For Albion fans wanting Carlos sacked.
#21
All the above.. sensible comments.
What I will add is that watching motd I too noticed the speed of attack of teams like Bournemouth getting players up the field.
When we get into attacking positions (and we do) there's rarely more than one player in the box.
I know that PL players are better than ours. But do they have to be quicker, with more stamina?
Reply
#22
For me I’m totally behind Carlos he still has plenty in the bank. Just wish he could get the players playing with a bit more intensity, like at the beginning of the season.
He did the wrong thing yesterday in switching Heggem from centre half. I can see why he did it with Styles lack of height, but you would never see Atkinson doing that to Statham and he wasn’t the tallest. I would have faith that Styles has the intelligence to find a way to cope.As for Dobbin send his back.
Reply
#23
(12-01-2024, 11:06 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 11:01 AM)aj21 Wrote: Agree with Rich that central midfield is our biggest problem, Mowatt started the season like Xavi but he’s regressed to the mean now and we don’t have any attacking instinct in the middle of the pitch. I’d love to see young Whitwell given a go as currently it’s just not working.

I would chance Whitwell too. We lack midfielders that can get the ball out of their feet quickly and play on the turn. Whitwell does this really well. Got an eye for a goal too.
I was dead against it but now I am 100% for - we are best in a 4411 and Whitwell is looking the best bet for the no 10 role.
Reply
#24
I was quite dejected leaving the ground yesterday. It started to feel like he was trying to get us out of this run by out thinking himself. The change of formation second half was bemusing. I know Keane coming in made a difference but instead of sticking to our game and pressing them into mistakes, we changed the formation and dropped deep.

The issue for me is a near constant reaction to what the opposition is doing over the qualities we have. This isn’t naive m, of course we need to react to changes in certain ways, but we could’ve been 3 nil up at HT. Instead of pushing for the second and playing how we’d found benefit in the first half, we changed and it cost us.

He’s overthinking and tinkering, that is a worrying sign.
Reply
#25
I got back late last night, took one look at the hysteria on the bored and decided another drunken, insulting rant was probably not required. Somewhat pleasantly surprised to see sanity return a day later. I might be branded a happy clapper (although to be anything else is surely self fulfilling), but is it so bad? I see people mention flowing football on MOTD but please remember they are the highlights. I actually thoroughly enjoyed the Sunderland game, we went to a difficult place and stifled them meanwhile creating the best 2 chances of the game. I want to see us competitive and hard to beat. We are. I want to see us get past the inherited P and S issues, we are doing that. What I expect further is more turnaround of the squad, let's see what January brings. If we can overcome the mis-management that has plagued us, within an 18 month period, we'll have achieved IMO.
Last summer it was unanimous on here this was a season of treading water, a period of transition. What on earth has changed to raise the bar? That's not to say I'm loving the whole thing. The subs for me are the biggest frustration. All in all though, what exactly IS good enough? For me we finish between 4th and 8th and that is progress.
Reply
#26
(12-01-2024, 12:20 PM)wba13 Wrote: For me I’m totally behind Carlos he still has plenty in the bank. Just wish he could get the players playing with a bit more intensity, like at the beginning of the season.
He did the wrong thing yesterday in switching Heggem from centre half. I can see why he did it with Styles lack of height, but you would never see Atkinson doing that to Statham and he wasn’t the tallest. I would have faith that Styles has the intelligence to find a way to cope.As for Dobbin send his back.

Agree on all points.

(12-01-2024, 10:56 AM)richbaggie Wrote:
(12-01-2024, 10:38 AM)Stillclem4england Wrote: Rich - are you of the opinion the squad is top six or pretty ordinary? I find myself thinking the latter - some fans think we have a divine right to beat Norwich, Millwall, Preston, Hull etc when in reality most teams in this league have two or three half decent players and the rest are mediocre Champ players and, on their day if the stars align and everyone performs, any team can beat any other. The top three or four are ordinary but better than us. Boro showed that as did the respect we gave Leeds and Sunderland. The way we played suggested that Carlos thinks man for man they are better than us and I would agree.

We have all creative players bar Tom out of form and have done for three months, however this does not excuse poor selections, not moving the hall quickly enough, shit subs and terrible set pieces.

I think it's pretty average. Well stocked in some areas, badly lacking in others. I think the way Grant is lauded this season sums it up. That's not knocking the lad as he's busting a gut for us but he's still an average player.

This is the poorest midfield in a long time. This for me is the biggest issue. Another player we have lauded is Mowatt and he's our best midfielder. He's a good tidy player but he's not a player that will consistently provide a bit of magic, drive us box to box or take control.

The division is full of average teams and average players. We should have enough to get play offs but I always thought it was going to be a difficult up and down season as we go through financial pain.
Totally agree with all of that Rich. And your KG point is interesting: a guy on the Liquidator podcast said the same after Norwich or Sunderland and thought it was fair.
Reply
#27
Just think that this team with a change of manager could easily slip into the bottom six category.Hull are very much an example and this League is full of mediocre teams who can beat each other.By all means we could roll the dice and appoint a new manager but there is no guarantee which way it could turn out.
Reply
#28
Very sensible and sober posts on this thread. 
I'd rather use funds to reinforce the squad in January than waste money replacing the coaching management (we probably don't have any though). 
I do wish he would try Whitwell and Cole rather than Wallace and Dobbin. 
A lot of people seem to have forgotten how good we were against a free scoring Norwich not so many games ago. 
Agree entirely about keeping Heggam in the middle and playing Styles.
Reply
#29
(12-01-2024, 12:59 PM)Huggybear Wrote: Just think that this team with a change of manager could easily slip into the bottom six category.Hull are very much an example and this League is full of mediocre teams who can beat each other.By all means we could roll the dice and appoint a new manager but there is no guarantee which way it could turn out.

Agree. Man for man Hull are at best slightly weaker than us. Ditto Cov.
Reply
#30
(12-01-2024, 11:26 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: It’s a bit of moot point if results don’t improve. The owner isn’t going to allow us to drift into bottom half Championship mediocrity on the premise we hope things improve based on past performances.

My opinion is the squad is decent for the Championship certainly for 5th and 6th play-off spots. Even if it’s 8,9, 10th best what are we saying? That a coach / managers input is so neutral as to have no effect on results be they positive or negative?

Is correct. Like most fans, I think Carlos deserves time, but the reality is that if we start to dip below mid table, he will be sacked, especially if it looks like he's lost the players.

Considering how volatile football is and how a manager can completely lose a dressing room overnight, our owners (who I believe to be savvy people), should have accounted for this.

We aren't at that point yet, but there's no point pretending that it couldn't or shouldn't happen.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: