I would refuse to take part in taking the knee, rainbow flag stuff and poppies for all the above reasons.

I agree with most of what you’ve written, except for the poppy. The poppy has only recently become (in the eyes of some), a political statement. For me it’s simply a way to honour the fallen, who paid the ultimate sacrifice for the freedoms we enjoy today. I too would not take the knee, or wear a rainbow. But this does not make me a racist or a homophobe.
Reply
#7
(12-03-2024, 04:23 AM)PatelsPlatoon Wrote:
(12-02-2024, 11:23 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: He can do what he wants which he did, I'm going to call him a homophobic prick though because I'm allowed to.

But here’s the point, why should he be forced into being placed into a position where his views on homosexuality has to be put under a spotlight where you come to this conclusion.
Also he’s from a country not as liberal as we are in the west. Who knows what grief he might have got in Egypt when he returns there for international matches.
The problem is the liberal west expects the rest of the world to accept as read the way they are so liberal now, but not every country has the collective mindset to accept such rapid change.
We’ve actually seen this in America and made it a very divided country.
The way we seem over the top championing things now for a minority in a public way just doesn’t sit well with me.
I’ve gay people in my family. I’ve relations who have married across colour and cultural boundaries but I don’t feel the need to wave a multicoloured flag or get on one knee when I see my relations of beyond these boundaries. I just talk to them like equals as I’m not compelled to upset them by making a quip about life in the jungle or telling them I wouldn’t like to pick up the soap in a shower besides them. It’s because it’s not 1974.
I think 99.99 percent of people are the same. 
When I meet these people they are just John or Chris- not gay John or black Chris. 
I really don’t like the politicising where guys like McClean or Morsy are pushed into such corners when their job is just to play football.
Where does being a gay advocate fit into the footballer narrative and why do we have to have a special weekend with some multicoloured flag to show consenting adults it’s ok to sleep together with someone of your gender just because the vast majority aren’t of your orientation.
I’d like to think I would refuse to take part in taking the knee, rainbow flag stuff and poppies for all the above reasons.

Statements like this show why there is still a need for this sort of thing…. Until such a time that everyone sees them AS equals, there is work to do.

Sam Morsy was born in the UK, over 30 years ago. If he is still so homophobic as to refuse to wear a symbol that promotes the equality of all peoples based on a storybook and a fear of upsetting his Twitter followers in some backward hell hole in the Middle East he should be called out for it. As Borin’ Baggie says, he can choose to reject the rainbow armband if he wishes, but he has to then live with the fact he’s a homophobic cunt.

It’s a dangerous precedent to compare one rainbow armbands or taking the knee with the poppy - two are about promoting equality and raising awareness that certain minorities still have to live in a way with fewer rights, privileges and transparency than others. The poppy commemorates an army that has committed atrocities against certain peoples in the past.
Reply
#8
If any cunt tries to make me wear an armband to support kids who think their cats they can fuck off
Reply
#9
I was going to post about this to see what peoples thoughts were, good work.

My opinion FWIW. He doesn't haven't to wear the arm band, but Ipswich should have released a statement saying that on that day Morsy would not be captain, they could have explained that they stand by his rights to not support the campaign on the grounds of his religious beliefs, but his views did not represent what the club stands for.

Simple solution and everybody would have been satisfied.
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#10
(12-03-2024, 06:57 AM)Baggies_Tel Wrote: If any cunt tries to make me wear an armband to support kids who think their cats they can fuck off

Big Grin
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)