Corberán record.
#21
(12-01-2024, 11:28 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Jacko my man, are you telling me that 12 points out of a possible 42 is anything other than relegation form? Or maybe you're confident that Carlos will find a way to end this nightmare run of extreme tedium and crushing disappointment? Are you seeing signs of improvement that are somehow invisible to humans?

As Henry Ford said, history is bunk. CC is judged on what he's doing now and where it's perceived (by Shilen Patel) to be heading. Your constant efforts to make excuses after each winnable match turns into a bore-draw can't change the FACTS - which are that we are in a mess which Carlos seems unable to get out of.

Two wins in the next two matches buys him the rest of the season. Two defeats and I reckon he's gone before Christmas. Two draws in arguably winnable home matches? Then I guess we'll find out what Mr Patel is made of. Tough decision for him.

Bad luck with injuries, lack of quality in the squad, poor form from the players etc etc. None of these excuses can hide the fact that Carlos is floundering. He needs to get a grip. We all want him to succeed, but when do we finally accept that it isn't going to happen?

If you are going to home in on “12 points out of 42”, are you also going to ignore the “16 points out of 18” which immediately preceded it?  The fact is that we are 7th in the league at the start of December. That’s the more important stat.  It only takes a slight upturn to put us back into the playoffs 

CC has earned far more credit over the last 18 months than you’re prepared to give him. After the summer squad turnover we are about where we should be either the current squad.  

Fortunately I don’t believe that Patel will be trigger-happy and rightly so.  Be very careful what you wish for.
Reply
#22
(12-01-2024, 11:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 10:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 10:11 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 09:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 09:53 PM)Jacko Wrote: Agreed hard to compare him to any you have mentioned because they all have riches/resources beyond his dreams. Thanks for enforcing the original point.

You have proven one thing he’s better than Val and Bruce the rest are not comparable for a variety of reasons. Thanks for stating the bleeding obvious.

He's got a better record than all but 1 manager in the history of our club and has spent just less than £4 million.

I'll give the Championship records of our Parachute managers tomorrow.

Your stat is meaningless… you’re comparing managers records in different eras, this ranges from the club not being able to afford to feed the team breakfast and training on a patch of land next to the old club offices on the Halfords Lane, whilst losing £30k a week, to an era where had more money than the rest of the Chsmpionship and everything in between. Not to mention ignoring the variables of the quality of the leagues over the same 25yrs. 

The only two manager you can possibly compare CC to is Bruce and Val and even then the  comparisons are difficult given every season is different.

Beyond me why clubs keep these records then. Pull the other one mate. Anyone above 40% win rate is very good irrespective of era/situation. To be nearly 50% with no money is incredible.

They keep them for historical records not to compare a manager from 1995 against one in 2024. If you pick promotion as an indicator CC is on a par with Brian Little with us… without context these comparison stats are meaningless.
Reply
#23
(12-01-2024, 11:28 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Jacko my man, are you telling me that 12 points out of a possible 42 is anything other than relegation form? Or maybe you're confident that Carlos will find a way to end this nightmare run of extreme tedium and crushing disappointment? Are you seeing signs of improvement that are somehow invisible to humans?

As Henry Ford said, history is bunk. CC is judged on what he's doing now and where it's perceived (by Shilen Patel) to be heading. Your constant efforts to make excuses after each winnable match turns into a bore-draw can't change the FACTS - which are that we are in a mess which Carlos seems unable to get out of.

Two wins in the next two matches buys him the rest of the season. Two defeats and I reckon he's gone before Christmas. Two draws in arguably winnable home matches? Then I guess we'll find out what Mr Patel is made of. Tough decision for him.

Bad luck with injuries, lack of quality in the squad, poor form from the players etc etc. None of these excuses can hide the fact that Carlos is floundering. He needs to get a grip. We all want him to succeed, but when do we finally accept that it isn't going to happen?

Which team has won 12 points out of a possible 42 then, because it isn't us.  Our last 14 games have yielded 18 points, which on a points per game basis is certainly not relegation for.  Or is it that you accidentally included our wins against Plymouth and Portsmouth (this is what actual selective use of stats looks like) and you meant to judge Corberan on 12 games instead of 14?
Reply
#24
(12-02-2024, 07:13 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 11:04 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 10:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 10:11 PM)Jacko Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 09:59 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: You have proven one thing he’s better than Val and Bruce the rest are not comparable for a variety of reasons. Thanks for stating the bleeding obvious.

He's got a better record than all but 1 manager in the history of our club and has spent just less than £4 million.

I'll give the Championship records of our Parachute managers tomorrow.

Your stat is meaningless… you’re comparing managers records in different eras, this ranges from the club not being able to afford to feed the team breakfast and training on a patch of land next to the old club offices on the Halfords Lane, whilst losing £30k a week, to an era where had more money than the rest of the Chsmpionship and everything in between. Not to mention ignoring the variables of the quality of the leagues over the same 25yrs. 

The only two manager you can possibly compare CC to is Bruce and Val and even then the  comparisons are difficult given every season is different.

Beyond me why clubs keep these records then. Pull the other one mate. Anyone above 40% win rate is very good irrespective of era/situation. To be nearly 50% with no money is incredible.

They keep them for historical records not to compare a manager from 1995 against one in 2024. If you pick promotion as an indicator CC is on a par with Brian Little with us… without context these comparison stats are meaningless.
Rubbish comparison. Brian Little had us at the other end of the table.
Reply
#25
(12-02-2024, 07:53 AM)George Stagefright Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 11:28 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Jacko my man, are you telling me that 12 points out of a possible 42 is anything other than relegation form? Or maybe you're confident that Carlos will find a way to end this nightmare run of extreme tedium and crushing disappointment? Are you seeing signs of improvement that are somehow invisible to humans?

As Henry Ford said, history is bunk. CC is judged on what he's doing now and where it's perceived (by Shilen Patel) to be heading. Your constant efforts to make excuses after each winnable match turns into a bore-draw can't change the FACTS - which are that we are in a mess which Carlos seems unable to get out of.

Two wins in the next two matches buys him the rest of the season. Two defeats and I reckon he's gone before Christmas. Two draws in arguably winnable home matches? Then I guess we'll find out what Mr Patel is made of. Tough decision for him.

Bad luck with injuries, lack of quality in the squad, poor form from the players etc etc. None of these excuses can hide the fact that Carlos is floundering. He needs to get a grip. We all want him to succeed, but when do we finally accept that it isn't going to happen?

Which team has won 12 points out of a possible 42 then, because it isn't us.  Our last 14 games have yielded 18 points, which on a points per game basis is certainly not relegation for.  Or is it that you accidentally included our wins against Plymouth and Portsmouth (this is what actual selective use of stats looks like) and you meant to judge Corberan on 12 games instead of 14?

OK, my bad. All those Maths A levels didn't help me at all. It sounds so much better when you say we've got 12 points from the last potential 36. Do that for a whole season and finish on 38 points. What could possibly go wrong?

Big questions are can he return to winning ways and when?
Reply
#26
(12-02-2024, 09:33 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(12-02-2024, 07:53 AM)George Stagefright Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 11:28 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: Jacko my man, are you telling me that 12 points out of a possible 42 is anything other than relegation form? Or maybe you're confident that Carlos will find a way to end this nightmare run of extreme tedium and crushing disappointment? Are you seeing signs of improvement that are somehow invisible to humans?

As Henry Ford said, history is bunk. CC is judged on what he's doing now and where it's perceived (by Shilen Patel) to be heading. Your constant efforts to make excuses after each winnable match turns into a bore-draw can't change the FACTS - which are that we are in a mess which Carlos seems unable to get out of.

Two wins in the next two matches buys him the rest of the season. Two defeats and I reckon he's gone before Christmas. Two draws in arguably winnable home matches? Then I guess we'll find out what Mr Patel is made of. Tough decision for him.

Bad luck with injuries, lack of quality in the squad, poor form from the players etc etc. None of these excuses can hide the fact that Carlos is floundering. He needs to get a grip. We all want him to succeed, but when do we finally accept that it isn't going to happen?

Which team has won 12 points out of a possible 42 then, because it isn't us.  Our last 14 games have yielded 18 points, which on a points per game basis is certainly not relegation for.  Or is it that you accidentally included our wins against Plymouth and Portsmouth (this is what actual selective use of stats looks like) and you meant to judge Corberan on 12 games instead of 14?

OK, my bad. All those Maths A levels didn't help me at all. It sounds so much better when you say we've got 12 points from the last potential 36. Do that for a whole season and finish on 38 points. What could possibly go wrong?

Big questions are can he return to winning ways and when?
Chesh, you're having a mare here. Step away from the maths...
Reply
#27
Whether we want CC to stay, or not, is irrelevant, the truth is, there will come a point where it's untenable.
Sheff Utd are the best team in the division, so defeat should not be a shock and a draw would be a great result, so he should not be judged on that. Frank Lampard's Coventry could be a different issue though.

Personally, I think he will get the upturn he needs. One thing he's not is stupid, he will be aware of the situation, and the fans' reaction, and I expect to see a bit more aggression, especially at home. Which is the other important point, we are still second in the away form table, which is the hardest one to get right, if, therefore, we can improve at home, whilst maintaining the away form, we will see an immediate rise back up the table.

Sunday will be tough, but, if we can get a win, everything will start to look a bit more positive.
Reply
#28
Good summary BF.
Reply
#29
Am I going mad here? But I genuinely don't see the need for panic or the doom and gloom. We're 7th and still right in the play-off mix. League position wise we're exactly where I expect us to be.

Yes, the recent run of draws is borderline unacceptable, and it needs arresting ASAP. Certain players need to pull their finger out and play to their ability, which they're currently not, and CC has to manage his in-game decisions/tactics/subs better than he currently is. However, it needs tweaking and a bit of good fortune, it doesn't need a complete overhaul in what we're doing, we are not far away at all. We're still a good team that is difficult to beat. I take great comfort in that.

Again, I am not defending the long run of draws, but the draws away to Sunderland and Preston are not to be sniffed at in isolation. They're perfectly acceptable. It just so happens that they've come when we're on a poor run so they're over analysed and the results aren't shown the respect they deserve.

Yes, it's not perfect, and I am as frustrated as anyone, but calls to sack CC are ridiculous, perspective and level heads are needed. The way some people are carrying on you'd think we were in the bottom 3 and heading towards League 1!

It's not that bad. Improvement is needed, yes, but there is plenty to be hopeful and positive about.
Reply
#30
I don't get half of these arguments.

Corberan has done a good job as manager since he got here, and then in the past 12 games or so we've not been as good as we should be.

Is anyone honestly trying to claim anything else with a straight face?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: